Texas 2015 - 84th Regular

Texas Senate Bill SB393

Filed
 
Out of Senate Committee
 
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to the punishment for certain offenses against property or against public administration.

Impact

The proposed changes within SB393 would have significant implications for local law enforcement and judicial proceedings in Texas. By raising the value thresholds for classifications of theft and property offenses, the bill may reduce the number of minor offenses that burden the court system. Supporters argue that this will allow law enforcement to focus their resources on more serious crimes, while simultaneously providing a clear delineation of consequences for offenders based on the degree of their offenses. However, this bill also raises concerns over the potential for increased criminal activity at lower threshold levels, as individuals might perceive fewer repercussions for certain offenses.

Summary

SB393 is a bill that seeks to revise the classification and punishment of various property offenses as outlined in the Texas Penal Code. Specifically, the bill introduces modifications to the thresholds that determine the categorization of offenses based on the value of stolen property. For instance, property valued under $100 is classified as a Class C misdemeanor, while property valued at $300,000 or more is treated as a felony of the first degree. These adjustments aim to ensure that punishment aligns more accurately with the severity of the crime and the financial impact on the victims involved.

Sentiment

The legislative discussions surrounding SB393 reflected a generally supportive sentiment among certain stakeholders, particularly those advocating for streamlined law enforcement practices. Many argued that the changes would promote better resource management within law enforcement agencies. Conversely, opponents of the bill expressed worries that elevating thresholds could undermine deterrents for property crimes, possibly leading to an escalation in theft rates. This bill underscored the tension between legislative efforts to reform criminal penalties and the need for maintaining public safety.

Contention

A notable point of contention regarding SB393 involves the balance of justice for victims versus the burden of the judicial system. Critics contended that the increases in value for felony classifications might lead to a lack of accountability for offenders, especially in cases where victims of theft feel that their losses are inadequately addressed by the legal system. Proponents countered this argument with data suggesting that lower-tier theft offenses should be managed more efficiently and that raising value thresholds is a logical step in modernizing the penal code. This ongoing debate about public safety, victim’s rights, and the efficiency of criminal justice processes illustrates the complexities legislators face in reforming property crime laws.

Companion Bills

TX HB1530

Identical Relating to the punishment for certain offenses against property or against public administration.

Similar Bills

TX HB1530

Relating to the punishment for certain offenses against property or against public administration.

TX HB2849

Relating to the punishment for certain offenses against property or against public administration.

TX HB1396

Relating to certain criminal offenses, punishments, and procedures; the construction of certain statutes and rules that create or define criminal offenses and penalties; a review of certain penal laws of this state.

TX HB3326

Relating to decreasing the punishment for certain criminal offenses.

TX HB381

Relating to the punishment for the offense of burglary of a vehicle; increasing a criminal penalty.

TX HB2827

Relating to the punishment for the offense of burglary of a vehicle and to grants of community supervision to persons who commit that offense.

TX SB2115

Relating to the criminal offense of fraudulent securing of document execution.

TX SB46

Relating to increasing the criminal penalty for the offense of criminal mischief involving tampering with a state-owned barrier or part of a barrier used to prevent travel across the international border of this state.