Tennessee House Bill HB2509

Tennessee 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/30/24
• Refer: 2/1/24
• Refer: 3/19/24

Caption

AN ACT to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Section 29-13-105, relative to persons eligible for compensation.

Impact

If enacted, HB2509 would directly affect the eligibility criteria for compensation claims made under the Tennessee Code. The change aims to ensure that only victims of crimes who are not involved in the commission of the crime can receive restitution. This could lead to a decrease in fraudulent or unjust claims, thereby helping to uphold the integrity of the victims' compensation program. Additionally, the amendment could prompt discussions about the broader implications of victim rights and the treatment of those who have participated, in any capacity, in criminal acts.

Summary

House Bill 2509 proposes an amendment to Tennessee Code Annotated, Section 29-13-105, which outlines the criteria for individuals eligible for compensation related to crime. The key change introduced by this bill is the specification of categories under which individuals can be deemed ineligible to receive such compensation. This includes individuals who are criminally responsible for the crime, accomplices to the crime, accessories after the fact, or who have contributed to the crime in some manner. The intent of the bill is to clarify the eligibility standards and prevent individuals involved in criminal activity from receiving financial awards meant for victims.

Contention

The bill has the potential to spark debate around its fairness and the definition of involvement in a crime. Critics may argue that the language used to define ineligibility could be interpreted too broadly, possibly impacting individuals who are not primarily culpable but rather were minor participants in the crime. This could lead to situations where deserving victims are denied compensation due to their association with the act, raising concerns about the justice and practicality of such exclusions. Therefore, discussions surrounding HB2509 may explore the balance between preventing fraud and ensuring equitable treatment for victims.