Texas House Bill HB3384

Texas 2009 - 81st Regular

Caption

Relating to prior approval of residential property insurance rates of certain insurers.

Impact

The impact of HB3384 on state laws centers around the Insurance Code, particularly in how it reinforces the role of the insurance commissioner as a regulator of rate changes. This move is designed to protect consumers from sudden and significant rate hikes, especially in communities recovering from natural disasters. By mandating prior approval, the bill seeks to foster greater transparency and accountability among insurers, ultimately providing homeowners with more stable and predictable insurance costs in volatile situations.

Summary

House Bill 3384 introduces a critical regulatory change concerning residential property insurance rates in Texas, specifically targeting insurers who seek to adjust their rates following a natural disaster. The bill establishes a requirement that insurers must receive prior approval from the state's insurance commissioner before implementing rate increases that exceed five percent or newly established deductibles that are proportionate to the insured property's value. This provision aims to provide consumer protection and reduce the financial burden on homeowners during vulnerable times following disasters.

Contention

While proponents of HH3384 argue that it is necessary for protecting homeowners, some critics believe it may have unintended consequences. Concerns have been raised regarding potential negative impacts on insurer financial stability and the possibility that stricter regulations could lead to insurance providers withdrawing from high-risk areas. Others worry that the increased regulatory burden could discourage insurers from entering or remaining in the market, potentially exacerbating coverage gaps for Texas residents in disaster-prone areas. Such conversations suggest that while the intent is protective, the balance between regulation and market viability needs careful consideration.