Texas House Bill HJR85

Texas 2019 - 86th Regular

Caption

Proposing a constitutional amendment requiring legislative approval of the historical narrative for certain exhibits featured at the Alamo or a museum owned or operated by the state.

Impact

If passed, HJR85 would significantly alter the way state-managed historical narratives are developed and presented. It places the power of narrative approval in the hands of lawmakers, potentially impacting how history is taught and represented to the public. State agencies managing museums would need to comply with new procedures for submitting narratives for legislative consideration, which could introduce delays and bureaucratic hurdles in the exhibition process. This legislative control may be seen as a way to protect the state's historical narrative from perceived biases or controversial interpretations that may arise.

Summary

HJR85 proposes a constitutional amendment that would require legislative approval for the historical narrative of specific exhibits featured at the Alamo or any museum owned or operated by the state of Texas. The bill amends Article III of the Texas Constitution by adding a new section that stipulates that no exhibit focused on the history of the Alamo or Texas can be displayed without prior approval from the legislature. This legislative control aims to ensure that the interpretation and presentation of Texas history is standardized and subjected to legislative oversight.

Contention

The proposal is expected to generate debate, with critics arguing that it represents an unnecessary overreach by the legislature into cultural and educational domains. Opponents may voice concerns about academic freedom and the ability of historians and curators to present history in a way that fosters critical engagement. Furthermore, the amendment could be seen as limiting creativity and flexibility in curatorial practices, leading to a homogenized presentation of Texas history that does not reflect diverse perspectives. Proponents, however, may argue that having legislative oversight prevents the dissemination of inaccurate or politically motivated historical narratives.