Texas House Bill HB3971

Texas 2019 - 86th Regular

Caption

Relating to the release of student directory information by a school district.

Impact

The implications of HB 3971 on state laws center on the balance between student privacy and the dissemination of information for post-secondary opportunities. By reinforcing the requirement for parental consent for the release of directory information, the bill enhances the privacy protections for students beyond what is provided under the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). This shift is aimed at fostering a more protective environment for students regarding their personal information, particularly in the context of military recruitment.

Summary

House Bill 3971 addresses the release of student directory information by school districts in Texas. The bill amends Section 26.013 of the Education Code, clarifying the conditions under which a school district can release directory information. Under the updated provisions, a student's directory information may not be disclosed by a school district without written consent from a parent, except under specific circumstances that are mandated by federal law. Notably, the bill specifies that secondary students' names, addresses, and phone numbers can be given to military recruiters or institutions of higher education unless parents formally object to such disclosures.

Contention

While proponents of HB 3971 argue that it strengthens student privacy rights and puts the decision-making power in the hands of parents, there are concerns regarding the potential limitations this could impose on students seeking opportunities after high school. Opponents contend that such restrictions might hinder military recruitment efforts and the ability of educational institutions to connect with prospective students. The need for explicit consent might complicate processes that are typically straightforward, thus raising questions about the efficacy of the measures intended to protect privacy.