Texas House Bill HB2219

Texas 2013 - 83rd Regular

Caption

Relating to the punishment for the offense of attempted murder.

Impact

The proposed changes in HB 2219 would lead to significant implications for Texas's criminal justice system. By elevating the punishment for attempted murder in circumstances that lead to serious long-term injuries, the bill aims to deter potential offenders from committing such acts. Lawmakers suggest that heightened penalties could contribute to lower rates of violent crime. Conversely, critics may raise concerns about the fairness of increased penalties and the potential impacts on the already overloaded judicial system, especially regarding how it would affect sentencing practices and prison populations.

Summary

House Bill 2219 aims to modify the legal repercussions for the offense of attempted murder in Texas. The bill proposes an amendment to the Penal Code to establish that attempted murder is classified as a felony of the second degree when certain conditions are met. Specifically, if the attempted murder causes serious bodily injury resulting in a persistent vegetative state, the maximum punishment could reach up to 40 years in prison. This reclassification is intended to impose stricter penalties for severe criminal actions, reflecting a legislative intent to enhance penalties in cases that result in significant harm to victims.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 2219 appears to be largely supportive among lawmakers advocating for tougher crime measures, particularly in cases involving severe harm to victims. Advocates of the bill believe that it sends a clear message about the state's stance on violent crime and emphasized the need for justice for victims and their families. On the other hand, there could be dissenting views from those who argue that the focus should also remain on rehabilitation and the underlying issues that lead to violent crime rather than solely on increased punishments.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding HB 2219 could revolve around the balance between punishment and rehabilitation in the penal system. Critics might question whether increasing the penalties for attempted murder actually serves as an effective deterrent or if it contributes to prison overcrowding without addressing root causes of violence. Furthermore, discussions may arise on how the changes could disproportionately affect certain demographics and the overall efficacy of such legislative measures in reducing violent crime rates in Texas.