Texas 2011 - 82nd Regular

Texas House Bill HB3450 Latest Draft

Bill / Introduced Version

Download
.pdf .doc .html
                            By: Farrar H.B. No. 3450


 A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
 AN ACT
 relating to restrictions on the operations of public and private
 animal shelters, providing a penalty.
 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS:
 SECTION 1.  SHORT TITLE. This Act may be cited as the
 Companion Animal Protection Act of 2011.
 SECTION 2.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code, is amended
 by adding Section 823.010 to read as follows:
 Sec. 823.010.  STATEMENT OF LEGISLATIVE INTENT.  (a)  It is
 the intent of the State of Texas to curtail the killing of savable
 animals in the state.  In order to accomplish this, the State of
 Texas finds and declares:
 (1)  protecting animals is a legitimate and compelling
 public interest;
 (2)  the killing of savable animals in animal shelters
 is a tragedy, the incidence of which ought to be curtailed;
 (3)  no animal should be killed if the animal can be
 placed in a suitable home, if a private sheltering agency or rescue
 group is willing to take care and custody of the animal for purposes
 of adoption, or, in the case of feral cats, if they can be
 sterilized and released to their habitats;
 (4)  animals held in shelters deserve proper care and
 humane treatment;
 (5)  shelters have a duty to make all savable animals
 available for adoption for a reasonable period of time;
 (6)  owners of lost animals should have a reasonable
 period of time within which to redeem their animals;
 (7)  shelters should not kill savable animals at the
 request of their owners;
 (8)  all efforts should be made to encourage the
 voluntary spaying and neutering of animals;
 (9)  when animals are killed, it should be done as
 humanely and compassionately as possible;
 (10)  taxpayers and community members deserve full and
 complete disclosure about how animal shelters operate;
 (b)  The State of Texas further finds and declares that all
 public and private sheltering agencies that operate within the
 state shall:
 (1)  commit themselves to ending the killing of savable
 animals in their care and custody;
 (2)  work with other animal adoption organizations to
 promote the adoption of animals and to reduce euthanasia rates;
 (3)  provide every animal in their custody with
 individual consideration and care to the maximum extent
 practicable;
 (4)  not ban, bar, limit or otherwise obstruct the
 adoption of any animal based on arbitrary criteria, such as breed,
 age, color, or other criteria except as to the individual animal's
 medical condition or aggression, or the adopter's fitness to adopt.
 SECTION 2.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended to
 add Section 823.011 to read as follows:
 Section 823.011.  DEFINITIONS.  For purposes of this Act,
 the following definitions shall apply:
 (a)  a "Public Sheltering Agency" is an animal shelter or
 animal adoption group that receives city, county or state funding
 and/or has a contract with a city, county or state under which it
 accepts stray or owner-relinquished animals.
 (b)  a "Private Sheltering Agency" is an animal shelter or
 animal adoption group which is designated as a non-profit under
 Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code which does not
 receive city, county or state funding or have a contract with the
 city, county or state under which it accepts stray or
 owner-relinquished animals and is not operated from a private
 residence.
 (c)  a "Rescue Group" is a collaboration of individuals not
 operated for a profit, whose primary stated purpose is animal
 protection, which places into new homes stray and/or
 owner-relinquished animals and/or animals who have been removed
 from a public or private sheltering agency.  Individual rescuers
 who keep animals in their own homes but are not part of a larger
 collaboration are not a rescue group for purposes of this Act.
 (d)  an "Animal" is any domestic non-human living creature
 normally kept as a pet, or a feral cat.
 (e)  an "Impounded animal" is any animal who enters a public
 or private sheltering agency or rescue group regardless of whether
 the animal is a stray, owner-relinquished, seized, taken into
 protective custody, or transferred from another private or public
 sheltering agency.
 (f)  a "Stray animal" is any animal who is impounded without
 a known owner present at impound who is voluntarily relinquishing
 custody.
 (g)  a "Savable animal" is any animal who is either healthy
 or treatable, and is not a vicious or dangerous dog.
 (h)  a "Healthy animal" is any animal who is not sick or
 injured.
 (i)  a "Treatable animal" is any animal who is sick or
 injured, whose prognosis for rehabilitation of that illness and/or
 injury is excellent, good, fair, or guarded as determined by a
 veterinarian licensed to practice in this state.
 (j)  a "Non-rehabilitatable animal" is any animal with
 severe illness or injury whose prognosis for rehabilitation is
 either poor or grave as determined by a veterinarian licensed to
 practice in this state.
 (k)  an "Irremediably Suffering animal" is any animal with a
 medical condition who has a poor or grave prognosis for being able
 to live without severe, unremitting pain, as determined by a
 veterinarian licensed to practice in this state.
 (l)  a "Feral Cat" is a cat who is free-roaming, unsocialized
 to humans, and unowned.
 (m)  a "Feral Cat Caregiver" is someone who cares for feral
 cats and has an interest in protecting the cats, but is not the
 owner of those cats.
 (n)  an "Unweaned animal" is any neonatal animal who, in the
 absence of his/her mother, requires supplemental bottle feeding by
 humans in order to survive.  In the case of puppies and kittens,
 unweaned animals are animals who fit the above description and are
 from 0 to 4 weeks of age.
 (o)  a "Litter of animals" includes two or more animals who
 are under twelve weeks of age as determined by a veterinarian
 licensed to practice medicine in this state, or by a veterinary
 technician or veterinary assistant working under the direction of a
 veterinarian licensed to practice medicine in this state.
 (p)  a "Vicious Dog" is a dog who exhibits aggression to
 people even when the dog is not hungry, in pain, or frightened, and
 whose prognosis for rehabilitation of that aggression is poor or
 grave as determined by a trained behaviorist who is an expert on
 canine behavior.
 (q)  a "Dangerous Dog" is a dog adjudicated to be vicious by a
 court of competent jurisdiction and where all appeals of that
 judicial determination have been unsuccessful.
 SECTION 3.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended to
 add Section 823.012 to read as follows:
 Section 823.012.  STERILIZATION REQUIREMENTS.  (a)  Except
 as otherwise provided in this section, no public or private
 sheltering agency or rescue group shall sell, adopt, or give away
 to a new owner any dog, cat, rabbit, or other animal who has not been
 spayed or neutered, except that this section shall not apply to
 reptiles, amphibians, birds, fish, and small animals such as mice
 and hamsters, where the anesthesia or sterilization procedure is
 likely to result in the animal's death.
 (b)  If a veterinarian licensed to practice veterinary
 medicine in this state certifies that an animal is too sick or
 injured to be spayed or neutered, or that it would otherwise be
 detrimental to the health of the animal to be spayed or neutered,
 the adopter or purchaser shall be exempt from the requirements of
 this Section.
 SECTION 4.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended by
 adding Section 823.013 to read as follows:
 Section 823.012.  OFFENSES AND PENALTIES.  (a)  A person is
 subject to civil penalties of not less than two hundred dollars
 ($200) or more than five hundred dollars ($500) if that person does
 any of the following:
 (1)  falsifies any proof of spaying or neutering
 submitted for the purpose of compliance with this Act;
 (2)  intentionally issues a check for insufficient
 funds for any spaying or neutering deposit required under this Act;
 (3)  falsifies a signed letter from a veterinarian
 submitted for the purpose of compliance with this Act, certifying
 that an animal is too sick or injured to be spayed or neutered.
 (b)  An action for a penalty proposed under this section may
 be commenced in a court of competent jurisdiction by the
 administrator of the public or private animal sheltering agency or
 rescue group from which the recipient obtained the animal who is the
 subject of the violation.
 (c)  All penalties collected under this section shall be
 retained by the agency bringing the action under subsection (b) to
 be used solely for programs to spay or neuter animals.
 SECTION 5.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended to
 add Section 823.014 to read as follows:
 Section 823.014.  FERAL CATS.  (a)  Caretakers of feral cats
 shall be exempted from any provision of law proscribing the feeding
 of stray animals, requiring permits for the feeding of animals,
 requiring the confinement of cats, or limiting the number of
 animals a person can own, harbor, or have custody of, except that
 nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the enforcement
 of a statute having as its effect the prevention or punishment of
 animal neglect or cruelty, so long as such enforcement is based on
 the conditions of animals, and not based on the mere fact that a
 person is feeding feral cats in a public or private location.
 (b)  In order to encourage spay/neuter of feral cats and to
 protect cats, public or private sheltering agencies or rescue
 groups shall not lend, rent, or otherwise provide traps to the
 public to capture cats, except to a person for the purpose of
 catching and reclaiming that person's wayward cat(s), to capture
 injured or sick cats or cats otherwise in danger, to capture feral
 kittens for purposes of taming and adoption, or, in the case of
 feral cats, for purposes of spay/neuter and subsequent re-release;
 (1)  For purposes of this subsection, the location of
 the cats, without more, does not constitute "otherwise in danger";
 (2)  A person is subject to civil penalties of not less
 than two hundred dollars ($200) or more than five hundred dollars
 ($500) if that person uses a trap from a public or private
 sheltering agency or rescue group for purposes other than those
 enumerated above.
 (c)  An action for a penalty proposed under this section may
 be commenced in a court of competent jurisdiction by the
 administrator of the public or private animal sheltering agency or
 rescue group from which the recipient obtained the trap that is the
 subject of the violation.
 (d)  All penalties collected under this section shall be
 retained by the agency bringing the action under subsection (c) to
 be used solely for programs to spay or neuter animals.
 SECTION 6.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended by
 adding Section 823.015 to read as follows:
 Section 823.015.  HOLDING PERIODS.  (a)  The required
 holding period for a stray animal impounded by any public or private
 sheltering agency shall be at least five business days, not
 including the day of impoundment, unless otherwise provided in this
 section:
 (1)  Stray animals without any form of identification
 and without a known owner shall be held for owner redemption during
 the first two days of the holding period, not including the day of
 impoundment, and shall be available for owner redemption, transfer,
 and adoption for the remainder of the holding period;
 (2)  Stray animals may be adopted into new homes or
 transferred to a rescue group or private sheltering agency for the
 purpose of adoption after the first two days of the holding period,
 not including the day of impoundment, except as provided in
 subsections (a)(3) to (9);
 (3)  If a stray animal is impounded with a license tag,
 microchip, or other form of identification, or belongs to a known
 owner, the animal shall be held for owner redemption during the
 first three days of the holding period, not including the day of
 impoundment, and shall be available for owner redemption, transfer,
 and adoption for the remainder of the holding period;
 (4)  Litters of animals or individual members of a
 litter of animals, including the nursing mother, and unweaned
 animals may be transferred to a private sheltering agency or rescue
 group for the purpose of adoption immediately after impound;
 (5)  Individual members of litters of animals who are
 at least six weeks of age, including the mother, may be adopted
 immediately upon impound;
 (6)  A feral cat caregiver has the same right of
 redemption for feral cats as an owner of a pet cat, without
 conferring ownership of the cat(s) on the caregiver;
 (7)  Irremediably suffering animals may be euthanized
 without delay, upon a determination made in writing and signed by a
 veterinarian licensed to practice medicine in this state. That
 certification shall be made available for free public inspection
 for no less than three years;
 (8)  Symptomatic dogs with confirmed cases of
 parvovirus or cats with confirmed cases of panleukopenia may be
 euthanized without delay, upon a certification made in writing and
 signed by a veterinarian licensed to practice medicine in this
 state that the prognosis is poor even with supportive care. That
 certification shall be made available for free public inspection
 for no less than three years;
 (9)  Unweaned animals impounded without their mother
 may be killed so long as the shelter has exhausted all efforts to
 place the animals in foster care, made an emergency appeal under the
 requirements of Section 9, and certified that it is unable to
 provide the needed care and feeding in its facility. That
 certification shall also state in clear and definitive terms why
 the agency is unable to place the animals in foster care, which
 private sheltering agencies and rescue groups it made an appeal to,
 and what would be required in the future in order to provide the
 needed care and feeding in foster care or its facility, and what
 steps are being taken to do so.  This certification shall be made in
 writing, signed by the director of the agency or by a veterinarian,
 and be made available for free public inspection for no less than
 three years.
 SECTION 7.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code, is amended
 by adding Section 823.016 to read as follows:
 Section 823.016. SPECIAL PROVISIONS RELATED TO
 OWNER-RELINQUISHED ANIMALS. (a)  The required holding period for
 an owner relinquished animal impounded by public or private
 sheltering agencies shall be the same as that for stray animals and
 applies to all owner relinquished animals, except as follows:
 (1)  Any owner-relinquished animal that is impounded
 shall be held for adoption or for transfer to a private sheltering
 agency or rescue group for the purpose of adoption for the entirety
 of the holding period;
 (2)  Owner-relinquished animals may be adopted into new
 homes or transferred to a private sheltering agency or rescue group
 for the purpose of adoption at any time after impoundment.
 (b)  When an animal is surrendered or brought to a shelter to
 be killed at the owner's request, the animal shall be subject to the
 same holding periods and the same requirements of all owner
 relinquished animals notwithstanding the request.
 (c)  An animal seized by an officer of a public or private
 sheltering agency under the provisions of a state statute having as
 its effect the prevention or punishment of animal neglect or
 cruelty, or seized under the provision of state dangerous dog laws
 or under state quarantine or disease control regulations, shall be
 impounded and held as consistent with the requirements of those
 laws, except that holding periods under this Chapter shall be
 observed to the maximum extent practicable.
 SECTION 8.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code, is amended
 by adding Section 823.021 to read as follows:
 Section 823.021.  ADDITIONAL PROGRAMS AND DUTIES.  (a)  All
 public and private sheltering agencies that kill animals shall
 maintain a registry of organizations willing to accept animals for
 the purposes of adoption, as follows:
 (1)  All public or private sheltering agencies, and
 rescue groups designated as non-profits by Section 501(c)(3) of the
 Internal Revenue Code, shall be immediately placed on this registry
 upon their request, regardless of the organizations' geographical
 location or any other factor except as described under subsection
 (a)(5);
 (2)  The public or private sheltering agency may, but
 is not required to, include on the registry any rescue groups that
 are not designated as non-profits under Section 501(c)(3) of the
 Internal Revenue Code;
 (3)  The registry shall include the following
 information as provided by the registered organization:
 organization name, mailing address, and telephone number; website
 and e-mail address, if any; emergency contact information for the
 organization; the types of animals about whom the organization
 wishes to be contacted, including species-type and breed; and
 whether or not the organization is willing and able to care for
 unweaned animals, sick or injured animals, and/or feral or
 aggressive animals;
 (4)  All public and private sheltering agencies shall
 seek organizations to include on the registry;
 (5)  A public or private sheltering agency may refuse
 to include an organization on the registry, or delete it from the
 registry, until such time as this is no longer the case, if any of
 the organization's current directors and/or officers have been
 convicted in a court of competent jurisdiction of a crime
 consisting of cruelty to animals or neglect of animals; or if such
 charges are pending against any of the organization's current
 directors or officers; or if that organization or its current
 directors or officers are constrained by a court order or legally
 binding agreement that prevents the organization from taking in or
 keeping animals.  An agency may require an organization to disclose
 any or all convictions, charges, and legal impediments described in
 this subsection;
 (6)  A public or private sheltering agency may require
 that registered organizations provide the following summary
 information on no more than a monthly basis: the total number of
 animals the organization has taken from the agency who have been
 adopted, died, were transferred, were killed, and are still under
 the organization's care.  This information may be provided in an
 informal format, such as via electronic mail;
 (7)  A public or private sheltering agency shall not
 demand additional information, other than that described in this
 section, as a prerequisite for including an organization on the
 registry or for continuing to maintain that organization on the
 registry.
 (b)  No public or private sheltering agency may kill an
 animal unless and until the agency has notified, or made a
 reasonable attempt to notify, all organizations on the registry
 described in subsection (a) that have indicated a willingness to
 take an animal of that type.
 SECTION 9.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code, is amended
 by adding Section 823.022 to read as follows:
 Section 823.022.  LOST ANIMALS.  (a)  All public and private
 sheltering agencies shall take appropriate action to ensure that
 all animals are checked for all currently acceptable methods of
 identification, including microchips, identification tags, and
 licenses.  All public and private sheltering agencies shall
 maintain continuously updated lists of animals reported lost, and
 match these lost reports with animals reported found and animals in
 the shelter, and shall also post all stray animals on the Internet
 with sufficient detail to allow them to be recognized and claimed by
 their owners.  If a possible owner is identified, the agencies shall
 undertake reasonable efforts to notify the owner or caretaker of
 the whereabouts of the animal and any procedures available for the
 lawful recovery of the animal.  These efforts shall include, but are
 not limited to, notifying the possible owner by telephone, mail,
 and personal service to the last known address. Upon the owner's or
 caretaker's initiation of recovery procedures, the agencies shall
 retain custody of the animal for a reasonable period of time to
 allow for completion of the recovery process.  Efforts to locate or
 contact an owner or caretaker, and communications with persons
 claiming to be owners or caretakers, shall be recorded and be made
 available for free public inspection for no less than three years.
 SECTION 10.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.024 to read as follows:
 Section 823.024.  LIMITATION ON ADOPTION CRITERIA.  (a)  No
 public or private sheltering agency shall ban, bar, limit or
 otherwise obstruct the adoption of any animal based on arbitrary
 criteria, such as breed, age, color, or any other criteria except as
 to the individual animal's medical condition and aggression, or the
 adopter's fitness to adopt.
 SECTION 11.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.025 to read as follows:
 Section 823.025.  REQUIRED SERVICES.  (a)  Every public
 sheltering agency shall provide the following public services:
 (1)  low-cost spay/neuter services for animals;
 (2)  volunteer opportunities for people to assist the
 shelter, including fostering animals, socializing animals,
 assisting with adoptions, and otherwise helping in the operations
 of the shelter;
 (3)  programs to assist people in overcoming situations
 that may cause them to relinquish or abandon their animals,
 including, but not limited to, programs that address animal
 behavior problems, medical conditions, and environmental
 conditions.
 (b)  Nothing in this section shall prohibit an agency from
 enacting reasonable rules to facilitate the orderly operation of
 these programs, so long as the rules are designed to meet the goals
 of this Act.
 SECTION 12.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.030 to read as follows:
 Section 823.025.  PROHIBITION ON ADOPTION FOR CERTAIN
 PURPOSES. (a)  No person shall procure or use any living animal
 from a public or private sheltering agency or rescue group for
 medical or biological teaching, research or study.  No hospital,
 educational or commercial institution, laboratory, or animal
 dealer, whether or not such dealer is licensed by the United States
 Department of Agriculture, shall purchase or accept any living
 animal from a public or private sheltering agency, rescue group,
 commercial kennel, kennel, peace officer, or animal control
 officer.
 (b)  No public or private sheltering agency, rescue group,
 commercial kennel, kennel, peace officer, or animal control officer
 shall sell, adopt, transfer, or give away any living animal to a
 person, hospital, educational or commercial institution,
 laboratory, or dealer in animals, whether or not such dealer is
 licensed by the United States Department of Agriculture, for
 purposes of medical or biological teaching, research or study.
 SECTION 13.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.031 to read as follows:
 Section 823.031.  PRECONDITIONS FOR EUTHANASIA.  (a)  No
 savable animal in a public or private sheltering agency shall be
 killed simply because the holding period has expired. Before an
 animal is killed, all of the following conditions must be met:
 (1)  there are no empty cages, kennels, or other living
 environments in the shelter;
 (2)  the animal cannot share a cage or kennel with
 another animal;
 (3)  a foster home is not available;
 (4)  organizations listed on the registry described in
 Section 9 are not willing to accept the animal;
 (5)  the animal is not a feral cat subject to
 sterilization and release; and
 (6)  the director of the agency certifies he or she has
 no other alternative, or the director certifies that failure to
 euthanize the animal would constitute an unsustainable burden on
 the agency.
 (b)  The determination that all conditions of subsection (a)
 have been met shall be made in writing, signed by the director of
 the agency, and be made available for free public inspection for no
 less than three years.
 SECTION 14.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.032 to read as follows:
 Section 823.032.  EUTHANASIA PROCEDURES.  (a)  All animals
 impounded by a public or private sheltering agency or rescue group
 shall be killed only when necessary and consistent with the
 requirements of this Act, and the killing shall be accomplished by
 lethal intravenous injection of sodium pentobarbital, except as
 follows:
 (1)  intraperitoneal injections may be used only under
 the direction of a licensed veterinarian, and only when intravenous
 injection is not possible for infant animals, companion animals
 other than cats and dogs, feral cats, or in comatose animals with
 depressed vascular function.
 (2)  intracardiac injections may be used only when
 intravenous injection is not possible for animals who are
 completely unconscious or comatose, and then only under the
 direction of a veterinarian.
 (b)  No animal shall be allowed to witness any other animal
 being killed or being tranquilized/sedated for the purpose of being
 killed or see the bodies of animals which have already been killed.
 (c)  Animals shall be sedated/tranquilized as necessary to
 minimize their stress or discomfort, or in the case of vicious
 animals, to ensure staff safety, except that neuromuscular blocking
 agents shall not be used.
 (d)  Following their injection, animals shall be lowered to
 the surface on which they are being held and shall not be permitted
 to drop or otherwise collapse without support.
 (e)  An animal may not be left unattended between the time
 procedures to kill the animal are commenced and the time death
 occurs, nor may the body be disposed of until death is verified.
 (f)  Verification of death shall be confirmed for each animal
 in at least two of the following ways:
 (1)  by lack of heartbeat, verified by a stethoscope;
 (2)  by lack of respiration, verified by observation;
 (3)  by pale, bluish gums and tongue, verified by
 observation; and
 (4)  by lack of eye response, verified if lid does not
 blink when eye is touched and pupil remains dilated when a light is
 shined on it.
 (g)  The room in which animals are killed shall be cleaned
 and regularly disinfected as necessary.
 (h)  A veterinarian licensed to practice veterinary medicine
 in this state or a trained euthanasia technician shall perform the
 euthanasia procedures.
 SECTION 15.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.035 to read as follows:
 Section 823.035.  ADDITIONAL REPORTING REQUIREMENTS.  (a)
 All public or private sheltering agencies shall prepare a written
 monthly summary by the tenth day of the month that includes the
 following information by species-type:
 (1)  the number of animals impounded during the
 previous month;
 (2)  the number of impounded animals sterilized and/or
 sterilized by contract with participating outside private
 veterinarians during the previous month;
 (3)  the number of animals who were killed by the
 agency, at the agency's direction, with the agency's permission,
 and/or by a representative of the agency during the previous month;
 (4)  the number of animals who died, were lost, and/or
 were stolen while in the direct or constructive care of such agency
 during the previous month;
 (5)  the number of animals who were adopted or returned
 to prior owners during the previous month;
 (6)  the number of animals who were transferred to
 other organizations for adoption during the previous month; and
 (7)  the number of animals impounded into the reporting
 agency from outside the reporting agency's normal city or county
 service area during the previous month.
 (b)  An agency shall retain copies of the summaries required
 by (a) for at least three calendar years and shall make such
 summaries available for public inspection.
 SECTION 16.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.037 to read as follows:
 Section 823.037.  ENFORCEMENT AND REMEDIES.  Any public or
 private sheltering agency or rescue group may compel a public or
 private sheltering agency to follow the mandates of this Act
 through a lawsuit asking a court of competent jurisdiction to grant
 declaratory and injunctive relief including, but not limited to:
 restraining orders, preliminary injunctions, injunctions, writs of
 mandamus and prohibition, and other appropriate remedies at law
 which will compel compliance with this Act.
 SECTION 17.  Chapter 823, Health and Safety Code is amended
 by adding Section 823.038 to read as follows:
 Section 823.038.  SEVERABILITY.  (a)  If the provisions of
 any article, section, subsection, paragraph, subdivision or clause
 of this Act shall be adjudged invalid by a court or other tribunal
 of competent jurisdiction, such determination, order, or judgment
 shall not affect or invalidate the remainder of any article,
 section, subsection, paragraph, subdivision or clause of this Act.
 Any such invalidity shall be confined in its operation to the
 clause, sentence, paragraph, section or article thereof directly
 involved in the controversy in which such determination, order, or
 judgment shall have been rendered.
 SECTION 18.  This Act takes effect September 1, 2011.