Texas 2023 - 88th Regular

Texas House Bill HB1791

Filed
1/27/23  
Out of Senate Committee
 
Voted on by Senate
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to the qualifications of experts in certain health care liability claims.

Impact

If enacted, HB 1791 will modify existing statutes to allow chiropractors to participate more fully in the legal process concerning malpractice claims. This change is intended to provide a clearer avenue for establishing the causal link between the injury claimed and the standards of care practiced within the field of chiropractic. By officially recognizing chiropractors as experts for these cases, the bill aims to enhance the representation of chiropractic issues in court and ensure that the nuances of best practices in chiropractic care are acknowledged during litigation.

Summary

House Bill 1791 seeks to amend the Civil Practice and Remedies Code to expand the qualifications for expert witnesses in certain health care liability claims, specifically to include chiropractors. Under current law, only physicians, dentists, and podiatrists are recognized as qualified expert witnesses in malpractice lawsuits involving their respective domains. This bill proposes that chiropractors should also be permitted to testify as expert witnesses in cases relating to chiropractic care, aligning their status with that of other health care professionals who can offer expert opinions in legal contexts.

Sentiment

The general sentiment surrounding HB 1791 appears to be supportive among chiropractic practitioners and their advocates, who argue that this legislation is a step towards ensuring equitable treatment across the health professions. Supporters emphasize that if podiatrists and dentists are granted this level of recognition, it is logical for chiropractors, who operate within a regulated health care framework, to receive similar consideration. However, there may also be cautious sentiments from those concerned about the implications of expanding the definition of who is deemed qualified to testify, as it could affect the dynamics of malpractice litigation.

Contention

Notably, the expansion of expert witness qualifications may lead to contentious debates about the standards for expert testimony. While proponents argue that it enhances fairness and representation for chiropractor practitioners, there may be opposition asserting that it complicates the legal process by allowing individuals with potentially less experience or a different standard of care than traditional medical practitioners to influence legal findings. The impacts of such changes on liability claims, professional credibility, and patient outcomes could be areas of ongoing discussion among legislators and stakeholders.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Civil Practice And Remedies Code

  • Chapter 74. Medical Liability
    • Section: New Section

Companion Bills

TX SB2171

Identical Relating to the qualifications of experts in certain health care liability claims.

Similar Bills

CA SB1436

Natural parent and child relationship: establishment.

AZ HB2486

Parent-child relationship; restoration

SC H3830

Orders of Protection

AZ HB2454

Kinship foster care; hearings; reports

NJ S3341

Provides that for purposes of will contest, caregiver-testator relationship is deemed "confidential relationship" and caregiver has burden to prove no undue influence existed.

CA ACR115

Lending to gun-related businesses.

CA AB643

Pupil instruction: abusive relationships.

NC S156

Clarify DV Misdemeanor