Texas House Bill HB3142

Texas 2017 - 85th Regular

Caption

Relating to a requirement that a public or private institution of higher education include a disciplinary notation on a student's transcript under certain circumstances.

Impact

The bill will amend existing statutes within the Education Code, specifically adding a new section that outlines the processes and responsibilities of higher education institutions regarding disciplinary notes on transcripts. This enforcement of transparency in disciplinary actions is expected to increase accountability among students and institutions alike. Furthermore, the bill provides a mechanism for students to appeal or request the removal of such notations under specific conditions, which balances institutional accountability with the rights of the students.

Summary

House Bill 3142 mandates that both public and private institutions of higher education in Texas are required to include a disciplinary notation on a student's transcript if the student is suspended or expelled for any reason. This legal requirement aims to ensure that a student's disciplinary history is transparent, thereby informing future educational institutions or employers about the student's past conduct. It also addresses situations where a student withdraws from an institution pending disciplinary charges, ensuring that the disciplinary process is concluded before the student's record is cleared.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB3142 appears mixed. Supporters of the bill emphasize the importance of maintaining records of student conduct to foster a responsible academic environment. They argue that transparency promotes integrity within the educational system. Conversely, critics may argue that such notations could have long-lasting effects on a student’s future, potentially affecting their ability to gain admission to other institutions or attain employment. This concern raises discussions about fairness and the potential for overreach in the documentation of student behavior.

Contention

Notable points of contention include concerns from some educational leaders and student advocates, who argue that including disciplinary notations may unfairly hinder students' futures due to past mistakes. Critics are particularly worried about cases of minor infractions leading to significant repercussions on a student's educational record. Furthermore, the legislation also places the responsibility on the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board to create rules for implementation, which raises questions about how fairly and consistently these rules will be enforced across different institutions.