Connecticut 2024 Regular Session

Connecticut Senate Bill SB00431 Latest Draft

Bill / Comm Sub Version Filed 04/10/2024

                             
 
LCO   	1 of 12 
  
General Assembly  Substitute Bill No. 431  
February Session, 2024 
 
 
 
 
AN ACT CONCERNING FEES FOR COPYING, REVIEWING AND 
REDACTING RECORDS CREATED BY POLICE BODY -WORN 
RECORDING EQUIPMENT AND DASHBOARD CAMERAS.  
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General 
Assembly convened: 
 
Section 1. Section 29-6d of the 2024 supplement to the general statutes 1 
is repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective 2 
October 1, 2024): 3 
(a) For purposes of this section, [and] section 2 of this act and section 4 
7-277b: 5 
(1) "Law enforcement unit" has the same meaning as provided in 6 
section 7-294a;  7 
(2) "Police officer" means a sworn member of a law enforcement unit 8 
or any member of a law enforcement unit who performs police duties; 9 
(3) "Body-worn recording equipment" means an electronic recording 10 
device that is capable of recording audio and video;  11 
(4) "Dashboard camera" means a dashboard camera with a remote 12 
recorder, as defined in section 7-277b;  13 
(5) "Digital data storage device or service" means a device or service 14 
that retains the data from the recordings made by body-worn recording 15  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	2 of 12 
 
equipment using computer data storage; [and]  16 
(6) "Police patrol vehicle" means any state or local police vehicle other 17 
than an administrative vehicle in which an occupant is wearing body-18 
worn camera equipment, a bicycle, a motor scooter, an all-terrain 19 
vehicle, an electric personal assistive mobility device, as defined in 20 
subsection (a) of section 14-289h, or an animal control vehicle; 21 
(7) "Freedom of Information Act" has the same meaning as provided 22 
in section 1-200; 23 
(8) "Requesting party" means the person requesting a record created 24 
using body-worn recording equipment or a dashboard camera pursuant 25 
to the Freedom of Information Act;  26 
(9) "Involved person" means (A) any individual depicted in the 27 
record created using body-worn recording equipment or a dashboard 28 
camera, (B) any individual directly involved in the incident that led to 29 
the police officer being called to respond, or (C) any police officer 30 
responding to such incident, including the police officer whose body-31 
worn recording equipment or dashboard camera created the record; and  32 
(10) "Redact" means to obscure, pixelate or mute any portion of a 33 
record created using body-worn recording equipment or a dashboard 34 
camera. 35 
(b) The Commissioner of Emergency Services and Public Protection 36 
and the Police Officer Standards and Training Council shall jointly 37 
evaluate and approve the minimal technical specifications of body-worn 38 
recording equipment that shall be worn by police officers pursuant to 39 
this section, dashboard cameras that shall be used in each police patrol 40 
vehicle and digital data storage devices or services that shall be used by 41 
a law enforcement unit to retain the data from the recordings made by 42 
such equipment. The commissioner and council shall make such 43 
minimal technical specifications available to each law enforcement unit 44 
in a manner determined by the commissioner and council. The 45 
commissioner and council may revise the minimal technical 46  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	3 of 12 
 
specifications when the commissioner and council determine that 47 
revisions to such specifications are necessary. 48 
(c) (1) Each police officer shall use body-worn recording equipment 49 
while interacting with the public in such sworn member's law 50 
enforcement capacity, except as provided in subsection (g) of this 51 
section, or in the case of a municipal police department, in accordance 52 
with the department's policy adopted by the department and based on 53 
guidelines maintained pursuant to subsection (j) of this section, 54 
concerning the use of body-worn recording equipment. 55 
(2) Each police officer shall wear body-worn recording equipment on 56 
such officer's outer-most garment and shall position such equipment 57 
above the midline of such officer's torso when using such equipment. 58 
(3) Body-worn recording equipment used pursuant to this section 59 
shall conform to the minimal technical specifications approved 60 
pursuant to subsection (b) of this section, except that a police officer may 61 
use body-worn recording equipment that does not conform to the 62 
minimal technical specifications approved pursuant to subsection (b) of 63 
this section, if such equipment was purchased prior to January 1, 2016, 64 
by the law enforcement unit employing such officer. 65 
(4) Each law enforcement unit shall require usage of a dashboard 66 
camera in each police patrol vehicle used by any police officer employed 67 
by such unit in accordance with the unit's policy adopted by the unit 68 
and based on guidelines maintained pursuant to subsection (j) of this 69 
section, concerning dashboard cameras. 70 
(d) Except as required by state or federal law, no person employed by 71 
a law enforcement unit shall edit, erase, copy, share or otherwise alter 72 
or distribute in any manner any recording made by body-worn 73 
recording equipment or a dashboard camera or the data from such 74 
recording. 75 
(e) A police officer may review a recording from his or her body-worn 76 
recording equipment or a dashboard camera in order to assist such 77  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	4 of 12 
 
officer with the preparation of a report or otherwise in the performance 78 
of his or her duties. 79 
(f) (1) If a police officer is giving a formal statement about the use of 80 
force or if a police officer is the subject of a disciplinary investigation in 81 
which a recording from body-worn recording equipment or a 82 
dashboard camera is being considered as part of a review of an incident, 83 
the officer shall have the right to review (A) such recording in the 84 
presence of the officer's attorney or labor representative, and (B) 85 
recordings from other body-worn recording equipment capturing the 86 
officer's image or voice during the incident. Not later than forty-eight 87 
hours following an officer's review of a recording under subparagraph 88 
(A) of this subdivision, or if the officer does not review the recording, 89 
not later than ninety-six hours following the initiation of such 90 
disciplinary investigation, whichever is earlier, such recording shall be 91 
disclosed, upon request, to the public, subject to the provisions of 92 
subsection (g) of this section. Public disclosure may be delayed if the 93 
officer, due to a medical or physical response or an acute psychological 94 
stress response to the incident, is not reasonably able to review a 95 
recording under this subdivision, but in no event shall disclosure be 96 
delayed more than one hundred forty-four hours following the 97 
recorded event. 98 
(2) If a request is made for public disclosure of a recording from body-99 
worn recording equipment or a dashboard camera of an incident about 100 
which (A) a police officer has not been asked to give a formal statement 101 
about the alleged use of force, or (B) a disciplinary investigation has not 102 
been initiated, any police officer whose image or voice is captured on 103 
the recording shall have the right to review such recording in the 104 
presence of the officer's attorney or labor representative. Not later than 105 
forty-eight hours following an officer's review of a recording under this 106 
subdivision, or if the officer does not review the recording, not later than 107 
ninety-six hours following the request for disclosure, whichever is 108 
earlier, such recording shall be disclosed to the public, subject to the 109 
provisions of subsection (g) of this section. Public disclosure may be 110 
delayed if the officer, due to a medical or physical response or an acute 111  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	5 of 12 
 
psychological stress response to the incident, is not reasonably able to 112 
review a recording under this subdivision, but in no event shall 113 
disclosure be delayed more than one hundred forty-four hours 114 
following the recorded event. 115 
(g) (1) Except as otherwise provided by any agreement between a law 116 
enforcement unit and the federal government, no police officer shall use 117 
body-worn recording equipment or a dashboard camera, if applicable, 118 
to intentionally record (A) a communication with other law enforcement 119 
unit personnel, except that which may be recorded as the officer 120 
performs his or her duties, (B) an encounter with an undercover officer 121 
or informant or an officer performing detective work described in 122 
guidelines developed pursuant to subsection (j) of this section, (C) when 123 
an officer is on break or is otherwise engaged in a personal activity, (D) 124 
a person undergoing a medical or psychological evaluation, procedure 125 
or treatment, (E) any person other than a suspect to a crime if an officer 126 
is wearing such equipment in a hospital or other medical facility setting, 127 
or (F) in a mental health facility, unless responding to a call involving a 128 
suspect to a crime who is thought to be present in the facility. 129 
(2) No record created using body-worn recording equipment or a 130 
dashboard camera of (A) an occurrence or situation described in 131 
subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, of subdivision (1) of this subsection, 132 
(B) a scene of an incident that involves (i) a victim of domestic or sexual 133 
abuse, (ii) a victim of homicide or suicide, or (iii) a deceased victim of an 134 
accident, if disclosure could reasonably be expected to constitute an 135 
unwarranted invasion of personal privacy in the case of any such victim 136 
described in this subparagraph, or (C) a minor, shall be subject to 137 
disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act, [as defined in section 138 
1-200,] and any such record shall be confidential and redacted in 139 
accordance with section 2 of this act, except that (i) a record of an 140 
involved person or the requesting party undergoing a medical or 141 
psychological evaluation, procedure or treatment shall be disclosed to 142 
such involved person or the requesting party, and (ii) a record of a minor 143 
shall be disclosed if [(i)] (I) the minor and the parent or guardian of such 144 
minor consent to the disclosure of such record, [(ii)] or, if the minor is 145  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	6 of 12 
 
an involved person, the minor's parent or guardian is the requesting 146 
party or an involved person, (II) a police officer is the subject of an 147 
allegation of misconduct made by such minor or the parent or guardian 148 
of such minor, and the person representing such officer in an 149 
investigation of such alleged misconduct requests disclosure of such 150 
record for the sole purpose of preparing a defense to such allegation, or 151 
[(iii)] (III) a person is charged with a crime and defense counsel for such 152 
person requests disclosure of such record for the sole purpose of 153 
assisting in such person's defense and the discovery of such record as 154 
evidence is otherwise discoverable. 155 
(3) Any record created using body-worn recording equipment or a 156 
dashboard camera, the disclosure of which the public agency 157 
determines could reasonably be expected to constitute an invasion of 158 
personal privacy and that depicts the following shall be redacted prior 159 
to disclosure of such record under the Freedom of Information Act: (A) 160 
The inside of a private residence, except that a record showing the inside 161 
of a private residence of the requesting party or an involved person may 162 
be disclosed to such requesting party or involved person, as applicable, 163 
or (B) an individual in a state of undress or nudity, except that a record 164 
showing the requesting party or an involved party in a state of undress 165 
or nudity may be disclosed to such requesting party or involved person, 166 
as applicable. 167 
(h) No police officer shall use body-worn recording equipment prior 168 
to being trained in accordance with section 7-294s in the use of such 169 
equipment and in the retention of data created by such equipment. A 170 
law enforcement unit shall ensure that each police officer such unit 171 
employs receives such training at least annually and is trained on the 172 
proper care and maintenance of such equipment. 173 
(i) If a police officer is aware that any body-worn recording 174 
equipment or dashboard camera is lost, damaged or malfunctioning, 175 
such officer shall inform such officer's supervisor in writing as soon as 176 
is practicable. Upon receiving such information, the supervisor shall 177 
ensure that the body-worn recording equipment or dashboard camera 178  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	7 of 12 
 
is inspected and repaired or replaced, as necessary. Each police officer 179 
shall inspect and test body-worn recording equipment prior to each shift 180 
to verify proper functioning, and shall notify such officer's supervisor 181 
of any problems with such equipment. 182 
(j) The Commissioner of Emergency Services and Public Protection 183 
and the Police Officer Standards and Training Council shall jointly 184 
maintain guidelines pertaining to the use of body-worn recording 185 
equipment and dashboard cameras, including the type of detective 186 
work an officer might engage in that should not be recorded, retention 187 
of data created by such equipment and dashboard cameras and methods 188 
for safe and secure storage of such data. The guidelines shall not require 189 
a law enforcement unit to store such data for a period longer than one 190 
year, except in the case where the unit knows the data is pertinent to any 191 
ongoing civil, criminal or administrative matter. Each law enforcement 192 
unit and any police officer and any other employee of such unit who 193 
may have access to such data shall adhere to such guidelines. The 194 
commissioner and council may update and reissue such guidelines, as 195 
the commissioner and council determine necessary. The commissioner 196 
and council shall, upon issuance of such guidelines or any update to 197 
such guidelines, submit such guidelines in accordance with the 198 
provisions of section 11-4a to the joint standing committees of the 199 
General Assembly having cognizance of matters relating to the judiciary 200 
and public safety. 201 
(k) (1) Not later than October 1, 2023, the Police Officer Standards and 202 
Training Council, in consultation with the Institute for Municipal and 203 
Regional Policy at The University of Connecticut, shall prescribe a form 204 
to be used by law enforcement units to report each unit's compliance 205 
with the provisions of subsection (c) of this section. Such form shall 206 
require the compilation of information including, but not limited to, (A) 207 
the number of body-worn recording devices in operation in a law 208 
enforcement unit, (B) the number of dashboard cameras in operation in 209 
a law enforcement unit, (C) the number of police patrol vehicles not 210 
equipped with a dashboard camera in a law enforcement unit and the 211 
reasons such vehicles are not so equipped, (D) information regarding 212  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	8 of 12 
 
any incidents in which a police officer of a law enforcement unit was 213 
found in an internal investigation conducted by such unit to have 214 
violated such unit's policy regarding the use of body-worn recording 215 
equipment or dashboard cameras, and (E) any other information 216 
deemed necessary. 217 
(2) Not later than January 1, 2024, and annually thereafter, each law 218 
enforcement unit shall submit a report on the form prescribed pursuant 219 
to subdivision (1) of this subsection concerning the unit's compliance 220 
with the provisions of subsection (c) of this section to the Institute for 221 
Municipal and Regional Policy at The University of Connecticut. The 222 
institute shall post such reports on the institute's Internet web site. 223 
(3) Not later than July 1, 2024, and annually thereafter, the Institute 224 
for Municipal and Regional Policy at The University of Connecticut 225 
shall, within available appropriations, review the reports submitted 226 
pursuant to subdivision (2) of this subsection, and report the results of 227 
such review and any recommendations as a result of such review to the 228 
Governor, the Police Officer Standards and Training Council, the 229 
Criminal Justice Policy and Planning Division within the Office of Policy 230 
and Management and, in accordance with the provisions of section 11-231 
4a, the joint standing committees of the General Assembly having 232 
cognizance of matters relating to the judiciary and public safety and 233 
security. 234 
Sec. 2. (NEW) (Effective October 1, 2024) (a) Except as provided in 235 
subsections (b) and (c) of this section, any public agency, as defined in 236 
section 1-200 of the general statutes, that maintains a copy of a record 237 
created using body-worn recording equipment or a dashboard camera 238 
pursuant to section 29-6d of the general statutes, as amended by this act, 239 
may charge the requesting party a redaction fee for any such record that 240 
requires redaction in accordance with the provisions of this section. 241 
Such fee shall compensate the public agency for the time spent redacting 242 
any portion of the requested record as required or authorized by state 243 
or federal law, including, but not limited to, the provisions of subsection 244 
(g) of section 29-6d of the general statutes, as amended by this act. Such 245  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	9 of 12 
 
fee shall be calculated as follows: 246 
(1) The public agency shall not charge the requesting party for the 247 
time spent searching for the applicable record that is responsive to the 248 
request. 249 
(2) (A) Except as provided in subparagraph (B) of this subdivision, 250 
the first two hours of labor costs incurred by the public agency in 251 
redacting the requested record shall not be charged to the requesting 252 
party. 253 
(B) The first four hours of labor costs incurred by the public agency 254 
in redacting the requested record shall not be charged to the requesting 255 
party if the requesting party is (i) the parent or legal guardian of an 256 
involved person, or (ii) an attorney representing an involved person in 257 
any civil, criminal or administrative matter. 258 
(3) Except as provided in subsection (c) of this section, any additional 259 
labor costs associated with any time necessary to redact the requested 260 
record beyond the applicable time set forth in subdivision (2) of this 261 
subsection may be charged to the requesting party at a rate not to exceed 262 
the hourly wage of the lowest-paid employee with the requisite training 263 
for redacting the responsive record. For purposes of this subdivision, 264 
the hourly wage of an employee shall be based upon the employee's 265 
base salary and shall not include benefits. The responding agency shall 266 
not charge the requesting party for the services of any attorney hired by 267 
the responding agency to conduct a second review of the requested 268 
record or any company providing digital management services to the 269 
responding agency. 270 
(4) Any fee charged to a requesting party under this subsection shall 271 
not exceed one hundred dollars per hour of the actual length of time of 272 
the record requested. In calculating the fee under this subsection, the 273 
public agency may round up the actual length of time of the record 274 
requested to the nearest half hour at a rate of fifty dollars per half hour. 275 
(5) If the amount to be charged to the requesting party in accordance 276  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	10 of 12 
 
with subdivision (3) of this subsection is estimated to exceed two 277 
hundred fifty dollars, the public agency shall inform the requesting 278 
party of the estimated fee and may require prepayment of such fee prior 279 
to redacting the requested record. If the amount of prepaid fees exceeds 280 
the actual labor costs incurred by the public agency in redacting the 281 
requested record, the public agency shall reimburse the requesting 282 
party for any difference between the prepaid amount and actual cost. 283 
(b) The public agency shall waive any fee authorized under this 284 
section if required under subsection (d) of section 1-212 of the general 285 
statutes. 286 
(c) A public agency shall not charge a fee to any requesting party who 287 
is an involved person in the record requested. A public agency shall not 288 
charge a fee to any other requesting party if (1) the record depicts (A) a 289 
police officer involved in a shooting, (B) a police officer involved in a 290 
motor vehicle accident, or (C) a police officer giving a formal statement 291 
about the use of force, or (2) (A) there is an allegation of misconduct 292 
concerning the police officer involved, or (B) the police officer involved 293 
is the subject of a disciplinary investigation, subject to any limitations 294 
on disclosure set forth in subsection (g) of section 29-6d of the general 295 
statutes, as amended by this act.  296 
(d) The public agency shall maintain an original, unredacted copy of 297 
any requested record that is redacted for public dissemination in 298 
accordance with the provisions of this section. 299 
(e) If the Freedom of Information Commission determines that a 300 
public agency has violated any provision of this section, the Freedom of 301 
Information Commission may order the public agency to refund any 302 
payment made under this section. 303 
Sec. 3. Subsections (a) and (b) of section 1-212 of the general statutes 304 
are repealed and the following is substituted in lieu thereof (Effective 305 
October 1, 2024): 306 
(a) Any person applying in writing shall receive, promptly upon 307  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	11 of 12 
 
request, a plain, facsimile, electronic or certified copy of any public 308 
record. The type of copy provided shall be within the discretion of the 309 
public agency, except (1) the agency shall provide a certified copy 310 
whenever requested, and (2) if the applicant does not have access to a 311 
computer or facsimile machine, the public agency shall not send the 312 
applicant an electronic or facsimile copy. [The] Except as provided in 313 
section 2 of this act, the fee for any copy provided in accordance with 314 
the Freedom of Information Act: 315 
(A) By an executive, administrative or legislative office of the state, a 316 
state agency or a department, institution, bureau, board, commission, 317 
authority or official of the state, including a committee of, or created by, 318 
such an office, agency, department, institution, bureau, board, 319 
commission, authority or official, and also including any judicial office, 320 
official or body or committee thereof but only in respect to its or their 321 
administrative functions, shall not exceed twenty-five cents per page; 322 
and 323 
(B) By all other public agencies, as defined in section 1-200, shall not 324 
exceed fifty cents per page. If any copy provided in accordance with said 325 
Freedom of Information Act requires a transcription, or if any person 326 
applies for a transcription of a public record, the fee for such 327 
transcription shall not exceed the cost thereof to the public agency. 328 
(b) The fee for any copy provided in accordance with subsection (a) 329 
of section 1-211 shall not exceed the cost thereof to the public agency. 330 
[In] Except as provided in section 2 of this act, in determining such costs 331 
for a copy, other than for a printout which exists at the time that the 332 
agency responds to the request for such copy, an agency may include 333 
only: 334 
(1) An amount equal to the hourly salary attributed to all agency 335 
employees engaged in providing the requested computer-stored public 336 
record, including their time performing the formatting or programming 337 
functions necessary to provide the copy as requested, but not including 338 
search or retrieval costs except as provided in subdivision (4) of this 339  Substitute Bill No. 431 
 
 
LCO     	12 of 12 
 
subsection; 340 
(2) An amount equal to the cost to the agency of engaging an outside 341 
professional electronic copying service to provide such copying 342 
services, if such service is necessary to provide the copying as requested; 343 
(3) The actual cost of the storage devices or media provided to the 344 
person making the request in complying with such request; and 345 
(4) The computer time charges incurred by the agency in providing 346 
the requested computer-stored public record where another agency or 347 
contractor provides the agency with computer storage and retrieval 348 
services. Notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the fee for 349 
any copy of the names of registered voters shall not exceed three cents 350 
per name delivered or the cost thereof to the public agency, as 351 
determined pursuant to this subsection, whichever is less. The 352 
Department of Administrative Services shall provide guidelines to 353 
agencies regarding the calculation of the fees charged for copies of 354 
computer-stored public records to ensure that such fees are reasonable 355 
and consistent among agencies. 356 
This act shall take effect as follows and shall amend the following 
sections: 
 
Section 1 October 1, 2024 29-6d 
Sec. 2 October 1, 2024 New section 
Sec. 3 October 1, 2024 1-212(a) and (b) 
 
Statement of Legislative Commissioners:   
In Section 2(a)(3), an exception was added for consistency. 
 
GAE Joint Favorable Subst.