Texas 2023 - 88th Regular

Texas Senate Bill SB516

Voted on by Senate
 
Out of House Committee
 
Voted on by House
 
Governor Action
 
Bill Becomes Law
 

Caption

Relating to abolishing the death penalty.

Impact

If passed, SB516 will have significant implications for Texas law, particularly in the area of criminal justice and sentencing. The bill would amend existing sections of the Penal Code, establishing life imprisonment as the maximum sentence for capital felonies. This shift not only alters the potential consequences for defendants in capital cases but also potentially changes the dynamics of legal proceedings, as attorneys and jurors will no longer face the gravity of life-and-death decisions in such trials.

Summary

SB516 aims to abolish the death penalty in Texas, reforming the state's penal code in the process. This bill proposes that individuals found guilty of capital felonies will no longer face death as a possible punishment. Instead, they will be sentenced to life imprisonment, either with or without the possibility of parole, depending on their age at the time of the offense. The legislative intent behind this measure is to align Texas law with a growing national trend toward eliminating capital punishment, in recognition of its moral, ethical, and practical implications.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB516 is deeply polarized. Advocates of the bill argue that abolishing the death penalty will prevent wrongful executions and is in line with humanitarian values emphasizing the sanctity of life. They contend that the death penalty has not proven to be an effective deterrent to crime. Conversely, opponents of the bill express concerns that removing the death penalty could undermine justice for heinous crimes and victims' families. They argue that certain severe offenses warrant the ultimate punishment as a form of justice and deterrence.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding SB516 include debates over justice and morality. Proponents of the bill highlight the risk of wrongful convictions and the ethical dilemma of executing innocent individuals. On the other hand, critics focus on the belief that abolishing the death penalty would compromise the severity of punishment for the most egregious offenses. The bill's discussions also touch upon broader issues of criminal justice reform and systemic disparities, with various stakeholders arguing for or against capital punishment based on different ethical, legal, and practical perspectives.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Penal Code

  • Chapter 1. General Provisions
    • Section: New Section

Code Of Criminal Procedure

  • Chapter 1. General Provisions
    • Section: New Section
    • Section: 26

Government Code

  • Chapter 23. General Provisions For Trial Courts
    • Section: 101

Companion Bills

TX HB142

Similar Relating to abolishing the death penalty.

TX HB918

Similar To Relating to abolishing the death penalty.

Similar Bills

TX SB1133

Relating to a program to compensate landowners for property damage caused by certain criminal activities.

CA SB1146

Civil procedure: electronic filing, trial delays, and remote depositions.

LA HB23

Provides with respect to procedures for challenging the constitutionality of a statute or law (Item #21)

TX SB1424

Relating to criminal procedure, including grand jury proceedings and the appointment of an attorney pro tem for certain criminal proceedings.

TX HB1982

Relating to limitations on federal authority and federal agents in this state, including the licensure of federal agents and special procedures for executing federal warrants; creating a criminal offense.

CA SB757

Local government: nuisance abatement.

CA SB876

Local government: nuisance abatement: vegetation management.

CA AB345

Vehicular air pollution: regulations: exemption.