Joint resolution establishing a procedure for the conduct of the election of the University of Vermont and State Agricultural College trustees by plurality vote by the General Assembly in 2023
Impact
The passage of JRS011 transforms the election framework for this specific year, aiming to avoid the extended voting process that accompanies majority votes. It allows members of the assembly to vote for any number of candidates equivalent to the number of vacancies, with the top three candidates being elected. The resolution also addresses possible ties, establishing a protocol for consecutive ballots until all positions are filled. This change is expected to foster a quicker and more decisive election outcome, simplifying the voting experience for the assembly.
Summary
JRS011 establishes a specific procedure for the election of three trustees of the University of Vermont and State Agricultural College by the General Assembly, utilizing a plurality voting system for the year 2023. This resolution aims to streamline the election process to enhance efficiency, as previous elections have shown the burden of lengthy voting procedures when majority votes were required. The bill highlights the historical context by referencing past elections that alternated between plurality and majority voting, indicating a preference for plurality as a means to expedite decision-making.
Sentiment
Overall, the sentiment surrounding JRS011 appears to be favorable, as proponents advocate for the efficiency and clarity the plurality voting method brings to the election process. By reducing the potential for prolonged votes and confusion, supporters believe this approach encourages greater participation and swifter governance. However, there may be concerns among some legislators about the implications of changing traditional voting practices, particularly in response to past experiences with majority voting mechanics.
Contention
While the bill presents a straightforward solution for the upcoming election, any contention primarily revolves around the shift from majority to plurality voting. Critics may raise questions about the efficacy of plurality votes in ensuring representation, especially in closely contested races. This resolution essentially overrides Joint Rule 10 for one election cycle, which could provoke discussions on the implications for future elections and the potential need for reinstating majority voting methods thereafter.
Joint resolution establishing a procedure for the conduct of the election of the University of Vermont and State Agricultural College trustees by plurality vote by the General Assembly in 2025
Joint resolution establishing a procedure for the conduct of the election of two legislative trustees of the Vermont State Colleges Corporation by plurality vote by the General Assembly in 2024
Joint resolution providing for a Joint Assembly for the election of an Adjutant and Inspector General, and two legislative Trustees of the Vermont State Colleges Corporation
Senate Resolution Creating A Special Senate Commission To Study Non-plurality Voting Methods And Runoff Elections For General Assembly And General Officer Primaries (creates A 7 Member Commission To Study Non-plurality Voting And Runoff Elections For General Assembly And General Officer Primaries, And Report Back To The President Of The Senate By October 31, 2023, And Expire On December 31, 2023)