Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania House Bill HB2111

Introduced
3/14/24  

Caption

In miscellaneous provisions, providing for bag usage.

Impact

The introduction of HB 2111 is expected to significantly influence how states deal with initiatives aimed at reducing plastic waste and encouraging environmentally friendly practices. By establishing a single framework for bag usage, the bill aims to prevent a patchwork of local regulations, which can complicate business operations and compliance efforts. However, its passage may limit local governments' abilities to tailor regulations to specific needs of their communities, particularly in urban areas heavily affected by pollution and plastic waste.

Summary

House Bill 2111 aims to address the use of bags in various locales by setting provisions concerning the regulation of bag usage across the state. Its primary focus is to streamline regulations rather than allowing individual municipalities to enact varied rules regarding bag types and usage. Supporters of this bill argue that having a uniform standard will help local businesses by reducing confusion and complexity in compliance while also enhancing consumer awareness around sustainable options like reusable bags.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 2111 appears mixed. Proponents view it as a necessary step towards sustainability and economic efficiency, supporting local businesses by creating a clear set of expectations regarding bag usage. Conversely, critics, including local environmental advocates and community leaders, express concerns that the bill undermines local efforts to promote environmentally responsible behavior tailored to community-specific needs. This divergence in opinion reflects broader tensions between state regulatory frameworks and local governance responsibilities.

Contention

A key point of contention surrounding HB 2111 is the extent to which state law should supersede local regulations aimed at controlling bag usage. Opponents argue that local initiatives related to environmental responsibility are best suited to address unique community challenges, while supporters of the bill emphasize the necessity of a unified approach to avoid confusion and needless complications for businesses operating in multiple jurisdictions. The ongoing debate highlights the struggle between efficiency and local governance autonomy.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA SB1053

Solid waste: recycled paper bags: standards: carryout bag prohibition.

PA AB2236

Solid waste: recycled paper bags: standards: carryout bag prohibition.

PA HB1293

Concerning litter.

PA HB1471

To eliminate single-use plastic carry-out bags.

PA SB155

Prohibits certain uses of single-use plastic bags. (1/1/24)

PA A4029

Allows stores, and certain other establishments, to provide and sell compostable plastic bags and recycled paper bags to customers.

PA SB249

Relating To Single-use Plastics.

PA S3114

Eliminates prohibition on paper bags, and allows packaging options, for certain grocery orders for three years; requires program for disposition of reusable bags; extends timeframe for use of certain bags by food banks and pantries.

PA SB00226

An Act Concerning Single-use Carryout Bags.

PA S239

Eliminates prohibition on paper bags, and allows packaging options, for certain grocery orders for three years; requires program for disposition of reusable bags; extends timeframe for use of certain bags by food banks and pantries.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.