Video & Transcript DataContr Research : 'FTC enforcement'
Page 24 of 45
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Licensing & Administrative Procedures Mar 11th, 2025 at 10:30 am
House Licensing & Administrative Procedures Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- span> ...alcoholic beverage regulations in the state of Texas and enforce
- data-time="772">Our job is to make sure that the three-tier system that we regulate is properly enforced
- In our Law Enforcement Division, we have an authorized 300 FTEs.
- You've made enforcement look like enforcement.
- That rule, obviously, we cannot enforce under that provision until the public comment period is done,
Keywords:
House Bill 11, House Bill 3579, lottery ticket couriers, modernization, human trafficking, regulatory oversight
Summary:
The meeting focused primarily on legislative discussions surrounding House Bills 11 and 3579, with a significant emphasis on regulatory measures concerning lottery ticket couriers and modernization of licensing systems for the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation. Various committee members engaged in lively debates, particularly around the implications of using couriers within the lottery framework, as this raised concerns about regulatory gaps and the need for clearer oversight. Additionally, there was mention of the agency’s efforts to combat human trafficking through updated regulations and enforcement actions, indicating a priority agenda for the session.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- ...there's probably some sort of enforcement action that
- It's unfortunate that that happened, but I do have great compliance and enforcement staff.
- And that is the front side of enforcement.
- We could do that through enforcement action. So, it's just a complaint-driven process.
- To what extent is TCEQ partnering with county governments and local enforcement?
Keywords:
TCEQ, MUDs, Municipal Utility Districts, legislative control, environmental regulation, infrastructure, community concerns, transparency, growth management
Summary:
The meeting focused on discussions regarding the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality's (TCEQ) oversight and regulations concerning Municipal Utility Districts (MUDs). Several members expressed concerns about the rapid growth facilitated by the creation of MUDs, with particular emphasis on the legislative authority over such entities. Senator Birdwell highlighted the importance of legislative control over MUD creation, discussing the second and third-order impacts on local communities and infrastructure. The discussion was characterized by a view that the current approval processes may lack necessary scrutiny, leading to community concerns about environmental impacts and infrastructure strain as new developments arise.
Public testimony revealed a sense of urgency among constituents regarding environmental regulations and the role TCEQ plays in managing the challenges of population growth. Members of the committee raised issues around the clarity of TCEQ's powers and responsibilities, advocating for more transparency and proactive community engagement from the agency. As the meeting concluded, the need for improved communication and the importance of ensuring compliance with state law were emphasized, with a promise from TCEQ representatives to address these concerns moving forward.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Energy Resources Apr 7th, 2025 at 12:00 pm
House Energy Resources Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- So we're willing to enact statute in some places but rely on the market in other places for enforcement
- I'm a big proponent of theater and proper enforcement at the Railroad Commission.
- A retailer will have the opportunity to have a hearing prior to any fine being enforced.
- and their lack of enforcement up there in your area.
- I mean, do you have the confidence that they would enforce this bill?
Keywords:
inactive wells, oil and gas regulation, environmental protection, Railroad Commission of Texas, well plugging, Railroad Commission, penalties, violations, pipeline safety, civil penalties, criminal penalties, environmental protection, wildfire prevention, oil and gas, safety inspections, administrative penalties, Railroad Commission of Texas, excavation, notification, utilities
Summary:
The meeting of the House Committee focused predominantly on House Bill 3791, which aims to reform the notification requirements for excavators before commencing work. Representative Batson introduced the bill, emphasizing the need to update Texas's current 48-hour notification system to align with 45 other states, where the notification period is typically two business days. The bill aims to enhance public safety and streamline the excavation process, allowing for a more efficient and timely communication system among excavators and utility locators. During the discussions, Vice Chair Morales raised concerns regarding equitable enforcement and the absence of penalties for locators if deadlines aren't met, which led to a more in-depth conversation about enhancing responsibility across parties involved in the excavation process.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Finance (Part I) Mar 12th, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- Item number two: $4.7 million in all funds is adopted for law enforcement
Item number three is for the Enforcement Division, and
- >
There is one workgroup provision for Rider 21, county law enforcement
- ...local law enforcement grants to combat child sex trafficking
- Item number five, law enforcement technology and equipment
Keywords:
budget adjustments, salary increase, public defender, Senate Bill 9, workforce optimization
Summary:
The committee also reviewed workforce optimization projects and critical capital improvements, underscoring the importance of maintaining and enhancing state infrastructure. A work group revision related to Senate Bill 9 was adopted, further demonstrating the committee's proactive approach to addressing fiscal responsibilities and ensuring effective allocation of state resources. The meeting concluded with an overview of adopted items and a commitment to continue enhancing services for the public.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- We enforce age restrictions and use child-resistant packaging.
- Texas has an enforcement issue.
- It will not allow the state to enforce the law.
- What we lack is enforcement.
- We don't need prohibition; we need smart, enforceable regulation.
Keywords:
hemp regulation, consumable products, cannabinoids, state health, youth protection, licensing fees, criminal offenses, HB28, public testimony, committee decorum, bill substitute, legislative process
Summary:
The meeting featured significant discussions regarding HB28, where the chair outlined the plans to bring forward a substitute for the bill. The chair emphasized the importance of maintaining order and decorum during the proceedings. Members engaged in deliberations, and a number of public witnesses were invited to testify, thereby enriching the discussion around the bill. This interaction provided valuable insights into public sentiment regarding the issues at hand.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
How many people are in the Enforcement Division?
- Are the 12 people you have in your enforcement division enough
- division and request additional FTEs to enforce those standards.
How many people are in the enforcement division?
- division and request additional FTEs to enforce those standards.
Keywords:
energy policy, HB5066, power generation, energy demand, renewables, transmission, fund allocation, Texas grid
Summary:
The meeting convened primarily to discuss HB5066, focusing on energy policy and power generation in Texas. Key discussions revolved around the challenges and opportunities associated with forecasting energy demand and the balance between different types of generation sources, including renewables and thermal energy. Members voiced concerns about the speed at which new power generation can be integrated into the grid, with panelists emphasizing the critical need for effective transmission enhancements to keep pace with increasing demand. Notably, members also scrutinized the historical allocation of a $5 billion fund intended for energy projects, urging a review of previous allocations before committing further funds.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- Opposite sex enforcement matters too.
- How is this going to be enforced? What are people going to...
- Another thing I'd like to add is, how is this bill going to be enforced?
- There isn't any efficient way to ensure that this bill is enforced.
- There is no consequence for wasting law enforcement time with a false report.
Keywords:
biological sex, gender identity, public facilities, civil penalties, local government, alcohol sales, racing events, mixed beverage permit, temporary sale, Texas legislation, healthcare provider, retaliation, civil remedy, whistleblower protection, equal protection, impeachment, public officers, disqualification, procedural reform, removal from office
Summary:
The committee meeting primarily focused on Senate Bill 2043, aiming to provide protections for healthcare professionals against retaliation for reporting unethical practices. Chairman Hughes initiated the discussion, emphasizing the importance of safeguarding medical practitioners' rights. Testimonies from various witnesses highlighted real-life implications of the bill, with some expressing personal experiences of facing significant backlash for whistleblowing on unethical practices within healthcare facilities. Supporters of the bill touted it as a crucial step towards ensuring transparency and accountability in the medical field, particularly concerning the treatment of minors in gender transition procedures.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- It's in enforcement, and we're working to resolve the compliance issues to get...
- I can speak to the enforcement, which is working to resolve the issues.
- Negatively impacting law enforcement operations.
- A lot of that comes, or has enforcement with our sister agency, TCEQ.
- are our workhorse programs for replacing infrastructure, if you're not under enforcement...
Bills:
SB1
Keywords:
appropriations, budget, state funding, education, healthcare, infrastructure, water infrastructure, Railroad Commission, Senate Bill 30, Senate Bill 8, budget recommendations, public testimony, water funding, climate change, dedicated revenue stream
Summary:
The meeting included a comprehensive discussion on various upcoming budget recommendations impacting the Railroad Commission and water funding allocations. Significant dialogue focused on Senate Bill 30, which addresses water funding appropriations crucial for developing and maintaining the state's water infrastructure amidst growing demand. Testimonies from various stakeholders emphasized the urgency of addressing water resource issues in Texas, given the state's increasing population and the forthcoming infrastructure needs. Additionally, climate change impacts and funding challenges were heavily underscored by the participants, showcasing a collective concern over future water supply and management.
The committee also reviewed the implications of Senate Bill 8 and Senate Joint Resolution 75 regarding the creation of new funds and programs for water management and development. Importantly, the potential for a dedicated revenue stream was raised, echoing the sentiment that a historic investment in water infrastructure is critical. The meeting adjourned with plans for a follow-up to further evaluate and confirm budget appropriations, reflecting a strong commitment to tackle Texas's pressing water challenges.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- It authorizes civil penalties of up to $5,000, with enforcement through district court proceedings in
- quorums will happen, and that's why there are provisions to address quorums, such as using law enforcement
- Using civil arrest and law enforcement to compel members to
- marker="178" data-time="1062"> Okay, so essentially what we’re saying then is we’re letting the courts enforce
- But the enforcement requires courts to examine the motive of whether a member left to impede business
Bills:
HB18
Keywords:
political contributions, legislature, civil penalty, quorum-breaking, Texas Ethics Commission, HB18, quorum break, financial benefit, legislative integrity, constituent concerns, penalties, fundraising, Texas legislature
Summary:
The meeting of the committee focused on the discussions surrounding HB18, which aims to prevent legislators from financially benefiting when they break quorum. Chairman Shaheen emphasized that this bill addresses the integrity of the Texas legislature and responds to constituent concerns about lawmakers being absent and raising funds simultaneously. Throughout the meeting, members discussed the implications of enforcing penalties for breaking quorum and the balance between legislative strategy and financial transparency. Various representatives expressed their views, with some supporting the bill for enhancing accountability, while others argued that it imposes unfair restrictions on a constitutional tactic historically used by minority factions.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Water, Agriculture, and Rural Affairs Feb 24th, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- "328" data-time="1962"> At the Animal Health Commission, ensuring they remain accessible to law enforcement
- I'm a rancher and landowner, as well as the Executive Director of Law Enforcement Brand and Inspection
- To the county clerks, law enforcement, and livestock producers
- So, this online database will be critical to law enforcement
- House Bill 3232 provided a vehicle for those larger systems to reduce or eliminate the risk of enforcement
Keywords:
Senate Committee, Water and Agriculture, SB384, Operation Game Thief, poaching, legislative measures, public support, funding
Summary:
The Senate Committee on Water and Agriculture and Rural Affairs convened under the leadership of Chairman Kelly Hancock, who opened the meeting with a prayer in remembrance of Chairman Perry, who was absent due to a personal loss. The session focused on the discussions surrounding SB384, which aims to support the longstanding initiative known as Operation Game Thief. Senator Flores presented the bill, emphasizing its essential role in the fight against poaching through public support. The operation has a successful track record of convictions but is currently dependent on donations and merchandise sales for funding. The committee aimed to vote on multiple bills during this session, contingent on achieving a quorum. Notably, discussions also revolved around fiscal notes on two bills that were set aside for later consideration, indicating the committee's intention to carefully manage their legislative decisions. The meeting showcased a productive atmosphere, with committee members actively engaged in the review and potential advancement of key legislative measures.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Water, Agriculture, and Rural Affairs (Part II) Apr 14th, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- marker="4" data-time="18">Senate Bill 2661 allows members of groundwater conservation districts to enforce
So, this bill seeks to put real teeth into the enforcement
- But the balance between the penalties or the enforcement action that the bill would give to the utility
- The one thing that investor-owned utilities have the ability to enforce is their tariffs, which are their
- It's just that nobody wants to enforce it.
Keywords:
groundwater, water utilities, Senate Bill 2661, penalties, public testimony, aquifer depletion, water conservation, Senate Bill 2662, drought resources
Summary:
During this meeting, the committee had a thorough discussion centered around various Senate Bills primarily related to groundwater management and water utility regulations. Notably, Senate Bill 2661, introduced amendments to enhance penalties for over-pumping water, highlighting the growing concern over depleting aquifers and ensuring compliance with existing water use regulations. Multiple senators voiced their opinions regarding the necessity of tougher penalties and the implications for both water users and conservation methods. Public testimony was heard, with some arguing against the proposed penalties, stating they could unfairly burden farmers and landowners.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- To achieve enforcement and management, we need to cut these
- It's critical for our local governments and law enforcement
- This bill is silent on enforcement.
- Enforcement responsibilities and challenges could strain association resources, increase litigation,
- Local jurisdictions enforce more than general state codes
Bills:
SB2784, HB23, HB247, HB1533, HB2011, HB2013, HB2273, HB2421, HB2464, HB3120, HB3424, HB3575, HB3788, HB4370, HB4809, HB5057, HB5084, HB5534, HB5668, HJR34
Keywords:
Somervell County, hospital district, board of directors, elections, local governance, staggered terms, third-party review, property development, local government, permits, construction inspection, regulatory authority, land development, liability, occupancy certificate, border security, tax exemption, ad valorem, real property, infrastructure
Summary:
The meeting of the committee focused on a range of bills covering various legislative matters. Notably, bills concerning property rights, environmental sustainability, and public safety were debated prominently. HB2011 was presented and discussed in detail, with supporters highlighting its importance for ensuring property owners can repurchase their land if it has been acquired through eminent domain without due payments of property taxes. Furthermore, Senator Cook emphasized the need for accountability in the process while several senators expressed concerns regarding potential unintended consequences of new laws affecting local jurisdictions and public safety standards. Public testimony was also received from stakeholders both in support and against various bills, reflecting a diverse range of views on the proposed legislation. In addition to HB2011, several other bills, including HB4809 and HB2421, moved forward with recommendations for passage and were set for future calendars.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Trade, Workforce & Economic Development Apr 9th, 2025 at 10:30 am
House Trade, Workforce & Economic Development Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- So the rental company is left with no legal recourse and law enforcement has no leverage.
- They wouldn't cooperate with law enforcement or with us, and we had to honor that CDW.
- We want to support our law enforcement.
- We have a long list of witnesses, and we do have to enforce the two-minute rule.
- They said, "You're right, we can't enforce this."
Bills:
HB74, HB175, HB460, HB576, HB2271, HB2294, HB2874, HB3016, HB3133, HB3191, HB3458, HB3929, HB4063, HB4115, HB4394
Keywords:
Puerto Verde, Port Authority, eminent domain, bonds, tax assessments, economic development, infrastructure, transportation, public welfare, child care, certifications, Texas Rising Star Program, grant program, disability inclusion, child care, family income, affordability, economic impact, state study, child care
Summary:
This committee meeting predominantly focused on the discussions surrounding several significant bills aimed at enhancing child care accessibility and addressing the issues related to deepfake technology. Representative Bojani introduced HB3133, which seeks to create a clear reporting process for deepfake material, ensuring social media platforms take accountability for harmful content. The bill aims to safeguard users from digital manipulations. Notably, the representatives engaged in a robust dialogue regarding the rising need for responsible management of deepfake content, establishing that Texas could take a leading role in this area.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Local Government (Part I) Apr 28th, 2025
Senate Local Government Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- This bill also prohibits enforcement of any...
- It's to enforce the charter, an ordinance, or state law.
- That was, yes, it's to enforce the... yes.
So the question becomes, when enforcement is...
- Mathematically, we cannot enforce every law. We need to make a decision.
Bills:
SB250, SB375, SB536, SB845, SB1633, SB1944, SB1957, SB2081, SB2137, SB2262, SB2299, SB2419, SB2452, SB2522, SB2549, SB2594, SB2605, SB2631, SB2639, SB2675, SB3029, SJR60, HB22, HB1392, HB2525
Keywords:
municipal annexation, railroad, adjacent areas, local government, property rights, healthcare provider, Harris County Hospital District, hospital funding, healthcare services, public health program, home loans, nurses, veterans, public servants, Texas Heroes program, low-interest loans, social workers, home loans, housing assistance, veterans
Summary:
The committee meeting predominantly focused on various pieces of legislation, notably Senate Bill 2299, which aims to redefine municipal immunity. Deep concerns were raised during discussions, particularly by public witnesses who underscored the bill's potential to undermine citizen accountability and local governance. Representative Monty Bennett argued passionately against the bill, citing its conflict with recent local charter amendments passed by Dallas voters, reflecting a significant public sentiment for local governance autonomy. Multiple attendees voiced strong opposition due to fears of increased litigation against municipalities, which could strain local resources and hinder governance effectiveness. In contrast, proponents of the bill, including city representatives, argued that it is essential for preventing frivolous lawsuits and maintaining fiscal responsibility for city budgets.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- This is a more enforceable aspect, trying to get at what...
- to get at, but I think this gives better context to law enforcement and our prosecuting authorities.
- to enforce those laws.
- What is your sense of those that you would have to enforce and file charges for?
- Again, that's on law enforcement and prosecution to prove that they know this individual.
Keywords:
firearm acquisition, gun smuggling, criminal offenses, ammunition, terrorism, public safety, HCR40, HB214, border security, Operation Lone Star, public testimony, firearm offenses, terrorism, legislation
Summary:
The committee convened to discuss two significant bills: HCR40, regarding reimbursement for border security costs, and HB214, which addresses the prosecution of firearm and ammunition-related offenses. Senator Flores represented HCR40, urging Congress to reimburse Texas for expenses incurred under Operation Lone Star, citing ongoing issues with illegal crossings and drug trafficking. Though there was a commendable attempt at public testimony, none was received, and the bill was left pending with intentions for further discussions. Much emphasis was placed on the state's security responsibilities and federal inaction that led to a substantial financial burden on Texas taxpayers.
In discussing HB214 introduced by Chairman Birdwell, key points included the need for refinement in identifying which offenses classify as terroristic. The members engaged in a comprehensive debate surrounding the expansion of offenses related to firearms smuggling and terrorism. Members expressed concern over including overly broad definitions that could lead to misuse of power and mislabeling of offenses. The committee's focus shifted towards creating a more precise framework that separates economic offenses from true acts of terrorism. The meeting emphasized collaboration and careful consideration in drafting legislation aimed at enhancing public safety without infringing on rights.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Judiciary & Civil Jurisprudence May 12th, 2025 at 09:05 am
House Judiciary & Civil Jurisprudence Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- chaired by Justice Jane Bland, of which Speaker Moody is a member, has been working with judges, law enforcement
- Due to the severity of his illness, we sometimes turned to law enforcement for help.
- We reached out to law enforcement and APS, but again, his rights allowed him to refuse treatment.
- was wounded, and my 84-year-old mother was caught in the crossfire and died at the hands of law enforcement
- It allows law enforcement to apprehend, meaning to take that initial apprehension if the officer has
Keywords:
judicial conduct, state commission, judicial misconduct, commission membership, constitutional amendment, mental health, court proceedings, notice requirements, legal filings, electronic documents, automated motor vehicles, traffic safety, Department of Public Safety, crimes, transportation network companies, justice, judicial council, centers of excellence, court operations, recognition program
Summary:
This meeting of the Judiciary and Civil Jurisprudence Committee addressed multiple bills, focusing notably on mental health provisions and judicial accountability. SB1164 was a significant topic, discussing amendments to emergency detainer processes for individuals with severe mental illness. Witnesses provided compelling testimonies highlighting issues within the current mental health system, stressing the need for a compassionate approach to assist those refusing treatment. The discussion revealed tensions surrounding the legislative changes, with concerns from various stakeholders about potential overreach and effectiveness of proposed measures.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Trade, Workforce & Economic Development May 21st, 2025 at 08:05 am
House Trade, Workforce & Economic Development Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- Office of the Attorney General right now, but there have been no civil enforcement actions...
- So currently, the only office that has the ability or jurisdiction to enforce this civil penalty would
- And there's been no enforcement action.
- ...to enforce this very important training.
- You had mentioned there's a three-step enforcement process. Can you walk us through that process?
Keywords:
discrimination, trade association, membership rights, professional organizations, freedom of speech, discrimination, professional association, trade association, membership rights, freedom of speech, social media, bot accounts, misinformation, disclosure, civil penalty, Texas legislation, Economic Development, SB315, SB584, SB7105
Summary:
The meeting of the Economic Development Committee was marked by a series of important discussions surrounding a range of bills, including SB315, SB584, and SB7105. SB2670, which aims to protect businesses from misleading solicitations, was highlighted during the session, where its provisions were debated among committee members. Additionally, SB2637 was presented to tackle misinformation disseminated on social media platforms. Witnesses provided insights into the implications of these bills, specifically focusing on consumer protection and the balance between technological advancement and public safety. The chair urged thoughtful consideration of the bills in the context of their impact on both businesses and residents of the state.
The meeting concluded with a call for further analysis of several key bills that were left pending, indicating strong interest in ensuring that legislations align with public interests while addressing modern challenges posed by technology and misleading practices. Attendance was robust, with committee members actively engaging with witnesses and each other to ensure comprehensive discussions were had. Notable commentary emphasized the need for regulations to adapt to the evolving digital landscape and protect citizens from dishonest business practices.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Delivery of Government Efficiency Apr 2nd, 2025 at 10:30 am
House Delivery of Government Efficiency Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- What about the enforcement process?
- We must hold law enforcement and governmental agencies accountable.
- So, we want to see these enforced.
- Throughout the years, there's been a reduction in enforcement officers, right?
- directed towards enforcement, right?
Bills:
HB512, HB2248, HB2679, HB2832, HB3112, HB3368, HB3490, HB3512, HB3623, HB3666, HB3700, HB3711, HB3770, HB3963
Keywords:
grievance procedures, state agency, employee rights, workplace regulations, employment law, grievance procedures, state agency, employees, employment actions, appeal, grievance procedures, state employees, workplace rights, disciplinary actions, employment conditions, employee rights, grievance procedures, state agency, employment disputes, job protections
Summary:
The meeting centered around the discussion of House Bill 3700, presented by Representative Vaux, which seeks to amend the Texas Labor Code to enhance the regulatory authority for the Texas Workforce Commission (TWC). Representative Vaux highlighted the need for clear statutory authority to prevent fraud, waste, and abuse in all TWC programs, engaging members with an emphasis on the implications of the changes proposed. Public testimony was also invited, allowing various stakeholders to express their views on the bill.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Water, Agriculture, and Rural Affairs Mar 31st, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- funds currently generated from saltwater fishing stamp sales are used for general coastal fishery enforcement
- and Enforced Service to create and maintain a statewide database
- There is no penalty or enforcement listed, which is important to note.
- Chairman, I also have the enforcement matters by the TCEQ against this particular company if anybody
- But when it is, we do need that stronger enforcement. So for those reasons, we support the bill.
Keywords:
Senate Bills, agriculture, public health, fire safety, committee substitutes, legislative updates
Summary:
The meeting was convened to discuss various Senate Bills, focusing on issues pertinent to agriculture, environment, and public health. Notably, Senator Perry spearheaded discussions on SB1247 and SB1948, emphasizing the need for committee substitutes to adapt the bills to recent legislative requirements. SB1948, in particular, was introduced to exempt agricultural structures from certain fire safety regulations, reflecting concerns among agricultural producers regarding compliance costs. Multiple members supported this legislation, highlighting the impact on the agricultural sector's operational viability.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- Our enforcement officers bring in almost a million dollars every month.
The law enforcement folks that are there do not have
**Senator Paxton**: So how many law enforcement people
- Well, in my sources from both Mexican law enforcement and public officials and on this side of the border
- Just know that our staff, you know, a lot of those enforcement officers, for example, they're out in
Summary:
The meeting involved a comprehensive review of various legislative bills, with members voicing their opinions and concerns on each. Significant discussions centered around land use policies, education reforms, and public health initiatives. A number of witnesses were called to share their insights, providing both supportive and opposing perspectives on the proposed bills. The committee demonstrated a commitment to thorough deliberation, ensuring all voices were heard before taking votes on the legislation.