Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB926

Introduced
10/3/23  

Caption

Providing for State aid requirement for libraries relating to book removal and for prohibited removal of instructional materials and voluntary inquiry materials in public school entities.

Impact

The implementation of SB 926 would impact state laws by requiring libraries to adhere to new standards concerning the removal of books and educational materials. If passed, this bill would formalize the process of how instructional materials can be handled in educational settings, ensuring that they are not removed without a justifiable cause. This could lead to improved stability and availability of resources in libraries and schools, promoting the idea that all students should have access to a wide range of learning materials.

Summary

Senate Bill 926 aims to establish requirements for state aid to libraries, specifically addressing the issue of book removal and the prohibition of the removal of instructional and voluntary inquiry materials in public school entities. This bill represents a significant legislative effort to ensure that libraries remain funded and that educational resources, particularly in public schools, are protected from arbitrary removal. The bill suggests that libraries play a crucial role in providing access to educational materials, which is vital for the intellectual growth of students and community members alike.

Sentiment

The sentiment expressed during discussions surrounding SB 926 appears to be largely supportive among certain advocacy groups who view it as an important step towards safeguarding educational integrity. Advocates argue that the removal of instructional materials without a fair and transparent process could undermine educational equity. However, there are also concerns about potential censorship and the limits on what materials can be accessed, highlighting a debate between protecting educational resources and maintaining academic freedom.

Contention

Notable points of contention related to SB 926 revolve around the balance between protecting students' access to educational content and the desire for appropriate oversight regarding what materials are available in schools. Critics may argue that the bill could inadvertently restrict the discretion of educators and administrators, while supporters assert that it is necessary to prevent the arbitrary loss of educational resources. The bill's potential impact on local library governance and instructional autonomy in public schools will likely continue to fuel discussions in the legislature.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA HB1506

In terms and courses of study, providing for prohibited review of curriculum, instructional materials and voluntary inquiry material in public school entities.

PA HB860

In terms and courses of study, providing for prohibited review of curriculum, instructional materials and voluntary inquiry material in public school entities.

PA SB7

In terms and courses of study, providing for parental control relating to instructional materials and books containing sexually explicit content.

PA A3446

"Freedom to Read Act"; establishes requirements for library material in public school libraries and public libraries; protects school library staff members and librarians.

PA S2421

"Freedom to Read Act"; establishes requirements for library material in public school libraries and public libraries; protects school library staff members and librarians.

PA HB05417

An Act Concerning Public School Libraries.

PA HJR440

Public school libraries; JLARC to study removal of books.

PA S2281

Encourages and protects the freedom of public libraries to acquire materials without limitations and prohibits materials being removed from public libraries due to partisan or doctrinal disapproval.

PA H7386

Encourages and protects the freedom of public libraries to acquire materials without limitations and prohibits materials being removed from public libraries due to partisan or doctrinal disapproval.

PA SJR251

Public school libraries; JLARC to study removal of books.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.