Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB1140

Introduced
4/5/24  

Caption

In railroads, providing for fiber optic broadband line railroad crossing.

Impact

The legislation is expected to significantly impact state laws governing public utilities, particularly in terms of how broadband infrastructure can be deployed. By mandating that railroad companies review and approve crossing applications under specific guidelines and timelines, SB1140 aims to remove potential roadblocks that could delay broadband expansion. Nonetheless, the bill also puts the onus of responsibility on the broadband service providers for both the costs and planning associated with these crossings, potentially raising concerns about the financial feasibility for smaller providers or projects that are less capitalized.

Summary

Senate Bill 1140 aims to amend Title 66 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes by establishing provisions surrounding the crossing of railroad tracks by fiber optic broadband lines. The bill intends to facilitate the construction of broadband systems by requiring broadband service providers to submit applications for crossings to the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission. This legislation is part of a broader effort to enhance broadband accessibility across the state by streamlining the process of obtaining necessary permissions from railroad companies when laying down infrastructure that crosses railroad properties.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB1140 appears to be generally positive, particularly among proponents of increased broadband access. Legislators supporting the bill argue that by simplifying the approval process, it will accelerate broadband deployment, which is crucial for closing the digital divide in underserved areas. However, some stakeholders have expressed caution regarding the implications for railroad companies, who might face challenges related to disruptions their operations or added liabilities during construction. Therefore, the support for the bill comes with recognition of the need for careful implementation to balance the interests involved.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the responsibilities imposed on broadband providers and the potential for disputes between service providers and railroad companies. While the bill aims to facilitate the crossing process, it also opens the door for issues related to the coordination of construction schedules and safety management. Additionally, the provision requiring the railroad company to demonstrate undue hardship to delay crossings might lead to conflicts if both parties have differing views on what constitutes a hardship, highlighting the critical need for clear frameworks to handle such interactions.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

LA HB651

Provides with respect to broadband service providers access to railroad right of way

PA HB1151

In broadband services, further providing for definitions and providing for application for crossing, for review and approval of application for crossing, for procedures for crossing, for fees and costs associated with crossing, for petition to commission, for duties of commission and for miscellaneous provisions.

VA HB1752

Public utilities; fiber optic broadband lines crossing railroads.

VA SB1029

Public utilities; fiber optic broadband lines crossing railroads.

WV HB3265

Relating to fiber optic broadband lines crossing railroads

WV HB3059

Give PSC authority to fine Class I railroads for safety and operational violations.

ME LD1791

An Act to Make the ConnectMaine Authority Responsible for Attachments to and Joint Use of Utility Poles and to Establish Procedures for Broadband Service Infrastructure Crossing Railroad Tracks

LA HR40

Urges and requests the House Committee on Commerce to study the effects that the railroads have on broadband deployment