Texas 2011 - 82nd Regular

Texas House Bill HB1041

Filed
 
Out of House Committee
4/19/11  
Out of Senate Committee
 
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to the waiver of sovereign immunity for certain claims arising under written contracts with state agencies.

Impact

If passed, HB 1041 would significantly alter the legal landscape governing contractual disputes involving state agencies. Currently, the doctrine of sovereign immunity provides protection against lawsuits, but this bill introduces specific instances where that immunity could be waived. The altered regulations would enable contractors to seek adjudication through civil suits or arbitration procedures, thus promoting more responsible contracting practices among state entities. However, this capability comes with limitations on the types of damages that can be awarded, specifically excluding consequential damages and emphasizing direct payments owed under contracts.

Summary

House Bill 1041 addresses the waiver of sovereign immunity for certain claims that arise from written contracts with state agencies. The bill amendments to the Civil Practice and Remedies Code include provisions that allow state agencies to face civil suits for breach of contract under specific circumstances. This bill is particularly relevant for contracts exceeding $250,000, thereby creating a larger threshold for claims where the state can be held accountable. The proposed changes aim to enable greater accountability for state agencies when failing to uphold contractual agreements, specifically removing the shield of sovereign immunity for these cases.

Contention

The introduction of this bill can lead to contentious debates around the balance between governmental accountability and protection against frivolous lawsuits. Supporters argue that it is essential for state agencies to be held liable for breaches, which would encourage them to fulfill contracts responsibly. Conversely, critics may raise concerns about potential litigation risks that could arise, arguing it may lead to adversarial relationships between state agencies and contractors. Furthermore, attendees of discussions around the bill might debate the implications of specific limitations attached to awarded damages, including concerns over fair compensation in the event of contract breaches.

Companion Bills

TX SB562

Identical Relating to the waiver of sovereign immunity for certain claims arising under written contracts with state agencies.

Previously Filed As

TX SB313

Relating to the Texas Sovereignty Act.

TX HB384

Relating to the Texas Sovereignty Act.

TX HJR84

Proposing a constitutional amendment authorizing the Kickapoo Traditional Tribe of Texas to conduct gaming by executing a gaming compact with this state; providing for occupational licensing under the compact; limiting certain taxes and fees.

TX SJR30

Proposing a constitutional amendment authorizing the Kickapoo Traditional Tribe of Texas to conduct gaming by executing a gaming compact with this state; providing for occupational licensing under the compact; limiting certain taxes and fees.

TX HB1752

Relating to liability for the provision to certain children of procedures and treatments for gender transitioning, gender reassignment, or gender dysphoria; providing a civil penalty.

TX SB648

Relating to the procedure for removing certain prosecuting attorneys for their policies on the enforcement of criminal offenses; providing a private cause of action.

TX HB1467

Relating to drug testing and prescription drug policies and certain legal protections for employees and independent contractors of state agencies and political subdivisions and for other persons regarding the medical use of low-THC cannabis and hemp.

TX SB575

Relating to the creation of a cause of action for deprivation of rights and the waiver of immunity.

TX HB21

Relating to civil liability for the sterilization, castration, or genital mutilation of children.

TX HB2024

Relating to statutes of limitation and repose for certain claims arising out of residential construction.

Similar Bills

CA AB954

Dental services: third-party network access.

DC B25-0265

Contract No. GAGA-2022-C-0259 with SodexoMagic, LLC Approval and Payment Authorization Emergency Act of 2023

TX SB543

Relating to oversight of and requirements applicable to state contracts and other state financial and accounting issues; authorizing fees.

TX HB1426

Relating to certain requirements applicable to contracts entered into by, and the contract management process of, state agencies.

MS HB934

Healthcare Contracting Simplification Act; create.

NJ S3443

Requires State Contract Managers to monitor work conducted by subcontractors on State contracts.

NJ A4487

Requires State Contract Managers to monitor work conducted by subcontractors on State contracts.

CA SB681

Public employees’ retirement: contracting agencies: termination.