Texas 2023 - 88th Regular

Texas Senate Bill SB304

Voted on by Senate
 
Out of House Committee
 
Voted on by House
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to prohibited immunization status discrimination and vaccine mandates; authorizing administrative penalties.

Impact

The enactment of SB304 is expected to significantly influence state public health laws by rendering mandates for vaccination non-enforceable in various sectors, including education and employment. It creates an environment where individuals have autonomy over their vaccination choices without the fear of discrimination or backlash from institutions. By establishing clear boundaries on how vaccination statuses can be considered, the bill addresses a growing concern among citizens regarding privacy and personal choice in health care.

Summary

SB304 is a legislative act aimed at prohibiting discrimination based on an individual's vaccination history or immunity status related to communicable diseases. It amends existing laws, establishing a framework under which individuals cannot be denied public accommodations, employment opportunities, or health care services due to their vaccine status. This legislation also restricts health care providers and facilities from refusing to provide services to individuals based on vaccination records. Consequently, the bill underscores the principle of individual rights concerning health decisions while seeking to protect against vaccine mandates enforced by employers or state agencies.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB304 appears to be highly polarized. Proponents of the bill argue that it protects personal freedom and health choices, fostering an environment of respect for individual rights. This perspective resonates particularly with groups that view vaccination mandates as intrusive. Conversely, opponents contend that such a bill could undermine public health initiatives, especially in the wake of communicable diseases like COVID-19. They express concerns about potential risks to community health that could arise from eroding vaccination requirements.

Contention

The primary point of contention regarding SB304 lies in its implications for public health safety. Critics argue that eliminating vaccination mandates may lead to increased susceptibility to outbreaks of preventable diseases. Advocacy groups emphasize the importance of herd immunity and the role that vaccination plays in protecting vulnerable populations. Meanwhile, supporters counter that personal choice should take precedence over government mandates, framing the debate as a conflict between individual rights and collective health responsibility.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Human Resources Code

  • Chapter 42. Regulation Of Certain Facilities, Homes, And Agencies That Provide Child-care Services
    • Section: New Section

Insurance Code

  • Chapter 544. Prohibited Discrimination
    • Section: New Section

Education Code

  • Chapter 38. Health And Safety
    • Section: New Section

Health And Safety Code

  • Chapter 161. Public Health Provisions
    • Section: New Section

Labor Code

  • Chapter 21. Employment Discrimination
    • Section: New Section

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

TX SB1669

Relating to prohibited discrimination regarding vaccination status and mandates for receiving or participating in the administration of vaccines; authorizing administrative penalties.

TX HB3304

Relating to a prohibition on vaccination mandates.

TX SB1024

Relating to preventative health care and public health, including prohibited immunization and face-covering requirements and private business or school closures.

MS SB2755

"Vaccine Discrimination and Transparency Act"; prohibit coercion related to vaccination.

TX HB3957

Relating to prohibited discrimination based on a child's immunization status; authorizing administrative penalties.

TX SB303

Relating to discrimination by a provider participating in Medicaid or the child health plan program against an individual based on immunization status.

ND HB1391

Creating a new status related to human rights and antidiscrimination policies; and to provide an appropriation.

FL H0305

Protection of Medical Freedom