Texas 2011 - 82nd Regular

Texas House Bill HB323

Filed
11/19/10  
Out of House Committee
4/8/11  
Out of Senate Committee
 
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to inclusion of pets and other companion animals in protective orders; providing a penalty.

Impact

The proposed amendments will have a substantial impact on protective orders by recognizing pets not merely as property but as integral members of the family unit. This legislation aims to ensure the safety and wellbeing of pets caught in domestic violence situations, thereby preventing further trauma to victims who may already be suffering from abusive relationships. By mandating courts to consider the welfare of pets and assistance animals, HB323 aligns animal welfare with human safety in protective orders.

Summary

House Bill 323 seeks to enhance the legal protections afforded to pets and companion animals within the context of family violence protective orders. It amends the Family Code to explicitly allow courts to prohibit a party in a protective order from removing a pet or assistance animal from their rightful owner or from the premises. This inclusion acknowledges the significant emotional support and companionship that animals provide, particularly to victims of family violence, thus reinforcing the importance of their presence during distressing situations.

Contention

While the bill has garnered support for its humane approach, it has also faced scrutiny and debate regarding the practical implications of enforcing such provisions. Critics may voice concerns over the feasibility of enforcement—how courts will assess the safety of pets and the potential increase in litigation. Additionally, there is a dialogue about the balance between protecting animals and the complexities that arise in custody disputes involving both people and pets. Supporters argue that the emotional harm caused by the removal of pets from victims should not be overlooked, emphasizing the bill's role in promoting overall welfare.

Companion Bills

TX SB279

Identical Relating to inclusion of pets and other companion animals in protective orders; providing a penalty.

Similar Bills

CA SB726

Hazardous waste: public agencies: materials exchange program.

CA AB998

Household hazardous waste.

CA SB552

Hazardous waste: household hazardous waste: door-to-door collection programs: residential pickup services.

CA AB2460

Department of Consumer Affairs: Bureau of Household Goods and Services: household movers.

CA AB224

Department of Consumer Affairs: Bureau of Household Goods and Services: household movers.

CA AB2481

Household hazardous waste: facilities: transportation and acceptance.

CA SB203

Juveniles: custodial interrogation.

CA SB289

Recycling: batteries and battery-embedded products.