Texas House Bill HB4815

Texas 2025 - 89th Regular

• Filed: 3/13/25

Caption

Relating to the liability of owners or operators of certain sources or facilities for unauthorized emissions caused by the criminal act of another.

Impact

The bill's passage would carry significant implications for how liability is assigned in cases of air contamination. By exempting certain facility owners from liability associated with emissions caused by third-party criminal acts, it could limit the accountability of operators in incidents where they played no role in the offending actions. This aspect may be viewed favorably by industry stakeholders concerned about unjust penalties for emissions they did not cause, potentially offering them greater protection from legal repercussions related to environmental regulation compliance.

Summary

House Bill 4815 addresses the liability of owners or operators of specific facilities concerning unauthorized emissions resulting from criminal acts perpetrated by others. This legislative measure amends Section 382.085 of the Health and Safety Code by adding a clause that expressly states these owners or operators are not to be held civilly, administratively, or criminally liable for emissions of air contaminants that occur due to the actions of individuals other than themselves. This provision is targeted at providing relief to businesses and facilities defined under certain Standard Industrial Classification codes, which could potentially be affected by emissions caused by unlawful activities like vandalism or sabotage.

Contention

While the bill aims to address the concerns of facility operators, it could also provoke debate regarding environmental protections and accountability. Critics may argue that such exemptions could disincentivize precautions against emissions and undermine environmental regulation efforts. The concern would be that operators might neglect ensuring adequate security measures to prevent unauthorized emissions, as the risk of liability would be reduced. This could lead to increased air quality issues in areas surrounding these facilities, raising questions about the balance between industry protection and environmental responsibility.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Health And Safety Code

• Chapter 382. Clean Air Act
  • Section: 085