Us Congress 2023-2024 Regular Session

Us Congress Senate Bill SB5038

Introduced
9/12/24  

Caption

Stop CARB Act of 2024 Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2024

Impact

The passage of SB5038 would significantly alter the landscape of state-level environmental regulations, especially in states like California that have historically implemented stricter emissions controls. Proponents argue that this bill would foster a more unified national standard and prevent what they perceive as overreach by states, advocating for consistency in the auto industry. However, critics argue that this would undermine states' rights to implement more protective measures based on local environmental needs. They contend that allowing states to set their own standards has led to successful reductions in pollution, particularly in areas with severe air quality issues, which could be jeopardized by this legislation.

Summary

SB5038, also known as the Stop CARB Act of 2024, proposes amendments to the Clean Air Act aimed at eliminating state waivers that allow certain states, particularly California, to set their own vehicle emissions standards that are more stringent than federal standards. The bill seeks to prevent states from adopting new motor vehicle emissions and engine standards if they align with those established in California, effectively centralizing emissions regulation at the federal level. This change is positioned as an effort to streamline federal regulations on vehicle emissions and mitigate the regulatory burden perceived to be imposed by state-level initiatives.

Contention

The bill has sparked significant debate, primarily revolving around the tension between federal authority and state autonomy in environmental regulation. Supporters highlight the need for uniformity, while opponents express concern that this bill disregards local ecological impacts and ignores state-specific data showing the effectiveness of stricter regulations. This contention underscores a broader national conversation about the balance between federal oversight and state rights, particularly in matters concerning public health and environmental sustainability.

Companion Bills

US HB9574

Same As Stop CARB Act of 2024 Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2024

Previously Filed As

US HB9574

Stop CARB Act of 2024 Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2024

US HB2218

Stop CARB Act of 2025 Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2025

US SB1072

Stop CARB Act of 2025 Stop California from Advancing Regulatory Burden Act of 2025

US SB3864

Stop CMV Act of 2024

US HB7542

Stop CMV Act of 2024

US HB8427

Stop Arming Cartels Act of 2024

US SB1829

Stop Harboring Iranian Petroleum Act of 2023

US HB5089

Reducing Regulatory Burdens Act of 2023

US HB7264

Stop Politicians Profiting from War Act of 2024

US SB4056

EMIT LESS Act of 2024 Enteric Methane Innovation Tools for Lower Emissions and Sustainable Stock Act of 2024

Similar Bills

CA ACA19

State finance: budget: unemployment insurance debt repayment.

CA ACA1

Public finance.

CT HB06369

An Act Concerning Child Support And Enforcement.

US HB1832

Special Immigrant Visas for Afghan Fulbright Scholars Act of 2023

IA HF668

A bill for an act relating to property taxation for commercial child care centers and facilities and including effective date, applicability, and retroactive applicability provisions.(Formerly HSB 224.)

IA HSB224

A bill for an act relating to property taxation for commercial child care centers and facilities and including effective date, applicability, and retroactive applicability provisions.(See HF 668.)

IA HF991

A bill for an act placing assessment limitations for property tax purposes on commercial child care facilities, and including effective date, applicability, and retroactive applicability provisions.(Formerly HSB 316.)

IA HSB316

A bill for an act placing assessment limitations for property tax purposes on commercial child care facilities, and including effective date, applicability, and retroactive applicability provisions.(See HF 991.)