Pennsylvania House Bill HB1902

Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 12/11/23
• Refer: 12/11/23

Caption

In procedure, further providing for exceptions for public records.

Impact

The revisions proposed in HB1902 would affect state laws regarding public records by introducing specific exemptions that could limit access to some types of information. This reflects an ongoing legislative effort to navigate the delicate tension between the public's right to know and the need for certain confidentiality in governmental functions. This bill may lead to a reevaluation of what constitutes public information and could set precedents for future legislation regarding transparency and data protection in the state.

Summary

House Bill 1902 aims to amend current legislation concerning public records by providing new exceptions. The bill seeks to balance the need for transparency in government operations with the necessity to protect certain sensitive information from public disclosure. This reform is critical in ensuring that citizens have access to relevant data while safeguarding important privacy concerns. The adjustments proposed in HB1902 could significantly impact how information is managed and disseminated by state agencies, possibly leading to a more efficient records management system.

Sentiment

The sentiment around HB1902 appears to be mixed, with stakeholders expressing both support and concern. Proponents argue that the bill is necessary to modernize public records laws and protect sensitive information that, if disclosed, could harm individuals or the state. Critics, however, worry that the new exceptions may be too broad, potentially allowing for excessive withholding of information that should be available to the public. This division reflects a broader debate over the principles of transparency and accountability in government.

Contention

Notable points of contention in discussions surrounding HB1902 include concerns about the scope of the new exceptions being proposed and their potential implications for public scrutiny of government actions. Opponents fear that the bill might undermine the spirit of transparency by creating loopholes that could be exploited to deny access to public records. Balancing public access with privacy rights will be a key focus in ongoing discussions about the bill, showcasing the challenges lawmakers face in crafting effective legislation.