Video & Transcript DataContr Research : 'Texas courts'
Page 55 of 58
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
S/C on Academic & Career-Oriented Education Apr 24th, 2025 at 08:04 am
House S/C on Academic & Career-Oriented Education
Transcript Highlights:
In 2016, Texas created new educational opportunities for
Lastly, the program partners with Texas institutions of
- So this bill aims to fix this oversight by amending the Texas
- Currently, the state of Texas requires school districts to teach students a total of 75,600 minutes,
- My name is Gabe Grantham, Education Policy Advisor at Texas 2036, and I'm here to express our support
Keywords:
school funding, instructional days, education, public schools, school performance, four-day school week, instructional days, education, four-day school week, performance rating, school governance, instructional days, school calendar, education funding, emergency closures, four-day school week, public schools, education, instructional days, public schools
Summary:
The committee meeting focused on various educational bills, prominently House Bill 1209, which aims to address concerns surrounding the implementation of four-day school weeks in Texas. Key discussions highlighted the potential negative impacts on student performance, particularly after a report indicated that students in four-day districts scored lower in reading and math compared to their peers in traditional five-day school weeks. Representative Cunningham raised significant points regarding the importance of maintaining instructional time and the need for accountability for school districts opting for shorter weeks.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th 1st C.S.
89th Legislative Session - First Called Session Jul 24th, 2025 at 10:07 am
Texas House Floor Meeting
Transcript Highlights:
We thank You, Father, for the wonderful state of Texas
- Please join me in the pledge of allegiance to the United States and the State of Texas.
Under the Texas flag, I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas
- And, you know, with that, I'm incredibly grateful for y'all and for the people of Texas that have really
- It is a true testament to how wonderful the people of Texas are.
Keywords:
Kerr County, flood, community support, recovery, volunteers, construction, local government, infrastructure
Summary:
The committee meeting focused on the aftermath of a devastating flood in Kerr County, where lives were lost and families were displaced. Many representatives expressed their condolences and shared stories of community support, highlighting the extraordinary efforts of volunteers who rushed to help those affected. Member discussions were filled with heartfelt sentiments, as many acknowledged the long road ahead for recovery and rebuilding efforts. The atmosphere was one of solidarity, reflecting the commitment of the representatives to aid their constituents in times of crisis and to ensure such disasters are better managed in the future.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- On behalf of Texas 2036.
Okay. Thank you.
You're Tom Banning, you represent the Texas Academy of
The Texas Medical Association has a position on the AP
- Are you familiar with the report that Texas Department of Insurance used to do, the Texas Mandated Benefits
- God bless Texas. Happy birthday.
Keywords:
health impact analysis, cost analysis, coverage mandates, health insurance, legislative analysis, health care data, education, funding, classroom resources, teacher support, student outcomes, health benefits, provider dentists, payment reimbursement, insurance code, noncontracting, dental care, reimbursement, health benefit plans, noncontracting providers
Summary:
The meeting of the committee focused significantly on discussions surrounding HB138 and HB388. Representative Harris-DeVille presented HB388, which aims to standardize the coordination of benefits questionnaires used by health benefit plan issuers and healthcare providers. This discussion highlighted the issues of patient billing complexities and the potential for reduced errors in healthcare coverage. Various stakeholders provided testimony in support of the bill, emphasizing its importance in streamlining the process for patients who have dual coverage, such as Medicaid and Medicare. There was considerable backing for the functionality that HB388 would bring in clearing up confusion in billing practices across different insurance plans.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- fewer than 42 semester credit hours for associate degrees, a program subject to the approval of the Texas
- Moreover, this aligns Texas' education system with the evolving demands of the global economy, ensuring
- I request that you give this bill a favorable report for the benefit of Texas students.
- Good morning, Sarah Keaton with the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board.
- ...was to establish the Texas Direct Degree Program.
Keywords:
higher education, transfer students, education transparency, academic credit, institutional reporting, Senate Committee on Education, SB2846, SB2847, higher education, curricula flexibility, workforce alignment, student transfer
Summary:
The Senate Committee on Education K through 16 convened to discuss two significant bills, SB2846 and SB2847, with a focus on enhancing educational structures in Texas. Senator Hagen-Booe introduced SB2847, which aims to provide greater flexibility in core curricula for bachelor's degree programs. The discussion highlighted the potential positive implications of this bill, particularly in terms of aligning education with workforce needs and reducing barriers for students seeking technical degrees. However, there was no public testimony registered for either bill, which limited the input from stakeholders outside the legislative body. The committee chair indicated that further review of SB3039 would be necessary, pending additional discussions and data collection on student transfer issues from community colleges to four-year universities.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Natural Resources (Part II) Mar 26th, 2025
Senate Natural Resources Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- Texas, but I'm concerned with the growing conflicts resulting
We support the growth in Texas but want to do so in a way
- AGC represents approximately 700 members who build critical infrastructure vital to Texas growth.
- I'm here to testify on behalf of the Texas Aggregate and Concrete Association.
- I understand the growth objectives for Texas. I like it here, and I want to continue that.
Keywords:
rock crushing, permits, air quality, environmental monitoring, aggregate production, seismicity, public meeting, land use, oil emergency, gas emergency, liability protection, Railroad Commission, emergency assistance, civil liability, natural resources, SB1757, aggregate production operations, permits, environmental monitoring, public participation
Summary:
The committee meeting was convened to discuss SB1757, which proposed a new standard permit impacting aggregate production operations (APOs) in Texas. Witnesses from various industries, including the Associated General Contractors and the Texas Aggregate and Concrete Association, provided insights supporting the bill while cautioning about potential overreach in regulation. Many expressed gratitude towards the committee members for their collaboration in achieving regulations that could accommodate operational needs while still being protective of community interests. Concerns were raised concerning the proposed public participation measures and the adequacy of environmental monitoring requirements under the new permit structure.
Significant discussions centered around balancing industry growth with community health, particularly regarding air quality and the implementation of best management practices. Some witnesses voiced opposition, insisting that the current version fails to correctly incorporate control requirements and could potentially exacerbate tensions between industry and public health considerations. It was clear that ongoing negotiations were taking place among stakeholders, with a collective aim to refine the bill to better align with both industry and community needs.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Land & Resource Management Apr 24th, 2025 at 10:04 am
House Land & Resource Management Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- in Texas for Housing are in support of this bill.
- The majority of Texas does not regulate cedar trees because they can be...
- He said it shows a site in central Texas where no regard for existing trees has been...
- We've had enough wildfires in the last decade in Texas, and we've seen that.
- I'm with Audubon, Texas.
Bills:
SB840, HB2025, HB2512, HB3139, HB3798, HB3892, HB4373, HB4398, HB4582, HB4689, HB5187, HB5658, HB5666
Keywords:
municipality, extraterritorial jurisdiction, residents rights, local governance, petition, Edwards Aquifer, municipal utility district, bond issuance, county authority, water management, Ashe juniper, tree removal, municipal regulation, military base, property rights, environmental impact, county regulation, infrastructure planning, subdivisions, building codes
Summary:
The meeting focused heavily on discussions surrounding affordable housing, particularly through the lens of House Bill 4398. Representative Garcia-Hernandez presented the bill, which aims to streamline the permitting process for low-income housing projects, thus reducing the timeline municipalities typically take to approve or deny permits by 50%. This bill is viewed as critical given the pressing issues related to low-income housing availability in Texas. Public testimony included supportive evidence from various stakeholders, highlighting the urgent need for expedited permits to align construction timelines with strict tax credit requirements. Experts from the Texas Affiliation of Affordable Housing Providers also underscored that permitting delays create significant financial risks, complicating the completion of necessary housing units.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Agriculture & Livestock May 14th, 2025 at 09:05 am
House Agriculture & Livestock Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- data-time="90"> Would be required to hold an ungraded dealer-wholesaler license obtained from the Texas
- That are ungraded, or Texas duck eggs that are ungraded.
- My name is Doug Hoffman and I own and operate Mesquite Field with my wife in Nixon, Texas, located in
- Essler, and I'm with the Texas Poultry Federation, and we are opposed to SB1864.
- Now, currently, today in the state of Texas, anybody can sell eggs.
Bills:
SB1864
Keywords:
SB1864, graded egg market, small-scale producers, food safety, agribusiness, consumer protection, local markets
Summary:
This meeting of the committee centered around the discussion of SB1864, which aims to increase access to the graded egg market for small-scale producers. Chairman Wilson introduced the bill, highlighting its potential to lower barriers for entry, allowing smaller producers to sell ungraded eggs to retailers and wholesalers with proper labeling and documentation. The committee heard differing viewpoints, with supporters emphasizing the importance of farming diversity and access to local markets, while opponents raised concerns about food safety and maintaining quality standards. Testimonies from various stakeholders, including farmer representatives, industry experts, and regulatory bodies, were presented, showcasing the tension between market access for small producers and the need for consumer protection through existing food safety regulations.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Water, Agriculture, and Rural Affairs Apr 22nd, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- Chairman, Chronic Wasting Disease poses a significant threat to the Texas deer population.
- Brain Institute, and Texas A&M Veterinary College.
- with the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department using existing
- The bill requires the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department to hold public hearings.
- I'm the Wildlife Division Director for Texas Parks and Wildlife, and I'm testifying neutral.
Keywords:
SB2476, transfer of water supply, Angelina River Authority, technical capabilities, sunset accountability
Summary:
This committee meeting focused on the discussions surrounding SB2476, which proposes the transfer of the Woodlawn Water Supply Corporation to the Angelina and Natchez River Authority. Senator Nichols presented the bill, highlighting its local agreements and the technical capabilities of the River Authority to manage the water supply efficiently. The discussion included inquiries about the implications of this transfer, particularly regarding sunrise accountability and whether the new arrangement would adhere to sunset processes in the future. Members engaged in a collaborative dialogue, reflecting an understanding of the local needs and the importance of maintaining water supply management.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- grant funding for broadband development, a rider appropriation of 1.3 billion for transfer to the Texas
- My name is **Glenn Hager**, Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts.
- It's going to become law in the state of Texas. I heard that.
- We have our Texas Identification Number System, TINS, which has vendor information.
- We have our Texas Identification Number System, TINS, which has vendor information.
Summary:
The meeting involved a comprehensive review of various legislative bills, with members voicing their opinions and concerns on each. Significant discussions centered around land use policies, education reforms, and public health initiatives. A number of witnesses were called to share their insights, providing both supportive and opposing perspectives on the proposed bills. The committee demonstrated a commitment to thorough deliberation, ensuring all voices were heard before taking votes on the legislation.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Criminal Jurisprudence S/C New Offenses and Changed Penalties May 1st, 2025 at 08:05 am
Transcript Highlights:
- There's clearly an effort in the state of Texas to expand gambling, which I strongly oppose.
- In Texas, Adult Protective Services...
- Texas public transit.
- But in Texas, we don't have a bright line rule.
- Bud Wein from the Texas Civil Rights Project.
Keywords:
public safety, criminal penalties, HB544, vulnerable populations, child abuse, consecutive sentencing, HB689, elder abuse, public testimony
Summary:
The committee meeting primarily focused on discussing various bills addressing public safety and criminal penalties within Texas. Notable discussions included the introduction of HB544, which aims to expand consecutive sentencing for crimes against children and vulnerable adults. Representative Gervin Hawkins highlighted the urgent need for this legislation by referencing a shocking case in Bexar County involving severe abuse, illustrating the limitations of current law in imposing adequate penalties. The bill received public support and raised awareness of the ongoing issues surrounding the safety of vulnerable populations.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Delivery of Government Efficiency May 14th, 2025 at 09:05 am
House Delivery of Government Efficiency Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- and over 20,000 small businesses in Texas across all different
- Members of the Committee, as the owner of Alcon DTS, a Texas
SB 2610 aligns with these by encouraging Texas businesses
Riley, testifying for yourself, Texas Association of
- this step to ensure the safety and privacy of the folks that are running elections in the state of Texas
Keywords:
election officials, confidentiality, personal information, government transparency, public safety, financial exploitation, artificial intelligence, phishing, legal liability, criminal offense, civil penalty, consumer protection, cybersecurity, small businesses, election officials, safety, SB2610, SB1540, SB2373
Summary:
During the meeting, the committee reviewed three significant bills: SB2610, SB1540, and SB2373. SB2610, presented by Chairman Capriglione, provides a legal safe harbor from punitive damages for small and mid-sized businesses implementing documented cybersecurity programs. Testimonies from representatives of the National Federation of Independent Businesses emphasized the importance of this legislation in safeguarding businesses against cyber threats. Similarly, SB1540 aims to enhance the safety of election officials by protecting their personal information from disclosure, addressing increasing threats and harassment faced by these individuals. The committee heard heartfelt testimonies from election officials who highlighted the risks endured due to their roles, reinforcing the need for stronger protections.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- The Commission allowed a business entity named Rook Texas to collect.
- Additionally, the Texas Lottery is a very regressive tax,
- So when we talk about the revenue raised by the Texas Lottery, we're talking about revenue raised to
- Even though the Lottery Commission colludes with criminals to defraud Texas, the lottery itself is a
- All new rules and rule modifications must be in full compliance with Texas law.
Keywords:
deep fake, social media, user reports, deceptive trade practices, online safety, election administration, deepfake material, gun license grace period, lottery regulations, public testimony
Summary:
The meeting focused on several critical pieces of legislation including HB677, HB3133, HB668, SB2819, and SB3070. Notably, HB677 prohibits county election administrators from holding other appointed positions while serving in their role, with no public testimony registered against it, leading to its pending status. Conversely, HB3133, which addresses the issue of explicit deep fake material on social media, drew significant attention but was left pending without public testimony as well. The discussion of HB668 included provisions for a one-year grace period for licensed handgun owners after expiration, a relatively straightforward bill that also registered no public testimony. Meanwhile, SB2819, a companion to HB677, emphasizes the strict regulations surrounding election administration, seeking to eliminate any potential conflicts of interest. Lastly, SB3070 sparked conversations about lottery regulations and transparency in operations, prompting discussions around its implications and garnering witness testimonies in favor of the bill.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Land & Resource Management Apr 10th, 2025 at 08:00 am
House Land & Resource Management Committee
Transcript Highlights:
As Texas uses NFPA fire code standards, this mandate
- Colby Ferguson, on behalf of the Texas Pork Producers Association, here in support of House Bill 3630
- I'm with the Texas Poultry Federation, and we are in favor of House Bill 3630.
- Pendleton on behalf of Texas.
- Our MUD is located on the west side of Harris County, Texas.
Keywords:
manufactured housing, HUD-code, zoning, local government regulations, installation permits, municipal utility district, board meetings, public access, meeting location, transparency, fire prevention, agriculture, local government, fire safety, regulations, municipal utility districts, public notice, housing regulations, legislation, committee testimony
Summary:
The meeting convened with a quorum present and was primarily focused on multiple pieces of legislation related to municipal utility districts (MUDs). Among the bills discussed, HB2225 was moved forward favorably, extending public notice requirements for fee impositions. Representative Nozzolio and Vice-Chair Malani contributed significantly to the discussion, highlighting the implications of these changes. Another significant bill was HB2797, which prohibits municipalities from regulating the number of occupants in a dwelling unit based on various status categories. The committee adopted a substitute for this bill, which suggested that key modifications address community concerns around housing policies. Positive sentiments were expressed regarding the adaptability of this substitute which was widely discussed among the members.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- of fact, a couple of sessions back, we all joined together and stood up and passed a bill that made Texas
- data-time="252">By telling the federal government there will be no federal laws on gun law enforced in Texas
- on on gun laws that exceed Texas law.
- No question, you've been a tremendous leader for Texas.
- up for Texas sovereignty in it.
Keywords:
House Bill 796, federal directives, state sovereignty, committee substitute, Senator King, Senator Birdwell, Senate proceedings
Summary:
The meeting of the committee primarily focused on House Bill 796, which seeks to establish a framework for the legislature to declare federal directives unconstitutional. Senator King introduced a committee substitute that provided a detailed explanation of the bill's intent, emphasizing the importance of state sovereignty in opposing what they deem unconstitutional actions from the federal government. The discussion included various viewpoints on how effective the bill would be in empowering the state against federal overreach. Senator Birdwell moved to adopt the substitute without any objections, indicating broad support for the measure. The bill was subsequently reported favorably to the full Senate for further consideration.
In addition to HB796, SB707 was mentioned as part of the discussions but did not receive as much focus as the primary bill. The committee sessions were indicative of a collaborative effort amongst the senators to assert Texas's legal stances on federal directives, pushing forward with legislation intended to protect state rights. With a quorum present, the session was efficient and concluded with a sense of purpose and agreement on future proceedings.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Licensing & Administrative Procedures Apr 29th, 2025 at 10:04 am
House Licensing & Administrative Procedures Committee
Transcript Highlights:
- Adding human trafficking by the Texas Department of Licensing
- that we previously voted out relating to exempting certain transactions from the regulation of the Texas
- relating to the licensing and regulation of massage therapy and other programs administered by the Texas
- The Board of Boiler Rules is within the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation.
- Under current law, the Texas Department of Licensing must update the Texas Workforce Commission monthly
Keywords:
elevator inspection, building safety, construction standards, health and safety code, regulatory requirements, public safety, licensing, regulatory measures, cosmetology, driver education, committee meeting
Summary:
The committee meeting covered a variety of bills primarily focusing on public safety, regulatory measures, and licensing issues. Notable discussions included the approval of SB1366, which mandates the inclusion of construction and maintenance work zone information in driver education curriculums, and SB378, which clarifies the restrictions on cosmetologists and estheticians regarding injections and incisions, addressing safety concerns regarding unauthorized procedures. Members actively debated the merits of these bills, with several voiced concerns about the implications for public health and safety. The meeting also saw the passage of several bills without opposition, indicating a generally collaborative atmosphere among members.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
AdministrationAudio only. May 23rd, 2025
Transcript Highlights:
- ="13" data-time="112">Not sure if y'all know a lot about it, but it was a nuisance to the state of Texas
The state of Texas allows the officers to...
- span> ...work and they have to live their lives, and the State of Texas
- H.C.R. 59 designates April as Promise Month in Texas, a time to recognize and celebrate the enduring.
- Aviation and Defense Capital of Texas for a 10-year period
Keywords:
Small Business Saturday, HCR 9, HCR 135, Banana Pudding Capital, vehicle tag fraud, public testimony, community initiatives, Senate Committee on Administration
Summary:
The meeting of the Senate Committee on Administration focused on multiple resolutions, including the designation of important dates and recognitions for communities across Texas. HCR 9, pushed by Senator Hinojosa, proposed the first Saturday of each month to be designated as 'Small Business Saturday', intended to support local businesses and foster community ties. The committee reported favorably on this resolution, alongside others like HCR 135 which recognizes Slayton as the official 'Banana Pudding Capital of Texas'. Public testimony was held for several of the proposals, but most passed with little opposition, showcasing bipartisan support for promoting local initiatives.
Additionally, the meeting featured emotional testimony concerning HB 1135, which aims to combat fraud involving vehicle tags. Tawni Solberg spoke passionately about her son's tragic experience related to the misuse of temporary tags, underscoring the necessity for legislation that honors victims and prevents future incidents. The committee members expressed their sympathy and support, highlighting the bill's importance in ensuring safety and accountability on the roads. Overall, the atmosphere was collaborative, with a clear focus on generating positive outcomes for Texas communities.
TX
Texas 2025 - 89th Regular
Press Conference: Senators Royce West and Borris Miles Apr 2nd, 2025 at 06:00 am
Transcript Highlights:
- Of anything of that sort, you have said that in Texas it's okay not to care about diversity, not to care
- We know that Texas kind of leads the nation in policy development.
But the Senate, the state of Texas, had an opportunity
- We recommend it in the federal government, but using the Texas Workforce Commission to determine whether
- Of anything of that sort, you have said that in Texas it's
Keywords:
Senate Bill 688, Senate Bill 9, equity, meritocracy, social progress, policy reform, public testimony
Summary:
During this meeting of the committee, significant discussions centered around Senate Bill 688 and Senate Bill 9, with members expressing deep concerns over the implications of the proposed legislation. Chair Carol Alvarado initiated the meeting by addressing the audience and highlighting the need for robust dialogue regarding the bills in question. Senator Royce West actively contributed to the discussions, emphasizing the necessity to reform existing policies that some believe would regress social progress in the state. The debate revealed a passionate division among committee members, as they navigated the complexities of equity and meritocracy in legislation.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- I want to thank all the women of the Texas House who signed that rider.
- acuity behavioral health needs, providing resources to combat infectious disease across the state of Texas
- the House floor for our deliberation and ultimately addressing the needs of our public schools in Texas
- 864"> additional funds for work towards making higher education more affordable and accessible for Texas
- data-time="1278"> input and their thoughtful ideas in trying to address the needs of the state of Texas
Keywords:
Appropriations Committee, subcommittee reports, budget recommendations, crime victim services, military community support, juvenile probation, transparency, House rules
Summary:
The meeting of the Appropriations Committee focused on the adoption of subcommittee reports for various articles, emphasizing critical funding needs for Texas. Representative Gonzalez highlighted significant budget recommendations, including appropriations for crime victim services, military community support, and enhancements to juvenile probation departments. The adoption of several articles was met with a mixture of support and dissent, showcasing discussions surrounding the allocation of state resources and adherence to House rules regarding formal meeting records and transparency.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
The Texas Department of
- Okay, I show registered Audrey Vanderwaal from the Texas Chiropractic Association.
Interested is Corey Rose from the Texas Car Project Association- I'm here in support of House Bill 1642 on behalf of myself and the Texas Chiropractic Association.
- span>
I am a chiropractor that practices in New Braunfels, Texas
Bills:
HB854, HB1052, HB1642, HB2076, HB3042, HB3695, HB3787, HB4062, HB4092, SB213, SB493, SB896, HB5519, HB4635
Keywords:
insurance, replacement cost, homeowner's policy, renter's policy, condominium insurance, property damage, claims process, telemedicine, teledentistry, telehealth, health benefit plan, insurance coverage, out-of-state services, health benefit plan, anxiety, pain management, contraceptive devices, insurance coverage, women's health, medical procedures
Summary:
The meeting focused on House Bill 1642, which aims to establish an expedited credentialing process for chiropractors to help ensure patients receive timely treatment. Representative Cain presented the bill and emphasized that the lengthy credentialing delays harm patients seeking prompt care. Witnesses, including representatives from the Texas Chiropractic Association, voiced support for the bill, reiterating how essential it is for chiropractors to have the same expedited process available as other healthcare providers. The discussions highlighted the impact of delays in credentialing on patient care, particularly for those in pain, and proposed that the bill would alleviate these issues by enabling faster access to care for chiropractic patients.
The meeting also included public testimony, where individuals expressed their concerns about current delays and the financial burden on patients. Representative Cain responded to queries and emphasized the importance of passing the bill to prevent unnecessary suffering and provide patients with timely access to chiropractic services. Ultimately, HB 1642 was left pending, allowing for further consideration, and the meeting concluded with appreciation for the witnesses and attendees present.
TX
Transcript Highlights:
- It reflects our recommendations for the operation of the Texas Senate. Mr.
- solemnly swear that I will faithfully execute the duties of the office of the Senate of the State of Texas
- /span> Of the office, your office, of the Senate of the State of Texas
- Senator Eckhardt: ... bolstered by her affiliation with the American Academy of Family Medicine and the Texas
- Liu, thank you for volunteering your time, your expertise, and your care to the people of Texas today
Keywords:
SCR7, State Preservation Board, Plague of Honor, Children of the Confederacy, historical justice, legislative updates, committee assignments
Summary:
The committee meeting primarily focused on the discussion surrounding SCR7, which was introduced to direct the State Preservation Board to initiate steps for replacing the Children of the Confederacy Plague with a Plague of Honor recognizing victims of the State's convict leasing system. The resolution sparked notable conversations among members regarding its historical implications and the importance of addressing past injustices. Senators expressed their support for the resolution, recognizing the need for collective acknowledgment of the state's history.