Texas Senate Bill SB394

Texas 2013 - 83rd Regular

Caption

Relating to restricting access to records of children convicted of or receiving deferred disposition for certain fine-only misdemeanors.

Impact

The implementation of SB394 would amend existing provisions in the Code of Criminal Procedure and Family Code, specifically targeting how the records of minor convictions are treated under Texas law. It would make all records related to fine-only misdemeanors committed by children confidential. This change could potentially lessen the repercussions that a minor might face in future employment or educational opportunities, thereby allowing for a more rehabilitative approach rather than punitive for non-violent offenses. By restricting access to such records, the bill aligns with broader goals to reform the juvenile justice system by focusing on rehabilitation and privacy.

Summary

SB394 focuses on restricting access to the records of children who have been convicted of or received deferred disposition for certain fine-only misdemeanors. The bill serves to ensure that records related to these types of offenses are confidential, meaning they cannot be disclosed to the public except in specific circumstances. This measure is viewed as a significant step in safeguarding the privacy of minors involved in the juvenile justice system, especially concerning non-violent offenses that carry a fine rather than imprisonment. By categorizing these offenses in this manner, the bill aims to prevent children from facing lifelong stigmas arising from minor infractions.

Contention

Notable points of contention related to SB394 mainly revolve around the balance between public safety and juvenile privacy. Advocates for the bill argue that confidentiality is crucial for second chances and the opportunity for rehabilitation, which are essential in dealing with minors. On the other hand, critics may express concerns regarding accountability and public awareness regarding juvenile offenses, potentially arguing for transparency in cases where communities have a vested interest. The discussion surrounding the bill implicates broader themes including the treatment of young offenders and the ethical considerations of ensuring privacy while maintaining community safety.