Rhode Island 2023 Regular Session

Rhode Island House Bill H6059 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
11
22
33
44
5-2023 -- H 6059 SUBSTITUTE A
5+2023 -- H 6059
66 ========
7-LC002094/SUB A
7+LC002094
88 ========
99 S TATE OF RHODE IS LAND
1010 IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY
1111 JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2023
1212 ____________
1313
1414 A N A C T
1515 RELATING TO TOWNS AN D CITIES -- ZONING ORDINANCES
1616 Introduced By: Representatives Craven, Shekarchi, McGaw, Shanley, Dawson, and
1717 O'Brien
1818 Date Introduced: March 03, 2023
1919 Referred To: House Judiciary
2020
2121
2222 It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:
23-SECTION 1. Sections 45-24-31, 45-24-38, 45-24-40, 45-24-41, 45-24-42 and 45-24-46 of 1
24-the General Laws in Chapter 45-24 entitled "Zoning Ordinances" are hereby amended to read as 2
23+SECTION 1. Sections 45-24-31, 45-24-38, 45-24-41, 45-24-42 and 45-24-46 of the 1
24+General Laws in Chapter 45-24 entitled "Zoning Ordinances" are hereby amended to read as 2
2525 follows: 3
2626 45-24-31. Definitions. Definitions – Effective January 1, 2024. 4
2727 Where words or terms used in this chapter are defined in § 45-22.2-4 or 45-23-32, they 5
2828 have the meanings stated in that section. In addition, the following words have the following 6
2929 meanings. Additional words and phrases may be used in developing local ordinances under this 7
3030 chapter; however, the words and phrases defined in this section are controlling in all local 8
3131 ordinances created under this chapter: 9
3232 (1) Abutter. One whose property abuts, that is, adjoins at a border, boundary, or point with 10
3333 no intervening land. 11
3434 (2) Accessory dwelling unit (ADU). A residential living unit on the same parcel where the 12
3535 primary use is a legally established single-unit or multi-unit dwelling. An ADU provides complete 13
3636 independent living facilities for one or more persons. It may take various forms including, but not 14
3737 limited to: a detached unit; a unit that is part of an accessory structure, such as a detached garage; 15
3838 or a unit that is part of an expanded or remodeled primary dwelling. 16
3939 (3) Accessory use. A use of land or of a building, or portion thereof, customarily incidental 17
4040 and subordinate to the principal use of the land or building. An accessory use may be restricted to 18
4141 the same lot as the principal use. An accessory use shall not be permitted without the principal use 19
4242
4343
44-LC002094/SUB A - Page 2 of 16
44+LC002094 - Page 2 of 15
4545 to which it is related. 1
4646 (4) Aggrieved party. An aggrieved party, for purposes of this chapter, shall be: 2
4747 (i) Any person, or persons, or entity, or entities, who or that can demonstrate that his, her, 3
4848 or its property will be injured by a decision of any officer or agency responsible for administering 4
4949 the zoning ordinance of a city or town; or 5
5050 (ii) Anyone requiring notice pursuant to this chapter. 6
5151 (5) Agricultural land. “Agricultural land,” as defined in § 45-22.2-4. 7
5252 (6) Airport hazard area. “Airport hazard area,” as defined in § 1-3-2. 8
5353 (7) Applicant. An owner, or authorized agent of the owner, submitting an application or 9
5454 appealing an action of any official, board, or agency. 10
5555 (8) Application. The completed form, or forms, and all accompanying documents, exhibits, 11
5656 and fees required of an applicant by an approving authority for development review, approval, or 12
5757 permitting purposes. 13
5858 (9) Buffer. Land that is maintained in either a natural or landscaped state, and is used to 14
5959 screen or mitigate the impacts of development on surrounding areas, properties, or rights-of-way. 15
6060 (10) Building. Any structure used or intended for supporting or sheltering any use or 16
6161 occupancy. 17
6262 (11) Building envelope. The three-dimensional space within which a structure is permitted 18
6363 to be built on a lot and that is defined by regulations governing building setbacks, maximum height, 19
6464 and bulk; by other regulations; or by any combination thereof. 20
6565 (12) Building height. For a vacant parcel of land, building height shall be measured from 21
6666 the average, existing-grade elevation where the foundation of the structure is proposed. For an 22
6767 existing structure, building height shall be measured from average grade taken from the outermost 23
6868 four (4) corners of the existing foundation. In all cases, building height shall be measured to the top 24
6969 of the highest point of the existing or proposed roof or structure. This distance shall exclude spires, 25
7070 chimneys, flag poles, and the like. For any property or structure located in a special flood hazard 26
7171 area, as shown on the official FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs), or depicted on the 27
7272 Rhode Island coastal resources management council (CRMC) suggested design elevation three foot 28
7373 (3′) sea level rise (CRMC SDE 3 SLR) map as being inundated during a one-hundred-year (100) 29
7474 storm, the greater of the following amounts, expressed in feet, shall be excluded from the building 30
7575 height calculation: 31
7676 (i) The base flood elevation on the FEMA FIRM plus up to five feet (5′) of any utilized or 32
7777 proposed freeboard, less the average existing grade elevation; or 33
7878 (ii) The suggested design elevation as depicted on the CRMC SDE 3 SLR map during a 34
7979
8080
81-LC002094/SUB A - Page 3 of 16
81+LC002094 - Page 3 of 15
8282 one-hundred-year (100) storm, less the average existing grade elevation. CRMC shall reevaluate 1
8383 the appropriate suggested design elevation map for the exclusion every ten (10) years, or as 2
8484 otherwise necessary. 3
8585 (13) Cluster. A site-planning technique that concentrates buildings in specific areas on the 4
8686 site to allow the remaining land to be used for recreation, common open space, and/or preservation 5
8787 of environmentally, historically, culturally, or other sensitive features and/or structures. The 6
8888 techniques used to concentrate buildings shall be specified in the ordinance and may include, but 7
8989 are not limited to, reduction in lot areas, setback requirements, and/or bulk requirements, with the 8
9090 resultant open land being devoted by deed restrictions for one or more uses. Under cluster 9
9191 development, there is no increase in the number of lots that would be permitted under conventional 10
9292 development except where ordinance provisions include incentive bonuses for certain types or 11
9393 conditions of development. 12
9494 (14) Common ownership. Either: 13
9595 (i) Ownership by one or more individuals or entities in any form of ownership of two (2) 14
9696 or more contiguous lots; or 15
9797 (ii) Ownership by any association (ownership may also include a municipality) of one or 16
9898 more lots under specific development techniques. 17
9999 (15) Community residence. A home or residential facility where children and/or adults 18
100100 reside in a family setting and may or may not receive supervised care. This does not include halfway 19
101101 houses or substance-use-disorder-treatment facilities. This does include, but is not limited to, the 20
102102 following: 21
103103 (i) Whenever six (6) or fewer children or adults with intellectual and/or developmental 22
104104 disability reside in any type of residence in the community, as licensed by the state pursuant to 23
105105 chapter 24 of title 40.1. All requirements pertaining to local zoning are waived for these community 24
106106 residences; 25
107107 (ii) A group home providing care or supervision, or both, to not more than eight (8) persons 26
108108 with disabilities, and licensed by the state pursuant to chapter 24 of title 40.1; 27
109109 (iii) A residence for children providing care or supervision, or both, to not more than eight 28
110110 (8) children, including those of the caregiver, and licensed by the state pursuant to chapter 72.1 of 29
111111 title 42; 30
112112 (iv) A community transitional residence providing care or assistance, or both, to no more 31
113113 than six (6) unrelated persons or no more than three (3) families, not to exceed a total of eight (8) 32
114114 persons, requiring temporary financial assistance, and/or to persons who are victims of crimes, 33
115115 abuse, or neglect, and who are expected to reside in that residence not less than sixty (60) days nor 34
116116
117117
118-LC002094/SUB A - Page 4 of 16
118+LC002094 - Page 4 of 15
119119 more than two (2) years. Residents will have access to, and use of, all common areas, including 1
120120 eating areas and living rooms, and will receive appropriate social services for the purpose of 2
121121 fostering independence, self-sufficiency, and eventual transition to a permanent living situation. 3
122122 (16) Comprehensive plan. The comprehensive plan adopted and approved pursuant to 4
123123 chapter 22.2 of this title and to which any zoning adopted pursuant to this chapter shall be in 5
124124 compliance. 6
125125 (17) Day care — Daycare center. Any other daycare center that is not a family daycare 7
126126 home. 8
127127 (18) Day care — Family daycare home. Any home, other than the individual’s home, in 9
128128 which day care in lieu of parental care or supervision is offered at the same time to six (6) or less 10
129129 individuals who are not relatives of the caregiver, but may not contain more than a total of eight 11
130130 (8) individuals receiving day care. 12
131131 (19) Density, residential. The number of dwelling units per unit of land. 13
132132 (20) Development. The construction, reconstruction, conversion, structural alteration, 14
133133 relocation, or enlargement of any structure; any mining, excavation, landfill, or land disturbance; 15
134134 or any change in use, or alteration or extension of the use, of land. 16
135135 (21) Development plan review. The process whereby authorized, local officials review the 17
136136 site plans, maps, and other documentation of a development to determine the compliance with the 18
137137 stated purposes and standards of the ordinance. 19
138138 (22) District. See “zoning-use district.” 20
139139 (23) Drainage system. A system for the removal of water from land by drains, grading, or 21
140140 other appropriate means. These techniques may include runoff controls to minimize erosion and 22
141141 sedimentation during and after construction or development; the means for preserving surface and 23
142142 groundwaters; and the prevention and/or alleviation of flooding. 24
143143 (24) Dwelling unit. A structure, or portion of a structure, providing complete, independent 25
144144 living facilities for one or more persons, including permanent provisions for living, sleeping, eating, 26
145145 cooking, and sanitation, and containing a separate means of ingress and egress. 27
146146 (25) Extractive industry. The extraction of minerals, including: solids, such as coal and 28
147147 ores; liquids, such as crude petroleum; and gases, such as natural gases. The term also includes 29
148148 quarrying; well operation; milling, such as crushing, screening, washing, and flotation; and other 30
149149 preparation customarily done at the extraction site or as a part of the extractive activity. 31
150150 (26) Family member. A person, or persons, related by blood, marriage, or other legal 32
151151 means, including, but not limited to, a child, parent, spouse, mother-in-law, father-in-law, 33
152152 grandparents, grandchildren, domestic partner, sibling, care recipient, or member of the household. 34
153153
154154
155-LC002094/SUB A - Page 5 of 16
155+LC002094 - Page 5 of 15
156156 (27) Floating zone. An unmapped zoning district adopted within the ordinance that is 1
157157 established on the zoning map only when an application for development, meeting the zone 2
158158 requirements, is approved. 3
159159 (28) Floodplains, or Flood hazard area. As defined in § 45-22.2-4. 4
160160 (29) Freeboard. A factor of safety expressed in feet above the base flood elevation of a 5
161161 flood hazard area for purposes of floodplain management. Freeboard compensates for the many 6
162162 unknown factors that could contribute to flood heights, such as wave action, bridge openings, and 7
163163 the hydrological effect of urbanization of the watershed. 8
164164 (30) Groundwater. “Groundwater” and associated terms, as defined in § 46-13.1-3. 9
165165 (31) Halfway house. A residential facility for adults or children who have been 10
166166 institutionalized for criminal conduct and who require a group setting to facilitate the transition to 11
167167 a functional member of society. 12
168168 (32) Hardship. See § 45-24-41. 13
169169 (33) Historic district or historic site. As defined in § 45-22.2-4. 14
170170 (34) Home occupation. Any activity customarily carried out for gain by a resident, 15
171171 conducted as an accessory use in the resident’s dwelling unit. 16
172172 (35) Household. One or more persons living together in a single-dwelling unit, with 17
173173 common access to, and common use of, all living and eating areas and all areas and facilities for 18
174174 the preparation and storage of food within the dwelling unit. The term “household unit” is 19
175175 synonymous with the term “dwelling unit” for determining the number of units allowed within any 20
176176 structure on any lot in a zoning district. An individual household shall consist of any one of the 21
177177 following: 22
178178 (i) A family, which may also include servants and employees living with the family; or 23
179179 (ii) A person or group of unrelated persons living together. The maximum number may be 24
180180 set by local ordinance, but this maximum shall not be less than three (3). 25
181181 (36) Incentive zoning. The process whereby the local authority may grant additional 26
182182 development capacity in exchange for the developer’s provision of a public benefit or amenity as 27
183183 specified in local ordinances. 28
184184 (37) Infrastructure. Facilities and services needed to sustain residential, commercial, 29
185185 industrial, institutional, and other activities. 30
186186 (38) Land-development project. A project in which one or more lots, tracts, or parcels of 31
187187 land are developed or redeveloped as a coordinated site for one or more uses, units, or structures, 32
188188 including, but not limited to, planned development or cluster development for residential, 33
189189 commercial, institutional, recreational, open space, or mixed uses as provided in the zoning 34
190190
191191
192-LC002094/SUB A - Page 6 of 16
192+LC002094 - Page 6 of 15
193193 ordinance. 1
194194 (39) Lot. Either: 2
195195 (i) The basic development unit for determination of lot area, depth, and other dimensional 3
196196 regulations; or 4
197197 (ii) A parcel of land whose boundaries have been established by some legal instrument, 5
198198 such as a recorded deed or recorded map, and that is recognized as a separate legal entity for 6
199199 purposes of transfer of title. 7
200200 (40) Lot area. The total area within the boundaries of a lot, excluding any street right-of-8
201201 way, usually reported in acres or square feet. 9
202202 (41) Lot area, minimum. The smallest land area established by the local zoning ordinance 10
203203 upon which a use, building, or structure may be located in a particular zoning district. 11
204204 (42) Lot building coverage. That portion of the lot that is, or may be, covered by buildings 12
205205 and accessory buildings. 13
206206 (43) Lot depth. The distance measured from the front lot line to the rear lot line. For lots 14
207207 where the front and rear lot lines are not parallel, the lot depth is an average of the depth. 15
208208 (44) Lot frontage. That portion of a lot abutting a street. A zoning ordinance shall specify 16
209209 how noncontiguous frontage will be considered with regard to minimum frontage requirements. 17
210210 (45) Lot line. A line of record, bounding a lot, that divides one lot from another lot or from 18
211211 a public or private street or any other public or private space and shall include: 19
212212 (i) Front: the lot line separating a lot from a street right-of-way. A zoning ordinance shall 20
213213 specify the method to be used to determine the front lot line on lots fronting on more than one 21
214214 street, for example, corner and through lots; 22
215215 (ii) Rear: the lot line opposite and most distant from the front lot line, or in the case of 23
216216 triangular or otherwise irregularly shaped lots, an assumed line at least ten feet (10′) in length 24
217217 entirely within the lot, parallel to and at a maximum distance from, the front lot line; and 25
218218 (iii) Side: any lot line other than a front or rear lot line. On a corner lot, a side lot line may 26
219219 be a street lot line, depending on requirements of the local zoning ordinance. 27
220220 (46) Lot size, minimum. Shall have the same meaning as “minimum lot area” defined 28
221221 herein. 29
222222 (47) Lot, through. A lot that fronts upon two (2) parallel streets, or that fronts upon two 30
223223 (2) streets that do not intersect at the boundaries of the lot. 31
224224 (48) Lot width. The horizontal distance between the side lines of a lot measured at right 32
225225 angles to its depth along a straight line parallel to the front lot line at the minimum front setback 33
226226 line. 34
227227
228228
229-LC002094/SUB A - Page 7 of 16
229+LC002094 - Page 7 of 15
230230 (49) Mere inconvenience. See § 45-24-41. 1
231231 (50) Mixed use. A mixture of land uses within a single development, building, or tract. 2
232232 (51) Modification. Permission granted and administered by the zoning enforcement officer 3
233233 of the city or town, and pursuant to the provisions of this chapter to grant a dimensional variance 4
234234 other than lot area requirements from the zoning ordinance to a limited degree as determined by 5
235235 the zoning ordinance of the city or town, but not to exceed twenty-five percent (25%) of each of 6
236236 the applicable dimensional requirements. 7
237237 (52) Nonconformance. A building, structure, or parcel of land, or use thereof, lawfully 8
238238 existing at the time of the adoption or amendment of a zoning ordinance and not in conformity with 9
239239 the provisions of that ordinance or amendment. Nonconformance is of only two (2) types: 10
240240 (i) Nonconforming by use: a lawfully established use of land, building, or structure that is 11
241241 not a permitted use in that zoning district. A building or structure containing more dwelling units 12
242242 than are permitted by the use regulations of a zoning ordinance is nonconformity by use; or 13
243243 (ii) Nonconforming by dimension: a building, structure, or parcel of land not in compliance 14
244244 with the dimensional regulations of the zoning ordinance. Dimensional regulations include all 15
245245 regulations of the zoning ordinance, other than those pertaining to the permitted uses. A building 16
246246 or structure containing more dwelling units than are permitted by the use regulations of a zoning 17
247247 ordinance is nonconforming by use; a building or structure containing a permitted number of 18
248248 dwelling units by the use regulations of the zoning ordinance, but not meeting the lot area per 19
249249 dwelling unit regulations, is nonconforming by dimension. 20
250250 (53) Overlay district. A district established in a zoning ordinance that is superimposed on 21
251251 one or more districts or parts of districts. The standards and requirements associated with an overlay 22
252252 district may be more or less restrictive than those in the underlying districts consistent with other 23
253253 applicable state and federal laws. 24
254254 (54) Performance standards. A set of criteria or limits relating to elements that a particular 25
255255 use or process must either meet or may not exceed. 26
256256 (55) Permitted use. A use by right that is specifically authorized in a particular zoning 27
257257 district. 28
258258 (56) Planned development. A “land-development project,” as defined in subsection (38), 29
259259 and developed according to plan as a single entity and containing one or more structures or uses 30
260260 with appurtenant common areas. 31
261261 (57) Plant agriculture. The growing of plants for food or fiber, to sell or consume. 32
262262 (58) Preapplication conference. A review meeting of a proposed development held 33
263263 between applicants and reviewing agencies as permitted by law and municipal ordinance, before 34
264264
265265
266-LC002094/SUB A - Page 8 of 16
266+LC002094 - Page 8 of 15
267267 formal submission of an application for a permit or for development approval. 1
268268 (59) Setback line or lines. A line, or lines, parallel to a lot line at the minimum distance of 2
269269 the required setback for the zoning district in which the lot is located that establishes the area within 3
270270 which the principal structure must be erected or placed. 4
271271 (60) Site plan. The development plan for one or more lots on which is shown the existing 5
272272 and/or the proposed conditions of the lot. 6
273273 (61) Slope of land. The grade, pitch, rise, or incline of the topographic landform or surface 7
274274 of the ground. 8
275275 (62) Special use. A regulated use that is permitted pursuant to the special-use permit issued 9
276276 by the authorized governmental entity, pursuant to § 45-24-42. Formerly referred to as a special 10
277277 exception. 11
278278 (63) Structure. A combination of materials to form a construction for use, occupancy, or 12
279279 ornamentation, whether installed on, above, or below the surface of land or water. 13
280280 (64) Substandard lot of record. Any lot lawfully existing at the time of adoption or 14
281281 amendment of a zoning ordinance and not in conformance with the dimensional or area provisions 15
282282 of that ordinance. 16
283283 (65) Use. The purpose or activity for which land or buildings are designed, arranged, or 17
284284 intended, or for which land or buildings are occupied or maintained. 18
285285 (66) Variance. Permission to depart from the literal requirements of a zoning ordinance. 19
286286 An authorization for the construction or maintenance of a building or structure, or for the 20
287287 establishment or maintenance of a use of land, that is prohibited by a zoning ordinance. There are 21
288288 only two (2) categories of variance, a use variance or a dimensional variance. 22
289289 (i) Use variance. Permission to depart from the use requirements of a zoning ordinance 23
290290 where the applicant for the requested variance has shown by evidence upon the record that the 24
291291 subject land or structure cannot yield any beneficial use if it is to conform to the provisions of the 25
292292 zoning ordinance. 26
293293 (ii) Dimensional variance. Permission to depart from the dimensional requirements of a 27
294294 zoning ordinance, where the applicant for the requested relief has shown, by evidence upon the 28
295295 record, that there is no other reasonable alternative way to enjoy a legally permitted beneficial use 29
296296 of the subject property unless granted the requested relief from the dimensional regulations. 30
297297 However, the fact that a use may be more profitable or that a structure may be more valuable after 31
298-the relief is granted are not grounds for relief under the applicable standards set forth in § 45-24-32
299-41. 33
298+the relief is granted are not grounds for relief where the applicant has made a showing as set forth 32
299+in § 45-24-41. 33
300300 (67) Waters. As defined in § 46-12-1(23). 34
301301
302302
303-LC002094/SUB A - Page 9 of 16
303+LC002094 - Page 9 of 15
304304 (68) Wetland, coastal. As defined in § 45-22.2-4. 1
305305 (69) Wetland, freshwater. As defined in § 2-1-20. 2
306306 (70) Zoning certificate. A document signed by the zoning-enforcement officer, as required 3
307307 in the zoning ordinance, that acknowledges that a use, structure, building, or lot either complies 4
308308 with, or is legally nonconforming to, the provisions of the municipal zoning ordinance or is an 5
309309 authorized variance or modification therefrom. 6
310310 (71) Zoning map. The map, or maps, that are a part of the zoning ordinance and that 7
311311 delineate the boundaries of all mapped zoning districts within the physical boundary of the city or 8
312312 town. 9
313313 (72) Zoning ordinance. An ordinance enacted by the legislative body of the city or town 10
314314 pursuant to this chapter and in the manner providing for the adoption of ordinances in the city or 11
315315 town’s legislative or home rule charter, if any, that establish regulations and standards relating to 12
316316 the nature and extent of uses of land and structures; that is consistent with the comprehensive plan 13
317317 of the city or town as defined in chapter 22.2 of this title; that includes a zoning map; and that 14
318318 complies with the provisions of this chapter. 15
319319 (73) Zoning-use district. The basic unit in zoning, either mapped or unmapped, to which 16
320320 a uniform set of regulations applies, or a uniform set of regulations for a specified use. Zoning-use 17
321321 districts include, but are not limited to: agricultural, commercial, industrial, institutional, open 18
322322 space, and residential. Each district may include sub-districts. Districts may be combined. 19
323323 45-24-38. General provisions — Substandard lots of record General provisions -- 20
324324 Substandard lots of record -- Effective January 1, 2024. 21
325325 (a) Any city or town adopting or amending a zoning ordinance under this chapter shall 22
326326 regulate the use or uses development of any single substandard lot of record or contiguous lots of 23
327327 record at the effective date of adoption or amendment of the zoning ordinance. 24
328328 (b) Notwithstanding notwithstanding the failure of that lot or those lots to meet the 25
329329 dimensional and/or quantitative requirements, and/or road frontage or other access requirements, 26
330330 applicable in the district as stated in the ordinance, a substandard lot of record shall not be required 27
331331 to seek any zoning relief based solely on the failure to meet minimum lot size requirements of the 28
332-district in which such lot is located. The setback, frontage, and/or lot width requirements for a 29
333-structure under this section shall be reduced and the maximum building coverage requirements 30
334-shall be increased by the same proportion as the lot area of the substandard lot is to the minimum 31
335-lot area requirement of the zoning district in which the lot is located. All proposals exceeding such 32
336-reduced requirement shall proceed with a modification request under § 45-24-46 or a dimensional 33
337-variance request under § 45-24-41, whichever is applicable. 34
332+district in which such lot is located. As to other dimensional requirements for lots not meeting 29
333+minimum lot size requirements, such shall be reduced by the same ratio as the substandard lot area 30
334+is to the required lot size of the zoning district. All proposals exceeding such reduced ratio shall 31
335+proceed with a modification request under § 45-24-46 or a dimensional variance request under § 32
336+45-24-41, whichever is applicable. 33
337+(c) Provisions may be made for the merger of contiguous unimproved, or improved and 34
338338
339339
340-LC002094/SUB A - Page 10 of 16
341-(c) Provisions may be made for the merger of contiguous unimproved, or improved and 1
342-unimproved, substandard lots of record in the same ownership to create dimensionally conforming 2
343-lots or to reduce the extent of dimensional nonconformance. The ordinance shall specify the 3
344-standards, on a district by district basis, which determine the mergers. The standards include, but 4
345-are not to be limited to, the availability of infrastructure, the character of the neighborhood, and the 5
346-consistency with the comprehensive plan. The merger of lots shall not be required when the 6
347-substandard lot of record has an area equal to or greater than the area of fifty percent (50%) of the 7
348-lots within two hundred feet (200') of the subject lot, as confirmed by the zoning enforcement 8
349-officer. 9
350-45-24-40. General provisions — Alteration of nonconforming development. General 10
351-provisions — Alteration of nonconforming development; Alteration of uses established by 11
352-variance or special use permit — Effective January 1, 2024. 12
353-(a) A zoning ordinance may permit a nonconforming development to be altered under 13
354-either of the following conditions: 14
355-(1) The ordinance may establish a special-use permit, authorizing the alteration, which 15
356-must be approved by the zoning board of review following the procedure established in this chapter 16
357-and in the zoning ordinance; or 17
358-(2) The ordinance may allow the addition and enlargement, expansion, intensification, or 18
359-change in use, of nonconforming development either by permit or by right and may distinguish 19
360-between the foregoing actions by zoning districts. 20
361-(b) The ordinance may require that the alteration more closely adheres to the intent and 21
362-purposes of the zoning ordinance. 22
363-(c) A use established by variance or special use permit shall not acquire the rights of this 23
364-section, unless allowed by specific provisions of a municipal zoning ordinance. 24
365-45-24-41. General provisions — Variances. General provisions -Variances – Effective 25
366-January 1, 2024. 26
367-(a) An application for relief from the literal requirements of a zoning ordinance because of 27
368-hardship may be made by any person, group, agency, or corporation by filing with the zoning 28
369-enforcement officer or agency an application describing the request and supported by any data and 29
370-evidence as may be required by the zoning board of review or by the terms of the ordinance. The 30
371-zoning enforcement officer or agency shall immediately transmit each application received to the 31
372-zoning board of review and a copy of each application to the planning board or commission. 32
373-(b) A zoning ordinance provides that the zoning board of review, immediately upon receipt 33
374-of an application for a variance in the application of the literal terms of the zoning ordinance, may 34
340+LC002094 - Page 10 of 15
341+unimproved, substandard lots of record in the same ownership to create dimensionally conforming 1
342+lots or to reduce the extent of dimensional nonconformance. The ordinance shall specify the 2
343+standards, on a district by district basis, which determine the mergers. The standards include, but 3
344+are not to be limited to, the availability of infrastructure, the character of the neighborhood, and the 4
345+consistency with the comprehensive plan. The merger of lots shall not be permitted when more 5
346+than fifty percent (50%) of the lots within two hundred feet (200') of the property line are similarly 6
347+sized to the substandard lot of record. 7
348+45-24-41. General provisions — Variances. General provisions -Variances – Effective 8
349+January 1, 2024. 9
350+(a) An application for relief from the literal requirements of a zoning ordinance because of 10
351+hardship may be made by any person, group, agency, or corporation by filing with the zoning 11
352+enforcement officer or agency an application describing the request and supported by any data and 12
353+evidence as may be required by the zoning board of review or by the terms of the ordinance. The 13
354+zoning enforcement officer or agency shall immediately transmit each application received to the 14
355+zoning board of review and a copy of each application to the planning board or commission. 15
356+(b) A zoning ordinance provides that the zoning board of review, immediately upon receipt 16
357+of an application for a variance in the application of the literal terms of the zoning ordinance, may 17
358+request that the planning board or commission and/or staff report its findings and recommendations, 18
359+including a statement on the general consistency of the application with the goals and purposes of 19
360+the comprehensive plan of the city or town, in writing, to the zoning board of review within thirty 20
361+(30) days of receipt of the application from that board. The zoning board shall hold a public hearing 21
362+on any application for variance in an expeditious manner, after receipt, in proper form, of an 22
363+application, and shall give public notice at least fourteen (14) days prior to the date of the hearing 23
364+in a newspaper of general circulation in the city or town. Notice of hearing shall be sent by first-24
365+class mail to the applicant, and to at least all those who would require notice under § 45-24-53. The 25
366+notice shall also include the street address of the subject property. A zoning ordinance may require 26
367+that a supplemental notice, that an application for a variance is under consideration, be posted at 27
368+the location in question. The posting is for information purposes only and does not constitute 28
369+required notice of a public hearing. The cost of notification shall be borne by the applicant. 29
370+(c) A zoning ordinance may provide for unified development review, pursuant to § 45-24-30
371+46.4. Requests for dimensional and use variances submitted under a unified development review 31
372+provision of a zoning ordinance shall be submitted as part of the subdivision or land-development 32
373+application to the administrative officer of the planning board or commission, pursuant to § 45-24-33
374+46.4(a). All subdivision or land-development applications submitted under the unified development 34
375375
376376
377-LC002094/SUB A - Page 11 of 16
378-request that the planning board or commission and/or staff report its findings and recommendations, 1
379-including a statement on the general consistency of the application with the goals and purposes of 2
380-the comprehensive plan of the city or town, in writing, to the zoning board of review within thirty 3
381-(30) days of receipt of the application from that board. The zoning board shall hold a public hearing 4
382-on any application for variance in an expeditious manner, after receipt, in proper form, of an 5
383-application, and shall give public notice at least fourteen (14) days prior to the date of the hearing 6
384-in a newspaper of general circulation in the city or town. Notice of hearing shall be sent by first-7
385-class mail to the applicant, and to at least all those who would require notice under § 45-24-53. The 8
386-notice shall also include the street address of the subject property. A zoning ordinance may require 9
387-that a supplemental notice, that an application for a variance is under consideration, be posted at 10
388-the location in question. The posting is for information purposes only and does not constitute 11
389-required notice of a public hearing. The cost of notification shall be borne by the applicant. 12
390-(c) A zoning ordinance may provide for unified development review, pursuant to § 45-24-13
391-46.4. Requests for dimensional and use variances submitted under a unified development review 14
392-provision of a zoning ordinance shall be submitted as part of the subdivision or land-development 15
393-application to the administrative officer of the planning board or commission, pursuant to § 45-24-16
394-46.4(a). All subdivision or land-development applications submitted under the unified development 17
395-review provisions of a zoning ordinance shall have a public hearing, which shall meet the 18
396-requirements of § 45-23-50.1(c). 19
397-(d) In granting a variance, the zoning board of review, or, where unified development 20
398-review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-46.4, the planning board or commission, shall require that 21
399-evidence to the satisfaction of the following standards is entered into the record of the proceedings: 22
400-(1) That the hardship from which the applicant seeks relief is due to the unique 23
401-characteristics of the subject land or structure and not to the general characteristics of the 24
402-surrounding area; and is not due to a physical or economic disability of the applicant, excepting 25
403-those physical disabilities addressed in § 45-24-30(a)(16); 26
404-(2) That the hardship is not the result of any prior action of the applicant and does not result 27
405-primarily from the desire of the applicant to realize greater financial gain; and 28
406-(3) That the granting of the requested variance will not alter the general character of the 29
407-surrounding area or impair the intent or purpose of the zoning ordinance or the comprehensive plan 30
408-upon which the ordinance is based; and 31
409-(4) That the relief to be granted is the least relief necessary. 32
410-(e) The zoning board of review, or, where unified development review is enabled pursuant 33
411-to § 45-24-46.4, the planning board or commission, shall, in addition to the above standards, require 34
377+LC002094 - Page 11 of 15
378+review provisions of a zoning ordinance shall have a public hearing, which shall meet the 1
379+requirements of § 45-23-50.1(c). 2
380+(d) In granting a variance, the zoning board of review, or, where unified development 3
381+review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-46.4, the planning board or commission, shall require that 4
382+evidence to the satisfaction of the following standards is entered into the record of the proceedings: 5
383+(1) That the hardship from which the applicant seeks relief is due to the unique 6
384+characteristics of the subject land or structure and not to the general characteristics of the 7
385+surrounding area; and is not due to a physical or economic disability of the applicant, excepting 8
386+those physical disabilities addressed in § 45-24-30(a)(16); 9
387+(2) That the hardship is not the result of any prior action of the applicant and does not result 10
388+primarily from the desire of the applicant to realize greater financial gain; and 11
389+(3) That the granting of the requested variance will not alter the general character of the 12
390+surrounding area or impair the intent or purpose of the zoning ordinance or the comprehensive plan 13
391+upon which the ordinance is based; and 14
392+(4) That the relief to be granted is the least relief necessary. 15
393+(e) The zoning board of review, or, where unified development review is enabled pursuant 16
394+to § 45-24-46.4, the planning board or commission, shall, in addition to the above standards, require 17
395+that evidence is entered into the record of the proceedings showing that: 18
396+(1) In granting a use variance, the subject land or structure cannot yield any beneficial use 19
397+if it is required to conform to the provisions of the zoning ordinance. Nonconforming use of 20
398+neighboring land or structures in the same district and permitted use of lands or structures in an 21
399+adjacent district shall not be considered in granting a use variance; and 22
400+(2) In granting a dimensional variance, that the hardship suffered by the owner of the 23
401+subject property if the dimensional variance is not granted amounts to more than a mere 24
402+inconvenience. The fact that a use may be more profitable or that a structure may be more valuable 25
403+after the relief is granted is not grounds for relief. The zoning board of review, or, where unified 26
404+development review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-46.4, the planning board or commission has the 27
405+power to grant dimensional variances where the use is permitted by special-use permit if provided 28
406+for in the special use permit sections of the zoning ordinance. 29
407+45-24-42. General provisions — Special-use permits General provisions -- Special-use 30
408+permits -- Effective January 1, 2024. 31
409+(a) A zoning ordinance shall provide for the issuance of special-use permits approved by 32
410+the zoning board of review, or, where unified development review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-33
411+46.4, the planning board or commission. 34
412412
413413
414-LC002094/SUB A - Page 12 of 16
415-that evidence is entered into the record of the proceedings showing that: 1
416-(1) In granting a use variance, the subject land or structure cannot yield any beneficial use 2
417-if it is required to conform to the provisions of the zoning ordinance. Nonconforming use of 3
418-neighboring land or structures in the same district and permitted use of lands or structures in an 4
419-adjacent district shall not be considered in granting a use variance; and 5
420-(2) In granting a dimensional variance, that the hardship suffered by the owner of the 6
421-subject property if the dimensional variance is not granted amounts to more than a mere 7
422-inconvenience, meaning that relief sought is minimal to a reasonable enjoyment of the permitted 8
423-use to which the property is proposed to be devoted. The fact that a use may be more profitable or 9
424-that a structure may be more valuable after the relief is granted is not grounds for relief. The zoning 10
425-board of review, or, where unified development review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-46.4, the 11
426-planning board or commission has the power to grant dimensional variances where the use is 12
427-permitted by special-use permit if provided for in the special use permit sections of the zoning 13
428-ordinance. 14
429-45-24-42. General provisions — Special-use permits General provisions -- Special-use 15
430-permits -- Effective January 1, 2024. 16
431-(a) A zoning ordinance shall provide for the issuance of special-use permits approved by 17
432-the zoning board of review, or, where unified development review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-18
433-46.4, the planning board or commission. 19
434-(b) The ordinance shall: 20
435-(1) Specify the uses requiring special-use permits in each district. The ordinance may shall 21
436-provide for a procedure under which a proposed land use that is not specifically listed may be 22
437-presented by the property owner to the zoning board of review or to a local official or agency 23
438-charged with administration and enforcement of the ordinance for an evaluation and determination 24
439-of whether the proposed use is of a similar type, character, and intensity as a listed use requiring a 25
440-special-use permit. Upon such determination, the proposed use may be considered to be a use 26
441-requiring a special-use permit; 27
442-(2) Describe the conditions and procedures under which special-use permits, of each of the 28
443-various categories of special-use permits established in the zoning ordinance, may shall be issued; 29
444-(3) Establish specific and objective criteria for the issuance of each type of use category of 30
445-special-use permit that, which criteria shall be in conformance with the purposes and intent of the 31
446-comprehensive plan and the zoning ordinance of the city or town; however, in no case shall any 32
447-specific and objective criteria for a special use permit include a determination of consistency with 33
448-the comprehensive plan; 34
414+LC002094 - Page 12 of 15
415+(b) The ordinance shall: 1
416+(1) Specify the uses requiring special-use permits in each district. The ordinance may shall 2
417+provide for a procedure under which a proposed land use that is not specifically listed may be 3
418+presented by the property owner to the zoning board of review or to a local official or agency 4
419+charged with administration and enforcement of the ordinance for an evaluation and determination 5
420+of whether the proposed use is of a similar type, character, and intensity as a listed use requiring a 6
421+special-use permit. Upon such determination, the proposed use may be considered to be a use 7
422+requiring a special-use permit; 8
423+(2) Describe the conditions and procedures under which special-use permits, of each of the 9
424+various categories of special-use permits established in the zoning ordinance, may shall be issued; 10
425+(3) Establish specific and objective criteria for the issuance of each category of special-use 11
426+permit that which criteria shall be in conformance with the purposes and intent of the 12
427+comprehensive plan and the zoning ordinance of the city or town; however, in no case shall any 13
428+specific and objective criteria for a special use permit include a determination of consistency with 14
429+the comprehensive plan; 15
430+(4) Provide for public hearings and notification of the date, time, place, and purpose of 16
431+those hearings to interested parties. Special-use permit requests submitted under a zoning 17
432+ordinance’s unified development review provisions shall be heard and noticed in conjunction with 18
433+the subdivision or land-development application, according to the requirements of § 45-23-50.1. 19
434+Public notice for special-use permits that are not submitted under a zoning ordinance’s unified 20
435+development review provisions shall be given at least fourteen (14) days prior to the date of the 21
436+hearing in a newspaper of general circulation in the city or town. Notice of hearing shall be sent by 22
437+first-class mail to the applicant, and to all those who would require notice under § 45-24-53. The 23
438+notice shall also include the street address of the subject property. A zoning ordinance may require 24
439+that a supplemental notice, that an application for a special-use permit is under consideration, be 25
440+posted at the location in question. The posting is for information purposes only and does not 26
441+constitute required notice of a public hearing. The cost of notification shall be borne by the 27
442+applicant; 28
443+(5) Provide for the recording of findings of fact and written decisions; and 29
444+(6) Provide that appeals may be taken pursuant to § 45-24-70 or § 45-23-66, dependent on 30
445+the board to which application was made. 31
446+(c) If an ordinance does not expressly provide for specific and objective criteria for the 32
447+issuance of a category of special use permit such category shall be deemed to be permitted use. 33
448+(c)(d) The ordinance additionally may provide that an applicant may shall apply for, and 34
449449
450450
451-LC002094/SUB A - Page 13 of 16
452-(4) Provide for public hearings and notification of the date, time, place, and purpose of 1
453-those hearings to interested parties. Special-use permit requests submitted under a zoning 2
454-ordinance’s unified development review provisions shall be heard and noticed in conjunction with 3
455-the subdivision or land-development application, according to the requirements of § 45-23-50.1. 4
456-Public notice for special-use permits that are not submitted under a zoning ordinance’s unified 5
457-development review provisions shall be given at least fourteen (14) days prior to the date of the 6
458-hearing in a newspaper of general circulation in the city or town. Notice of hearing shall be sent by 7
459-first-class mail to the applicant, and to all those who would require notice under § 45-24-53. The 8
460-notice shall also include the street address of the subject property. A zoning ordinance may require 9
461-that a supplemental notice, that an application for a special-use permit is under consideration, be 10
462-posted at the location in question. The posting is for information purposes only and does not 11
463-constitute required notice of a public hearing. The cost of notification shall be borne by the 12
464-applicant; 13
465-(5) Provide for the recording of findings of fact and written decisions; and 14
466-(6) Provide that appeals may be taken pursuant to § 45-24-70 or § 45-23-66, dependent on 15
467-the board to which application was made. 16
468-(c) If an ordinance does not expressly provide for specific and objective criteria for the 17
469-issuance of a category of special use permit such category shall be deemed to be permitted use. 18
470-(c)(d) The ordinance additionally may shall provide that an applicant may apply for, and 19
471-be issued, a dimensional variance in conjunction with a special-use permit. If the special use could 20
472-not exist without the dimensional variance, the zoning board of review, or, where unified 21
473-development review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-46.4(b), the planning board or commission shall 22
474-consider the special-use permit and the dimensional variance together to determine if granting the 23
475-special use is appropriate based on both the special use criteria and the dimensional variance 24
476-evidentiary standards. 25
477-45-24-46. Special provisions — Modification Special provisions -- Modification -- 26
478-Effective January 1 2024. 27
479-(a) A zoning ordinance may shall provide for the issuance of modifications or adjustments 28
480-from the literal dimensional requirements of the zoning ordinance in the instance of the 29
481-construction, alteration, or structural modification of a structure or lot of record. If the ordinance 30
482-allows modifications then the The zoning enforcement officer is authorized to grant modification 31
483-permits. The zoning ordinance establishes the maximum percent allowed for a modification, which 32
484-shall not exceed twenty-five percent (25%), of any of shall permit modifications that are fifteen 33
485-percent (15%) or less of the dimensional requirements specified in the zoning ordinance but may 34
451+LC002094 - Page 13 of 15
452+be issued, a dimensional variance in conjunction with a special-use permit. If the special use could 1
453+not exist without the dimensional variance, the zoning board of review, or, where unified 2
454+development review is enabled pursuant to § 45-24-46.4(b), the planning board or commission shall 3
455+consider the special-use permit and the dimensional variance together to determine if granting the 4
456+special use is appropriate based on both the special use criteria and the dimensional variance 5
457+evidentiary standards. 6
458+45-24-46. Special provisions — Modification Special provisions -- Modification -- 7
459+Effective January 1 2024. 8
460+(a) A zoning ordinance may shall provide for the issuance of modifications or adjustments 9
461+from the literal dimensional requirements of the zoning ordinance in the instance of the 10
462+construction, alteration, or structural modification of a structure or lot of record. If the ordinance 11
463+allows modifications then the The zoning enforcement officer is authorized to grant modification 12
464+permits. The zoning ordinance establishes the maximum percent allowed for a modification, which 13
465+shall not exceed twenty-five percent (25%), but not less than fifteen percent (15%), of any of the 14
466+dimensional requirements specified in the zoning ordinance. A modification does not permit 15
467+moving of lot lines. The zoning ordinance shall specify which dimensional requirements or 16
468+combinations of these requirements are allowable under a modification. These requirements may 17
469+differ by use or zoning district. Within ten (10) days of the receipt of a request for a modification, 18
470+the zoning enforcement officer shall make a decision as to the suitability of the requested 19
471+modification based on the following determinations: 20
472+(1) The modification requested is reasonably necessary for the full enjoyment of the 21
473+permitted use; 22
474+(2) If the modification is granted, neighboring property will neither be substantially injured 23
475+nor its appropriate use substantially impaired; 24
476+(3) The modification requested is in harmony with the purposes and intent of the 25
477+comprehensive plan and zoning ordinance of the city or town does not require a variance of a flood 26
478+hazard requirement, unless the building is built in accordance with applicable regulations; and 27
479+(4) The modification requested does not require a variance of a flood hazard requirement 28
480+violate any rules or regulations with respect to freshwater wetlands. 29
481+(b) Upon an affirmative determination, the zoning enforcement officer shall notify, by 30
482+registered or certified mail, all property owners abutting the property which is the subject of the 31
483+modification request, and shall indicate the street address of the subject property in the notice, and 32
484+shall publish in a newspaper of general circulation within the city or town that the modification will 33
485+be granted unless written objection is received within thirty (30) fourteen (14) days of the public 34
486486
487487
488-LC002094/SUB A - Page 14 of 16
489-permit modification up to twenty-five percent (25%). A modification does not permit moving of 1
490-lot lines. The zoning ordinance shall specify which dimensional requirements or combinations of 2
491-these requirements are allowable under a modification. These requirements may differ by use or 3
492-zoning district. Within ten (10) days of the receipt of a request for a modification, the zoning 4
493-enforcement officer shall make a decision as to the suitability of the requested modification based 5
494-on the following determinations: 6
495-(1) The modification requested is reasonably necessary for the full enjoyment of the 7
496-permitted use; 8
497-(2) If the modification is granted, neighboring property will neither be substantially injured 9
498-nor its appropriate use substantially impaired; 10
499-(3) The modification requested is in harmony with the purposes and intent of the 11
500-comprehensive plan and zoning ordinance of the city or town does not require a variance of a flood 12
501-hazard requirement, unless the building is built in accordance with applicable regulations; and 13
502-(4) The modification requested does not require a variance of a flood hazard requirement 14
503-violate any rules or regulations with respect to freshwater or coastal wetlands. 15
504-(b) Upon an affirmative determination, in the case of a modification of five percent (5%) 16
505-or less, the zoning enforcement officer shall have the authority to issue a permit approving the 17
506-modification, without any public notice requirements. In the case of a modification of greater than 18
507-five percent (5%), the zoning enforcement officer shall notify, by registered or certified first class 19
508-mail, all property owners abutting the property which is the subject of the modification request, and 20
509-shall indicate the street address of the subject property in the notice, and shall publish in a 21
510-newspaper of general local circulation within the city or town that the modification will be granted 22
511-unless written objection is received within thirty (30) fourteen (14) days of the public notice. If 23
512-written objection is received within thirty (30) fourteen (14) days, the request for a modification 24
513-shall be denied. scheduled for the next available hearing before the zoning board of review on 25
514-application for a dimensional variance In that case the changes requested will be considered a 26
515-request for a variance and may only be issued by the zoning board of review following the standard 27
516-procedures for such variances, including notice requirements provided for under this chapter. If no 28
517-written objections are received within thirty (30) fourteen (14) days, the zoning enforcement officer 29
518-shall grant the modification. The zoning enforcement officer may apply any special conditions to 30
519-the permit as may, in the opinion of the officer, be required to conform to the intent and purposes 31
520-of the zoning ordinance. The zoning enforcement officer shall keep public records of all requests 32
521-for modifications, and of findings, determinations, special conditions, and any objections received. 33
522-Costs of any notice required under this subsection shall be borne by the applicant requesting the 34
523-
524-
525-LC002094/SUB A - Page 15 of 16
526-modification. 1
527-SECTION 2. This act shall take effect on January 1, 2024. 2
488+LC002094 - Page 14 of 15
489+notice. If written objection is received within thirty (30) fourteen (14) days, the request for a 1
490+modification shall be denied. scheduled for the next available hearing before the zoning board of 2
491+review on application for a dimensional variance In that case the changes requested will be 3
492+considered a request for a variance and may only be issued by the zoning board of review following 4
493+the standard procedures for such variances, including notice requirements provided for under this 5
494+chapter. If no written objections are received within thirty (30) fourteen (14) days, the zoning 6
495+enforcement officer shall grant the modification. The zoning enforcement officer may apply any 7
496+special conditions to the permit as may, in the opinion of the officer, be required to conform to the 8
497+intent and purposes of the zoning ordinance. The zoning enforcement officer shall keep public 9
498+records of all requests for modifications, and of findings, determinations, special conditions, and 10
499+any objections received. Costs of any notice required under this subsection shall be borne by the 11
500+applicant requesting the modification. 12
501+SECTION 2. This act shall take effect on January 1, 2024. 13
528502 ========
529-LC002094/SUB A
503+LC002094
530504 ========
531505
532506
533-LC002094/SUB A - Page 16 of 16
507+LC002094 - Page 15 of 15
534508 EXPLANATION
535509 BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL
536510 OF
537511 A N A C T
538512 RELATING TO TOWNS AN D CITIES -- ZONING ORDINANCES
539513 ***
540514 This act would amend certain general laws relative to zoning ordinance and variances, 1
541515 special use permits, modifications thereto and also amend provisions relative to substandard lots of 2
542516 record and the merger of such lots. 3
543517 This act would take effect on January 1, 2024. 4
544518 ========
545-LC002094/SUB A
519+LC002094
546520 ========