If enacted, SB4247 would have significant implications for how federal research funding is distributed among institutions of higher education, particularly those with large endowments. For example, institutions with endowment funds exceeding $5 billion would face a prohibition on using federal research award funds for indirect costs, while those with endowments between $2 billion and $5 billion would be subjected to an indirect cost rate limit of 8%. Meanwhile, other institutions not classified under these categories would maintain a higher allowable indirect cost limit of 15%.
Summary
SB4247, titled the 'No Subsidies for Wealthy Universities Act,' is proposed legislation aimed at establishing limits on indirect cost reimbursements associated with federal research awards granted to institutions of higher education. The bill is specifically designed to address concerns regarding wealth disparities among educational institutions by imposing strict caps on the amount of indirect costs that can be allocated from federal funding based on the size of the institution's endowment funds. This legislative effort seeks to prevent taxpayer money from subsidizing wealthy universities that already enjoy substantial financial resources.
Contention
The bill has garnered attention for its potential to shift the landscape of federal educational funding, with proponents arguing that it curtails waste and ensures equitable distribution of resources. Critics, however, may see it as a means of undermining well-funded universities' capabilities to conduct research effectively, thereby risking the overall quality of academic research outputs. The contention surrounding this bill revolves around balancing fairness in funding with maintaining the operational capacity of leading institutions, which are often key contributors to advancements in various fields.
No Subsidies for Wealthy Universities ActThis bill limits the indirect costs that are allowable under federal research awards to institutions of higher education (IHEs) with endowments above specified thresholds. (Generally, indirect costs represent expenses that are not specific to a research project but are needed to maintain the infrastructure and administrative support for federally funded research.)Specifically, the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) must annually collect information regarding the endowments of each IHE that has entered into a program participation agreement with the Department of Education.With this collected information, NCES must identify and make lists of (1) each IHE with an endowment of more than $5 billion, and (2) each IHE with an endowment of more than $2 billion (but not more than $5 billion). NCES must submit these lists to the Office of Management and Budget, which must then distribute the lists to federal agencies, Congress, and the public.The bill establishes the following limits on the indirect costs allowable under federal research awards:for an IHE with an endowment of more than $5 billion, the IHE is prohibited from using these awards for indirect costs;for an IHE with an endowment of more than $2 billion (but not more than $5 billion), the IHE is limited to an indirect cost rate of 8%; andfor all other IHEs, an indirect cost rate of 15%.The Government Accountability Office must annually report to Congress on indirect cost reimbursement on federal research awards for IHEs.
Federal Grant Accountability ActThis bill limits the indirect costs that are allowable under federal research awards to institutions of higher education (IHEs). (Generally, indirect costs represent expenses that are not specific to a research project but are needed to maintain the infrastructure and administrative support for federally funded research.)Specifically, the total amount of indirect costs allowable under a federal research award may not exceed the total amount of indirect costs allowable under private research awards. The Office of Management and Budget must determine the average indirect cost rate applicable to private research awards.Additionally, the Government Accountability Office must study and report on (1) the indirect cost rates allowable under federal research awards to IHEs, including awards made by the National Institutes of Health, the National Science Foundation, and other such organizations; and (2) the indirect cost rates allowable under private research awards to IHEs.
No Subsidies for Wealthy Universities ActThis bill limits the indirect costs that are allowable under federal research awards to institutions of higher education (IHEs) with endowments above specified thresholds. (Generally, indirect costs represent expenses that are not specific to a research project but are needed to maintain the infrastructure and administrative support for federally funded research.)Specifically, the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) must annually collect information regarding the endowments of each IHE that has entered into a program participation agreement with the Department of Education.With this collected information, NCES must identify and make lists of (1) each IHE with an endowment of more than $5 billion, and (2) each IHE with an endowment of more than $2 billion (but not more than $5 billion). NCES must submit these lists to the Office of Management and Budget, which must then distribute the lists to federal agencies, Congress, and the public.The bill establishes the following limits on the indirect costs allowable under federal research awards:for an IHE with an endowment of more than $5 billion, the IHE is prohibited from using these awards for indirect costs;for an IHE with an endowment of more than $2 billion (but not more than $5 billion), the IHE is limited to an indirect cost rate of 8%; andfor all other IHEs, an indirect cost rate of 15%.The Government Accountability Office must annually report to Congress on indirect cost reimbursement on federal research awards for IHEs.