West Virginia 2023 Regular Session

West Virginia Senate Bill SB115

Introduced
1/11/23  
Refer
1/11/23  
Report Pass
1/17/23  
Engrossed
1/20/23  
Refer
1/23/23  

Caption

Providing procedure for WV to select delegates to Article V Convention

Impact

The implementation of SB115 would reinforce the state's ability to engage in the constitutional amendment process while ensuring that its delegates are held to strict ethical standards. Violating the oath taken by delegates can result in severe penalties, including felony charges and significant fines. This strict accountability aim is intended to maintain the integrity of West Virginia's representation at the national level. Moreover, the bill prohibits any delegate from attending a convention that allows voting based on state population, thus promoting equal representation among the states.

Summary

Senate Bill 115 aims to establish a procedural framework for the State of West Virginia to select delegates for participating in an Article V convention, which is a constitutional mechanism for proposing amendments to the United States Constitution. The bill outlines specific roles and responsibilities for these delegates, including an oath they must take, which commits them to uphold constitutional laws and prevents them from endorsing unauthorized amendments. By creating this structure, the bill seeks to ensure that West Virginia's delegates operate within a clearly defined legal context when representing the state at such a convention.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB115 appears to be largely positive among its proponents, who view it as a necessary step for achieving constitutional reform and empowering state-level legislative authority. Supporters argue that it protects the state’s interests and ensures that representatives align with the desired constitutional standards. However, there may also be concerns about the restriction on amendments and potential backlash regarding the penalties imposed on delegates, reflecting a tension between efficient governance and legislative overreach.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding SB115 include discussions around the feasibility and implications of sending delegates to an Article V convention, particularly concerning the risks associated with the potential for radical amendments to the Constitution. Critics may raise concerns about the authority and limitations placed on delegates, questioning whether such severe penalties are necessary and whether they could deter qualified candidates from participating. Ultimately, debates could hinge on the balance between maintaining strict legislative control over representatives and allowing for a dynamic constitutional amendment process.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

WV SB435

Updating WV Law Institute

WV HB2653

Updating the West Virginia Law Institute

WV HB2199

Creating the Intrastate Coal and Use Act

WV HB4639

Creation of a Higher Education Prison Task Force

WV HB2603

Limit number of visitor bureaus that can exist in a county

WV SR29

Designating February 16, 2022, as WV State University Day

WV SCR46

Supporting North Central WV aviation and aerospace industries

WV HB4428

WV Small Business COVID Relief Act