Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB994

Introduced
12/8/23  

Caption

In general administration, further providing for State recording system for application of restraints to pregnant prisoners or detainees; in county correctional institutions, further providing for county recording system for application of restraints to pregnant prisoners or detainees; and, in miscellaneous provisions, further providing for healthy birth for incarcerated women.

Impact

The proposed bill is significant as it intends to reshape how pregnant women are treated in the corrections system, particularly concerning the use of restraints. By mandating a state and county-wide reporting system, it emphasizes the necessity of documenting each instance of restraint, which is intended to mitigate unnecessary harm and ensure the rights of pregnant prisoners are respected. If enacted, the bill would not only change how correctional facilities care for this demographic but could also influence broader prison reform initiatives by highlighting the need for humane treatment and oversight in corrections facilities.

Summary

Senate Bill 994 addresses the treatment of pregnant prisoners and detainees within correctional institutions in Pennsylvania. It aims to amend Title 61 of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes to establish a state and county recording system for the application of restraints on pregnant, laboring, or postpartum individuals. The bill includes definitions and regulations regarding when restraints can be applied and aims to prevent harm to both the prisoner and fetus during confinement and transport. It advocates for a standard reporting structure to ensure transparency and accountability when restraints are applied to these vulnerable populations.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 994 appears supportive among advocates for prisoners' rights and health care reform. Supporters argue that the bill represents a necessary step towards improving conditions for incarcerated women, particularly in concerns related to pregnancy and childbirth. There may be some contention from correctional officials or budgetary committees concerned about the implications of mandated reporting systems and additional training requirements, but the overall discourse seems to favor protecting the health and rights of pregnant women in custody.

Contention

Key points of contention in the discussions around SB 994 likely center on concerns over the practicality of implementing the new reporting and oversight requirements. Critics may argue that additional administrative processes could overburden correctional facilities, while advocates highlight the importance of accountability and informed practices that protect the well-being of pregnant detainees. Whether the proposed measures are seen as enhancements in care or as burdens on correctional operations will be an important debate as the bill moves through the legislative process.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

PA HB900

In general administration, further providing for State recording system for application of restraints to pregnant prisoners or detainees; in county correctional institutions, further providing for county recording system for application of restraints to pregnant prisoners or detainees; providing for Department of Human Services facilities; and, in miscellaneous provisions, further providing for healthy birth for incarcerated women and providing for restrictive housing prohibited for pregnant or postpartum incarcerated individuals and detainees, for cavity search and inspection restrictions, for training and education requirement, for feminine hygiene and incontinence products and for postpartum recovery.

PA HB1509

Amending Titles 42 (Judiciary and Judicial Procedure) and Title

IL SB3600

PREGNANT PRISONERS-RESTRAINTS

IL HB5431

PREGNANT PRISONERS-RESTRAINTS

AL HB230

Correction Dept., female inmates, prohibited practices regarding treatment of pregnant female inmates or female inmates in postpartum period

AL HB28

Correction Dept., female inmates, prohibited practices regarding treatment of a pregnant female inmate or a female inmate who is in the immediate postpartum period

CO HB1459

Birth Equity

CT SB00013

An Act Concerning The Fair Treatment Of Incarcerated Persons.