Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania House Bill HB1289

Introduced
6/1/23  
Refer
6/1/23  
Refer
6/21/23  
Report Pass
6/27/23  
Refer
6/27/23  
Report Pass
6/28/23  
Engrossed
6/28/23  
Refer
7/20/23  
Enrolled
12/14/23  
Chaptered
12/14/23  

Caption

In residential real property, providing for repudiation of discriminatory real estate covenants.

Impact

The bill will have a transformative impact on state laws regarding property rights and discriminatory practices in real estate. It will nullify existing unlawful restrictive covenants and provide a clear process for property owners to remove such restrictions from their deeds. This change reinforces the principle that discriminatory practices in housing are not valid and allows for increased equity in housing opportunities. Furthermore, it promotes compliance with the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act and indicates a legislative commitment to combat discrimination in housing.

Summary

House Bill 1289 addresses the issue of discriminatory restrictive real estate covenants in Pennsylvania. It aims to amend Title 68 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes by adding provisions that provide mechanisms for the nullification and repudiation of such covenants. These measures intend to empower property owners by allowing them to formally discharge these unlawful restrictions from their property titles without further need for legal action, thus fulfilling a significant legal gap in handling historical and discriminatory policies in real estate ownership.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around HB 1289 has been overwhelmingly positive among legislative supporters, who view the bill as a critical step forward in addressing and rectifying historical discrimination in real estate practices. Advocates for housing equality have praised the bill, emphasizing its potential to create fairer opportunities for diverse communities. However, there may be some contention regarding the practical implications of enforcing these changes and how they may affect existing property ownership dynamics.

Contention

Notable points of contention include concerns over the potential pushback from property associations and others who may hold interests in enforcing existing covenants. There is also discussion about the bill's implementation, particularly the processes involved in filing for covenant repudiation and the administrative burden this may place on local recorders. Ensuring that historically marginalized communities are fully aware of their rights under this new law is also a critical concern, as increased access to these avenues for justice relies on education and outreach.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

MN SF559

Certain restrictive covenants removal fees prohibition

CA AB1466

Real property: discriminatory restrictions.

WI SB439

Declaring discriminatory restrictions in instruments that affect real property void and unenforceable and allowing an owner of real property to discharge and release such a discriminatory restriction. (FE)

WI AB444

Declaring discriminatory restrictions in instruments that affect real property void and unenforceable and allowing an owner of real property to discharge and release such a discriminatory restriction. (FE)

MN SF1371

Certain affordable housing covenants exemption on real property from 30-year restriction

MN HF2055

Affordable housing covenants on real property exempted from 30-year restriction.

NM HB114

Ban Discriminatory Restrictive Covenants

NM SB286

Discriminatory Restrictive Covenants