Texas 2025 - 89th Regular

Texas House Bill HB4292 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.
OldNewDifferences
11 89R12631 KJE-D
22 By: Shaheen H.B. No. 4292
33
44
55
66
77 A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
88 AN ACT
99 relating to appeals regarding school laws and a school district's
1010 grievance procedure regarding complaints concerning violation of
1111 state education law or school district board of trustees policy.
1212 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS:
1313 SECTION 1. (a) This section takes effect only if H.B. 1025,
1414 89th Legislature, Regular Session, 2025, becomes law.
1515 (b) Section 7.057, Education Code, is amended by amending
1616 Subsections (a) and (c) and adding Subsection (c-1) to read as
1717 follows:
1818 (a) Except as provided by Subsection (e), a person may
1919 appeal in writing to the inspector general [commissioner] if the
2020 person is aggrieved by:
2121 (1) the school laws of this state; or
2222 (2) actions or decisions of any school district board
2323 of trustees or open-enrollment charter school governing body that
2424 violate:
2525 (A) [the school laws of this] state or federal
2626 law; [or]
2727 (B) a policy adopted by a school district board
2828 of trustees or open-enrollment charter school governing body; or
2929 (C) a provision of a written employment contract
3030 between the school district or open-enrollment charter school and a
3131 [school] district or school employee, if a violation causes or
3232 would cause monetary harm to the employee.
3333 (c) In an appeal against a school district or
3434 open-enrollment charter school, the inspector general
3535 [commissioner] shall, not later than the 60th [240th] day after the
3636 date the appeal is filed, issue a decision based on a review of the
3737 record developed at the district or school level under a
3838 substantial evidence standard of review. The parties to the appeal
3939 may agree in writing to extend, by not more than seven [60] days,
4040 the date by which the inspector general [commissioner] must issue a
4141 decision under this subsection. The inspector general shall
4242 provide a copy of the record to the person who filed the grievance
4343 not later than the seventh day after the date on which the inspector
4444 general receives the record. A school district's or
4545 open-enrollment charter school's disclosure of the record to the
4646 inspector general [commissioner] under this subsection is not an
4747 offense under Section 551.146, Government Code.
4848 (c-1) In an appeal against a school district or
4949 open-enrollment charter school, the inspector general may find a
5050 violation not raised by the person bringing the appeal.
5151 SECTION 2. (a) This section takes effect only if H.B. 1025,
5252 89th Legislature, Regular Session, 2025, does not become law.
5353 (b) Section 7.057, Education Code, is amended by amending
5454 Subsections (a) and (c) and adding Subsection (c-1) to read as
5555 follows:
5656 (a) Except as provided by Subsection (e), a person may
5757 appeal in writing to the commissioner if the person is aggrieved by:
5858 (1) the school laws of this state; or
5959 (2) actions or decisions of any school district board
6060 of trustees or open-enrollment charter school governing body that
6161 violate:
6262 (A) [the school laws of this] state or federal
6363 law; [or]
6464 (B) a policy adopted by a school district board
6565 of trustees or open-enrollment charter school governing body; or
6666 (C) a provision of a written employment contract
6767 between the school district or open-enrollment charter school and a
6868 [school] district or school employee, if a violation causes or
6969 would cause monetary harm to the employee.
7070 (c) In an appeal against a school district or
7171 open-enrollment charter school, the commissioner shall, not later
7272 than the 60th [240th] day after the date the appeal is filed, issue
7373 a decision based on a review of the record developed at the district
7474 or school level under a substantial evidence standard of review.
7575 The parties to the appeal may agree in writing to extend, by not
7676 more than seven [60] days, the date by which the commissioner must
7777 issue a decision under this subsection. The commissioner shall
7878 provide a copy of the record to the person who filed the grievance
7979 not later than the seventh day after the date on which the
8080 commissioner receives the record. A school district's or
8181 open-enrollment charter school's disclosure of the record to the
8282 commissioner under this subsection is not an offense under Section
8383 551.146, Government Code.
8484 (c-1) In an appeal against a school district or
8585 open-enrollment charter school, the commissioner may find a
8686 violation not raised by the person bringing the appeal.
8787 SECTION 3. (a) This section takes effect only if H.B. 1025,
8888 89th Legislature, Regular Session, 2025, becomes law.
8989 (b) Section 7.057(f), Education Code, is amended by adding
9090 Subdivision (3) to read as follows:
9191 (3) "Inspector general" means the inspector general
9292 appointed under Subchapter E, Chapter 7.
9393 SECTION 4. Section 12A.004(a), Education Code, is amended
9494 to read as follows:
9595 (a) A local innovation plan may not provide for the
9696 exemption of a district designated as a district of innovation from
9797 the following provisions of this title:
9898 (1) a state or federal requirement applicable to an
9999 open-enrollment charter school operating under Subchapter D,
100100 Chapter 12;
101101 (2) Subchapters A, C, D, and E, Chapter 11, except that
102102 a district may be exempt from Sections 11.1511(b)(5) and (14) and
103103 Section 11.162;
104104 (3) the grievance procedure required by Section
105105 26.011;
106106 (4) state curriculum and graduation requirements
107107 adopted under Chapter 28; and
108108 (5) [(4)] academic and financial accountability and
109109 sanctions under Chapters 39 and 39A.
110110 SECTION 5. Section 26.011, Education Code, is amended to
111111 read as follows:
112112 Sec. 26.011. GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE [COMPLAINTS]. (a) The
113113 board of trustees of each school district shall adopt a grievance
114114 procedure under which the board shall address each grievance
115115 [complaint] that the board receives concerning a violation of a
116116 right guaranteed by this chapter, of a board of trustees policy, or
117117 of a provision of this title.
118118 (b) The board of trustees of a school district is not
119119 required by Subsection (a) or Section 11.1511(b)(13) to address a
120120 grievance [complaint] that the board receives concerning a
121121 student's participation in an extracurricular activity that does
122122 not involve a violation of a right guaranteed by this chapter, of a
123123 board of trustees policy, or of a provision of this title. This
124124 subsection does not affect a claim brought by a parent under the
125125 Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (20 U.S.C. Section 1400
126126 et seq.) or a successor federal statute addressing special
127127 education services for a child with a disability.
128128 (c) The grievance procedure adopted under Subsection (a)
129129 must provide for:
130130 (1) a grievance to be considered timely filed
131131 regardless of when the conduct giving rise to the grievance
132132 occurred;
133133 (2) a copy of each grievance filed with the school
134134 district and any supporting documentation to be provided to the
135135 district's board of trustees not later than the seventh business
136136 day after the date on which the grievance is filed;
137137 (3) the board of trustees of the school district to be
138138 represented with respect to grievances by separate, independent
139139 legal counsel from the district who is not recommended, directed,
140140 or assigned by the district;
141141 (4) not more than three levels of review as follows:
142142 (A) a review by the principal of the district
143143 campus at which the grievance was filed that includes:
144144 (i) a conference with the principal and the
145145 person who filed the grievance, recorded by the principal or the
146146 principal's designee and provided to the person who filed the
147147 grievance, held not later than:
148148 (a) the seventh business day after the
149149 date on which the grievance is filed; or
150150 (b) if the grievance regards a safety
151151 concern, the second business day after the date on which the
152152 grievance is filed; and
153153 (ii) a written decision by the principal
154154 and, if applicable, relief not later than the seventh business day
155155 after the date on which the conference was held under Subparagraph
156156 (i);
157157 (B) if the requested relief was not granted or if
158158 the principal did not timely provide a written decision under
159159 Paragraph (A)(ii), an automatic appeal to the superintendent of the
160160 district at which the grievance was filed that includes:
161161 (i) a conference with the superintendent
162162 and the person who filed the grievance, recorded by the
163163 superintendent or the superintendent's designee and provided to the
164164 person who filed the grievance, held not later than the seventh
165165 business day after the date on which the appeal was initiated; and
166166 (ii) a written decision by the
167167 superintendent and, if applicable, relief not later than the
168168 seventh business day after the date on which the conference was held
169169 under Subparagraph (i); and
170170 (C) if the requested relief was not granted or if
171171 the superintendent did not timely provide a written decision under
172172 Paragraph (B)(ii), an automatic appeal to the board of trustees of
173173 the district that includes:
174174 (i) a hearing on the grievance at a meeting
175175 of the board of trustees, which must be:
176176 (a) an open meeting if requested by
177177 the person who filed the grievance; and
178178 (b) recorded by audio or video
179179 recording or by court reporter by the board of trustees, separate
180180 from any other recording the board of trustees is required to make
181181 of the meeting;
182182 (ii) written notice of the proposed date,
183183 time, and location of the hearing described by Subparagraph (i)
184184 provided to the person who filed the grievance not later than the
185185 seventh day after the date on which the appeal was initiated;
186186 (iii) the consent of the person who filed
187187 the grievance to the date and time of the hearing described by
188188 Subparagraph (i);
189189 (iv) the provision of all material,
190190 including any video footage, the district will use at the hearing to
191191 the person who filed the grievance not later than the third business
192192 day before the date on which the hearing is held, redacted only as
193193 authorized by law; and
194194 (v) a written decision by the board of
195195 trustees and, if applicable, relief, which may not include remand
196196 to the district, not later than the seventh business day after the
197197 date on which the hearing is held;
198198 (5) the person who filed the grievance to be notified
199199 before the conference or hearing, as applicable, of:
200200 (A) the school district's legal representation;
201201 (B) each attorney employed by or under contract
202202 with the school district who was involved in the matter giving rise
203203 to the grievance before the grievance was filed and the nature of
204204 the attorney's involvement; and
205205 (C) the person responsible for investigating the
206206 grievance at each level of review described by Subdivision (4);
207207 (6) except as provided by Subsection (d), the addition
208208 of evidence to the record throughout the grievance procedure,
209209 regardless of when the evidence was discovered; and
210210 (7) for a grievance alleging a violation of law or a
211211 board of trustees policy, the grievance to proceed directly to the
212212 level of review described by Subdivision (4)(C).
213213 (d) The board of trustees of a school district may not use at
214214 a hearing described by Subsection (c)(4)(C)(i) any material not in
215215 the record developed at the level of review described by Subsection
216216 (c)(4)(A) or (B).
217217 (e) Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, a
218218 person involved in the matter that gave rise to a grievance,
219219 including school district staff or legal counsel, may not
220220 participate in the grievance procedure adopted under Subsection (a)
221221 for that grievance. In the event of a conflict of interest
222222 described by this subsection for a person required to hear the
223223 grievance under Subsection (c)(4):
224224 (1) the district must select a person who does not have
225225 a conflict of interest to hear the grievance at the applicable level
226226 of review;
227227 (2) the person who filed the grievance may contest the
228228 person selected under Subdivision (1) if the person who filed the
229229 grievance believes the selected person is conflicted as described
230230 by this subsection or was not chosen in good faith; and
231231 (3) if the district and the person who filed the
232232 grievance cannot agree on a person to hear the grievance, the
233233 grievance must be heard by the board of trustees of the district in
234234 accordance with Subsection (c)(4)(C).
235235 (f) A school district may not require a person who files a
236236 grievance to submit a desired relief for the grievance. If desired
237237 relief is submitted by the person, the district must allow the
238238 person to amend the desired relief during the grievance procedure.
239239 (g) A member of a school district board of trustees may file
240240 a grievance with the district. The member may not vote on matters
241241 related to that grievance.
242242 (h) If, during the investigation of a grievance, a school
243243 district discovers an unreported violation of a right guaranteed by
244244 this chapter, of board of trustees policy, or of a provision of this
245245 title, the district shall open a new investigation into the
246246 unreported violation.
247247 (i) A school district may not be represented by an attorney
248248 at a conference or hearing held under Subsection (c)(4) unless the
249249 person who filed the grievance is represented by an attorney at the
250250 conference or hearing.
251251 (k) Each absence of a student due to a safety concern during
252252 the pendency of a grievance filed by or on behalf of the student
253253 regarding that safety concern is counted as two absences for
254254 purposes of calculating a school district's average daily
255255 attendance.
256256 (l) The superintendent of a school district is responsible
257257 for ensuring that the grievance procedure adopted under Subsection
258258 (a) is followed and may not delegate that responsibility to another
259259 person. If the State Board for Educator Certification determines
260260 that a superintendent has not ensured that the grievance procedure
261261 is followed, the board may:
262262 (1) issue an inscribed reprimand to be placed on the
263263 superintendent's certification records for a period of at least
264264 five years; or
265265 (2) revoke the superintendent's certification.
266266 (m) At the beginning of each school year, a school district
267267 shall provide to each student and the parent of each student
268268 enrolled in the district written notice regarding the district's
269269 grievance procedure adopted under Subsection (a). The notice:
270270 (1) may not be combined with any other notice or
271271 information provided to the parent; and
272272 (2) must include a detailed description of the
273273 grievance procedure, including the levels of review, any time
274274 limits provided, and the manner in which the person assigned to hear
275275 a grievance is selected.
276276 (n) A school district shall post in a prominent location on
277277 the district's Internet website the grievance procedure adopted
278278 under Subsection (a) and instructions regarding how to file a
279279 grievance.
280280 (o) A school district shall provide to each person who files
281281 a grievance an optional survey on the person's experience with and
282282 satisfaction with the results of the grievance procedure adopted
283283 under Subsection (a).
284284 (p) Each school district shall include the following
285285 information in the district's Public Education Information
286286 Management System (PEIMS) report:
287287 (1) data relating to grievances filed with the
288288 district during the preceding school year, disaggregated by the
289289 level of review described by Subsection (c)(4), including:
290290 (A) the number of grievances filed;
291291 (B) the subject matter of each grievance;
292292 (C) the number of grievances dismissed; and
293293 (D) the number of grievances for which relief was
294294 granted; and
295295 (2) the results of the survey submitted under
296296 Subsection (o).
297297 (q) The commissioner may adopt rules as necessary to
298298 implement this section.
299299 SECTION 6. (a) This section takes effect only if H.B. 1025,
300300 89th Legislature, Regular Session, 2025, becomes law.
301301 (b) Section 26.011, Education Code, as amended by this Act,
302302 is amended by adding Subsections (j) and (r) to read as follows:
303303 (j) A school district may not retaliate against a student or
304304 parent who files a grievance or a student on whose behalf a
305305 grievance is filed. If the inspector general determines that a
306306 district has retaliated against a student or parent in violation of
307307 this subsection:
308308 (1) the inspector general shall:
309309 (A) investigate the grievance, if the grievance
310310 has not yet been resolved;
311311 (B) require the district to preserve all district
312312 records until the audit described by Paragraph (C) is completed;
313313 (C) not later than the 30th day after the date on
314314 which the determination was made, conduct an audit of the district;
315315 (D) if the inspector general determines that a
316316 district educator has retaliated against a student or parent in
317317 violation of this subsection, report the educator to the State
318318 Board for Educator Certification for investigation; and
319319 (E) report the determination to the commissioner
320320 for purposes of Subdivision (2); and
321321 (2) the commissioner may withhold approval for the
322322 guarantee of the district's bonds by the permanent school fund
323323 under Subchapter C, Chapter 45.
324324 (r) In this section, "inspector general" means the
325325 inspector general appointed under Subchapter E, Chapter 7.
326326 SECTION 7. (a) This section takes effect only if H.B. 1025,
327327 89th Legislature, Regular Session, 2025, does not become law.
328328 (b) Section 26.011, Education Code, as amended by this Act,
329329 is amended by adding Subsection (j) to read as follows:
330330 (j) A school district may not retaliate against a student or
331331 parent who files a grievance or a student on whose behalf a
332332 grievance is filed. If the agency determines that a district has
333333 retaliated against a student or parent in violation of this
334334 subsection:
335335 (1) the agency shall:
336336 (A) investigate the grievance, if the grievance
337337 has not yet been resolved;
338338 (B) require the district to preserve all district
339339 records until the audit described by Paragraph (C) is completed;
340340 (C) not later than the 30th day after the date on
341341 which the determination was made, conduct an audit of the district;
342342 and
343343 (D) if the agency determines that a district
344344 educator has retaliated against a student or parent in violation of
345345 this subsection, report the educator to the State Board for
346346 Educator Certification for investigation; and
347347 (2) the commissioner may withhold approval for the
348348 guarantee of the district's bonds by the permanent school fund
349349 under Subchapter C, Chapter 45.
350350 SECTION 8. Section 25.087, Education Code, is amended by
351351 adding Subsection (b-10) to read as follows:
352352 (b-10) A school district shall excuse a student from
353353 attending school for an absence due to a safety concern regarding
354354 which a grievance filed by or on behalf of the student is pending
355355 under Section 26.011. A student whose absence is excused under this
356356 subsection may not be penalized for that absence and shall be
357357 allowed a reasonable time to make up school work missed on those
358358 days. If the student satisfactorily completes the school work, the
359359 day of absence shall be counted as a day of compulsory attendance.
360360 SECTION 9. This Act applies beginning with the 2025-2026
361361 school year.
362362 SECTION 10. Except as otherwise provided by this Act, this
363363 Act takes effect immediately if it receives a vote of two-thirds of
364364 all the members elected to each house, as provided by Section 39,
365365 Article III, Texas Constitution. If this Act does not receive the
366366 vote necessary for immediate effect, this Act takes effect
367367 September 1, 2025.