Georgia 2023-2024 Regular Session

Georgia Senate Bill SB92 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
1-23 SB 92/AP
2-S. B. 92
1+LC 47 2519S
32 - 1 -
4-Senate Bill 92
5-By: Senators Robertson of the 29th, Kennedy of the 18th, Walker III of the 20th, Cowsert
6-of the 46th, Brass of the 28th and others
7-AS PASSED SENATE
3+The House Committee on Rules offers the following substitute to SB 92:
84 A BILL TO BE ENTITLED
95 AN ACT
10-To amend Chapter 18 of Title 15 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to
11-1
6+To amend Chapter 18 of Title 15 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to1
127 prosecuting attorneys, so as to provide for duties of district attorneys; to create the2
138 Prosecuting Attorneys Qualifications Commission; to provide for definitions; to provide for3
149 the powers, composition, appointment, and confirmation of such commission; to provide for4
1510 commission members' terms, vacancies, and removals; to provide for procedures and5
1611 confidentiality; to disqualify certain individuals for a certain amount of time from being6
1712 appointed or elected to the offices of district attorney or solicitor-general; to amend Chapter 47
1813 of Title 21 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to recall of public officers,8
1914 so as to revise provisions relating to grounds for recall of district attorneys of judicial circuits9
2015 and solicitors-general of state courts; to provide for related matters; to provide for an10
2116 effective date; to repeal conflicting laws; and for other purposes.11
2217 BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF GEORGIA:12
2318 SECTION 1.13
2419 Chapter 18 of Title 15 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to prosecuting14
2520 attorneys, is amended by revising Code Section 15-18-6, relating to duties of district15
26-attorney, as follows:16 23 SB 92/AP
27-S. B. 92
21+attorney, as follows:16 LC 47 2519S
2822 - 2 -
29-"15-18-6.
30-17
23+"15-18-6.17
3124 The duties of the district attorneys within their respective circuits are:18
3225 (1) To attend each session of the superior courts unless excused by the judge thereof and19
3326 to remain until the business of the state is disposed of;20
3427 (2) To attend on the grand juries, advise them in relation to matters of law, and swear and21
3528 examine witnesses before them;22
3629 (3) To administer the oaths the laws require to the grand and trial jurors and to the23
3730 bailiffs or other officers of the court and otherwise to aid the presiding judge in24
3831 organizing the courts as he may require;25
39-(4) To review every individual case for which probable cause for prosecution exists, and
40-26
32+(4) To review every individual case for which probable cause for prosecution exists, and26
4133 make a prosecutorial decision available under the law based on the facts and27
4234 circumstances of each individual case under oath of duty as provided in Code Section28
4335 15-18-2;29
4436 (4)(5) To draw up all indictments or presentments, when requested by the grand jury, and30
4537 to prosecute all indictable offenses;31
4638 (5)(6) To prosecute civil actions to enforce any civil penalty set forth in Code Section32
4739 40-6-163 and to prosecute or defend any other civil action in the prosecution or defense33
4840 of which the state is interested, unless otherwise specially provided for;34
4941 (6)(7) To attend before the appellate courts when any criminal case emanating from their35
5042 respective circuits is tried, to argue the same, and to perform any other duty therein which36
5143 the interest of the state may require;37
5244 (7)(8) To advise law enforcement officers concerning the sufficiency of evidence,38
5345 warrants, and similar matters relating to the investigation and prosecution of criminal39
5446 offenses;40
5547 (8)(9) To collect all money due the state in the hands of any escheators and to pay it over41
5648 to the educational fund, if necessary, compelling payment by rule or order of court or42
57-other legal means;43 23 SB 92/AP
58-S. B. 92
49+other legal means;43 LC 47 2519S
5950 - 3 -
6051 (9)(10) To collect all claims of the state which they may be ordered to collect by the state44
6152 revenue commissioner and to remit the same within 30 days after collection; and on45
6253 October 1 of every year to report to the state revenue commissioner the condition of the46
6354 claims in their hands in favor of the state, particularly specifying:47
6455 (A) The amounts collected and paid, from what sources received and for what48
6556 purposes, and to whom paid;49
6657 (B) What claims are unpaid and why;50
6758 (C) What judgments have been obtained, when, and in what court; and51
6859 (D) What actions are instituted, in what courts, and their present progress and future52
6960 prospects;53
7061 (10)(11) To ensure disposition information is submitted in accordance with subsection54
7162 (g) of Code Section 35-3-36 when a final disposition decision is made by a district55
7263 attorney;56
7364 (11)(12) To assist victims and witnesses of crimes through the complexities of the57
7465 criminal justice system and ensure that the victims of crimes are apprised of the rights58
7566 afforded them under the law; and59
7667 (12)(13) To perform such other duties as are or may be required by law or which60
7768 necessarily appertain to their office."61
7869 SECTION 2.62
7970 Said chapter is further amended by adding a new Code section to Article 1, relating to63
8071 general provisions relative to prosecuting attorneys, to read as follows:64
8172 "15-18-32.65
8273 (a) Pursuant to Article VI, Section VIII, Paragraph II of the Constitution of Georgia in66
8374 reference to district attorneys and Article 3 of this chapter in reference to solicitors-general67
8475 of state courts, there is hereby created the Prosecuting Attorneys Qualifications68
85-Commission, which shall have the power to discipline, remove, and cause involuntary69 23 SB 92/AP
86-S. B. 92
76+Commission, which shall have the power to discipline, remove, and cause involuntary69 LC 47 2519S
8777 - 4 -
8878 retirement of appointed or elected district attorneys or solicitors-general in accordance with70
8979 such Paragraph. As used in this Code section, the term 'commission' means the Prosecuting71
9080 Attorneys Qualifications Commission.72
9181 (b) The commission shall consist of eight members.73
9282 (c)(1) The commission shall be divided into a five-member investigative panel and a74
9383 three-member hearing panel.75
9484 (2) The investigative panel shall be responsible for:76
9585 (A) The investigative, prosecutorial, and administrative functions of the commission;77
9686 (B) Investigation of alleged conduct constituting grounds for discipline under78
9787 subsection (h) of this Code section;79
9888 (C) The selection of an individual to serve as the director of the commission who shall80
9989 be an active status member of the State Bar of Georgia and who shall not engage in the81
10090 practice of law, other than to represent the commission; and82
10191 (D) Authorization of employment of such additional staff as the commission deems83
10292 necessary to carry out the powers assigned to the commission.84
10393 (3) The hearing panel shall be responsible for:85
10494 (A) Adjudicating formal charges filed by the investigative panel;86
10595 (B) Issuing disciplinary and incapacity orders;87
10696 (C) Issuing formal advisory opinions on its own initiative or on the recommendation88
10797 of the investigative panel regarding the grounds for discipline set forth under subsection89
10898 (h) of this Code section; and90
10999 (D) Issuing standards on its own initiative or on the recommendation of the91
110100 investigative panel. Any such standards shall elaborate, define, or provide context for92
111101 the grounds for discipline as set forth in subsection (h) of this Code section.93
112102 (d)(1) As used in this subsection, the term:94
113103 (A) 'Attorney' means a lawyer who has been an active status member of the State Bar95
114-of Georgia for at least ten years and is a registered voter in this state.96 23 SB 92/AP
115-S. B. 92
104+of Georgia for at least ten years and is a registered voter in this state.96 LC 47 2519S
116105 - 5 -
117106 (B) 'Judge' means an elected or appointed public official who presides over a court of97
118107 record.98
119108 (2) The Prosecuting Attorneys' Council of the State of Georgia may recommend to the99
120109 respective appointing authorities a list of the names of individuals for consideration to100
121110 serve as attorney commission members.101
122111 (3)(A) The five members of the commission's investigative panel shall be appointed102
123112 as follows:103
124113 (i) One attorney with prosecutorial experience as an elected district attorney or104
125114 elected solicitor-general shall be appointed by the Governor and shall serve a term of105
126115 four years; provided, however, that the initial appointment shall be for three years,106
127116 and thereafter, successors to such member shall serve terms of four years;107
128117 (ii) One attorney with at least five years of service as an assistant district attorney or108
129118 an assistant solicitor-general shall be appointed by the Lieutenant Governor and shall109
130119 serve a term of four years; provided, however, that the initial appointment shall be for110
131120 two years, and thereafter, successors to such member shall serve terms of four years;111
132121 (iii) Two practicing attorneys shall be appointed by the Speaker of the House of112
133122 Representatives and each shall serve terms of four years; provided, however, that the113
134123 initial appointment of one attorney member as designated by the Speaker of the House114
135124 of Representatives shall be for four years and the initial appointment of the other115
136125 attorney member as designated by the Speaker of the House of Representatives shall116
137126 be for one year, and thereafter, successors to such members shall serve terms of four117
138127 years; and118
139128 (iv) One attorney with at least five years of service as an assistant district attorney or119
140129 an assistant solicitor-general shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on120
141130 Assignments and shall serve a term of four years; provided, however, that the initial121
142131 appointment shall be for three years, and thereafter, successors to such member shall122
143-serve terms of four years.123 23 SB 92/AP
144-S. B. 92
132+serve terms of four years.123 LC 47 2519S
145133 - 6 -
146134 (B) The investigative panel members shall annually elect a chairperson and vice124
147135 chairperson for such panel.125
148136 (4) The three members of the commission's hearing panel shall be appointed as follows:126
149137 (A) One elected district attorney or elected solicitor-general shall be appointed by the127
150138 Governor for a term of four years and his or her successors shall serve terms of four128
151139 years; provided, however, that the initial appointment shall be for three years, and129
152140 thereafter, successors to such member shall serve terms of four years;130
153141 (B) One elected district attorney or elected solicitor-general shall be appointed by of131
154142 the Senate Committee on Assignments and shall be the presiding officer of the hearing132
155143 panel and shall serve a term of four years; provided, however, that the initial133
156144 appointment shall be for one year, and thereafter, successors to such member shall serve134
157145 terms of four years; and135
158146 (C) One former judge of the superior court or Court of Appeals or former Justice who136
159147 shall have at least ten years of service as a judge or Justice and has formerly been a137
160148 district attorney or a solicitor-general shall be appointed by the Speaker of the House138
161149 of Representatives and shall serve a term of four years; provided, however, that the139
162150 initial appointment shall be for three years, and thereafter, successors to such member140
163151 shall serve terms of four years.141
164152 (5) All members shall be appointed by and their initial terms shall begin on July 1, 2023;142
165153 provided, however, that the initial term of a member under this paragraph shall not be143
166154 construed as counting toward the limit of two full terms of service as provided for under144
167155 paragraph (6) of this subsection.145
168156 (6) A commission member shall be eligible to serve so long as he or she retains his or146
169157 her status as an attorney, citizen, or district attorney, but a vacancy shall be created by147
170158 operation of law when he or she no longer has the designation for which he or she was148
171159 appointed. Any vacancy for a member shall be filled by the appointing authority, and149
172-such appointee shall serve the balance of the vacating member's unexpired term;150 23 SB 92/AP
173-S. B. 92
160+such appointee shall serve the balance of the vacating member's unexpired term;150 LC 47 2519S
174161 - 7 -
175162 provided, however, that, if the appointing authority fails to fill a vacancy within 60 days151
176163 of being notified of such vacancy by the commission, the Governor shall appoint a152
177164 replacement member from the same category of member. Any member of the153
178165 commission shall serve no more than two full terms.154
179166 (e) Members and staff of the hearing panel shall not engage in any ex parte155
180167 communications regarding a disciplinary or incapacity matter of a district attorney or156
181168 solicitor-general, including with members and staff of the investigative panel.157
182169 (f)(1) Each member of the commission shall be entitled to vote on any matter coming158
183170 before his or her respective panel unless otherwise provided by rules adopted by the159
184171 commission concerning recusal. The chairperson of the investigative panel and the160
185172 presiding officer of the hearing panel shall retain a vote on all matters except those in161
186173 which such chairperson or presiding officer has been recused. No commission member162
187174 present at a panel meeting shall abstain from voting unless he or she is recused. The rules163
188175 of the commission shall establish grounds for recusal and the process for allowing a164
189176 temporary replacement of a commission member in such circumstance.165
190177 (2)(A) As used in this paragraph, the term 'for cause' shall include indictment for or166
191178 conviction of a felony or any offense involving moral turpitude; misconduct,167
192179 malpractice, malfeasance, misfeasance, nonfeasance, or incapacity; failure to attend168
193180 three or more panel meetings or hearings in a one-year period without good and169
194181 sufficient reason; or abstaining from voting, unless recused.170
195182 (B) Removal of a panel member for cause shall be by a unanimous vote of all members171
196183 of the commission; provided, however, that the panel member who is the subject of the172
197184 vote shall not vote.173
198185 (3) A quorum of the investigative panel shall require any three members of such panel.174
199186 (4)(A) Members of the commission shall serve without compensation but shall receive175
200187 the same daily expense allowance as members of the General Assembly receive, as set176
201-forth in Code Section 28-1-8, for each day such member is in physical attendance at a177 23 SB 92/AP
202-S. B. 92
188+forth in Code Section 28-1-8, for each day such member is in physical attendance at a177 LC 47 2519S
203189 - 8 -
204190 panel meeting or hearing, plus either reimbursement for actual transportation costs178
205191 while traveling by public transportation or the same mileage allowance for use of a179
206192 personal motor vehicle in connection with such attendance as members of the General180
207193 Assembly receive.181
208194 (B) Notwithstanding subparagraph (A) of this paragraph, no member shall receive such182
209195 expense allowance or travel reimbursement if he or she is entitled to receive an expense183
210196 allowance, travel reimbursement, or salary for performance of duties as a state184
211197 employee.185
212198 (C) Expense allowances and travel reimbursements shall be paid from moneys186
213199 appropriated or otherwise available to the commission.187
214200 (g) The commission, with the assistance of the Prosecuting Attorneys' Council of the State188
215201 of Georgia, shall promulgate standards of conduct and rules for the commission's189
216202 governance which will comport with due process and enforce the provisions of subsections190
217203 (h) and (i) of this Code section; provided, however, that such standards and rules shall be191
218204 effective only upon review and adoption by the Supreme Court. Such standards and rules192
219205 shall allow for a full investigation of a district attorney or solicitor-general only upon193
220206 majority vote of the investigative panel. When a commission member receives information194
221207 relating to the conduct of a district attorney or solicitor-general, such member shall provide195
222208 such information to the commission's director for appropriate action.196
223209 (h) The following shall be grounds for discipline of a district attorney or solicitor-general197
224210 or for his or her removal or involuntary retirement from office:198
225211 (1) Mental or physical incapacity interfering with the performance of his or her duties199
226212 which is, or is likely to become, permanent;200
227213 (2) Willful misconduct in office;201
228214 (3) With respect to district attorneys, willful and persistent failure to carry out duties202
229-pursuant to Code Section 15-18-6;203 23 SB 92/AP
230-S. B. 92
215+pursuant to Code Section 15-18-6;203 LC 47 2519S
231216 - 9 -
232217 (4) With respect to solicitors-general, willful and persistent failure to carry out duties204
233218 pursuant to Code Section 15-18-66;205
234219 (5) Conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude;206
235220 (6) Conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice which brings the office into207
236221 disrepute; or208
237222 (7) Knowingly authorizing or permitting an assistant district attorney or assistant209
238223 solicitor-general to commit any act constituting grounds for removal under paragraphs (1)210
239224 through (6) of this subsection.211
240225 (i)(1) In any complaint filed with the commission alleging a violation of subsection (h)212
241226 and requesting an investigation of an elected or appointed district attorney or213
242227 solicitor-general, the complainant shall be required to file with the commission a sworn214
243228 affidavit detailing the personal knowledge of the facts supporting the complaint,215
244229 including any interest the complainant may have in the outcome of the case. The216
245230 complainant may attach documents to support the complaint. Nothing in this Code217
246231 section shall be construed to limit the ability of the commission to bring a complaint218
247232 pursuant to this Code section on its own motion.219
248233 (2) The commission may not entertain a complaint on the basis of a charging decision,220
249234 plea offer, opposition to or grant of a continuance, placement of a case on a trial calendar,221
250235 or recommendation regarding bond unless the affidavits and any documents attached to222
251236 the complaint show it is plausible that the district attorney or solicitor-general made or223
252237 knowingly authorized the decision based on:224
253238 (A) Undue bias or prejudice against the accused or in favor of persons with interests225
254239 adverse to the accused;226
255240 (B) An undisclosed financial interest in the outcome of the prosecution;227
256241 (C) An undisclosed conflict of interest;228
257-(D) Factors that are completely unrelated to the duties of prosecution; or229 23 SB 92/AP
258-S. B. 92
242+(D) Factors that are completely unrelated to the duties of prosecution; or229 LC 47 2519S
259243 - 10 -
260244 (E) A stated policy, written or otherwise, which demonstrates that the district attorney230
261245 or solicitor-general categorically refuses to prosecute any offense or offenses of which231
262246 he or she is required by law to prosecute.232
263247 (3) Upon indictment of a district attorney or solicitor-general of a matter before either233
264248 panel, the commission shall suspend its investigation or hearing pending the outcome of234
265249 the procedure provided for in Code Section 45-5-6.235
266250 (j)(1) All information regarding a disciplinary or incapacity matter of a district attorney236
267251 or solicitor-general shall be kept confidential by the investigative panel and commission237
268252 staff before formal charges are filed; provided, however, that, if prior to filing formal238
269253 charges the judge and investigative panel agree to a satisfactory disposition of a239
270254 disciplinary matter other than by a private admonition or deferred discipline agreement,240
271255 a report of such disposition shall be publicly filed in the Supreme Court.241
272256 (2) After the filing and service of formal charges:242
273257 (A) With respect to an incapacity matter of a district attorney or solicitor-general, all243
274258 pleadings, information, hearings, and proceedings shall remain confidential; and244
275259 (B) With respect to a disciplinary matter of a district attorney or solicitor-general, all245
276260 pleadings and information shall be subject to disclosure to the public, and all hearings246
277261 and proceedings shall be open and available to the public, except to the extent that such247
278262 pleadings and information or hearings and proceedings could be properly sealed or248
279263 closed under Chapter 14 or Article 4 of Chapter 18 of Title 50 or by a court as provided249
280264 by law.250
281265 (3) With respect to administrative and other matters, all records and information shall be251
282266 subject to disclosure to the public, and all meetings, or portions thereof, shall be open and252
283267 available to the public, except to the extent that such records, information, and meetings253
284268 would:254
285269 (A) Disclose disciplinary matters of a district attorney or solicitor-general protected in255
286-paragraph (1) of this subsection;256 23 SB 92/AP
287-S. B. 92
270+paragraph (1) of this subsection;256 LC 47 2519S
288271 - 11 -
289272 (B) Disclose incapacity matters of a district attorney or solicitor-general protected in257
290273 paragraph (1) or subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of this subsection;258
291274 (C) Be considered a matter subject to executive session, if the commission were259
292275 considered to be an agency under Chapter 14 of Title 50; or260
293276 (D) Not be required to be publicly disclosed under Code Section 50-18-72, if the261
294277 commission were considered to be an agency under Article 4 of Chapter 18 of Title 50.262
295278 (4) The work product of the commission and its staff and the deliberations of the263
296279 commission shall remain confidential.264
297280 (k) Notwithstanding subsection (j) of this Code section, information regarding a265
298281 disciplinary or incapacity matter of a district attorney or solicitor-general may be disclosed266
299282 or the confidentiality of such information may be removed when:267
300283 (1) The privilege of confidentiality has been waived by the individual who was the268
301284 subject of the commission's investigation; or269
302285 (2) The commission's rules provide for disclosure:270
303286 (A) In the interest of justice and to protect the public;271
304287 (B) If an emergency situation exists; or272
305288 (C) If a district attorney or solicitor-general is under consideration for another state or273
306289 federal position.274
307290 (l) Information submitted to the commission or its staff, and testimony given in any275
308291 proceeding before the commission or one of its panels, shall be absolutely privileged, and276
309292 no civil action predicated upon such information or testimony shall be instituted against277
310293 any complainant, witness, or his or her counsel.278
311294 (m) A respondent may appeal the decision of the hearing panel by submitting a petition279
312295 to the superior court of the county where such respondent served as a district attorney or280
313296 solicitor-general. A respondent who is subjected to public reprimand, censure, limitation281
314297 on the performance of prosecutorial duties, suspension, retirement, or removal shall be282
315-entitled to a copy of the proposed record to be filed with the Supreme Court and, if the283 23 SB 92/AP
316-S. B. 92
298+entitled to a copy of the proposed record to be filed with the Supreme Court and, if the283 LC 47 2519S
317299 - 12 -
318300 respondent has objections to it, to have the record settled by the hearing panel's presiding284
319301 officer. The hearing panel's order in a disciplinary or incapacity matter may be appealed285
320302 to the Superior Court of Fulton County pursuant to Chapter 3 of Title 5.286
321303 (n) The commission shall commence by July 1, 2023, and the rules and regulations287
322304 promulgated by such commission shall be established no later than October 1, 2023. No288
323305 complaint shall be filed before October 1, 2023. The commission shall not receive289
324306 complaint submissions regarding misconduct in office that occurred prior to the effective290
325307 date of this Code section, unless such alleged misconduct is related to a continuous pattern291
326308 of conduct that continues beyond that date.292
327309 (o) The authority of the commission shall be limited to incapacity or discipline regarding293
328310 the conduct of a district attorney or solicitor-general as a holder of such office. Nothing294
329311 in this Code section shall be construed as diminishing the authority of the Supreme Court295
330312 or the State Bar of Georgia to regulate the practice of law in this state.296
331313 (p) In the event that a district attorney or solicitor-general is removed or involuntarily297
332314 retired pursuant to this Code section, such individual shall be disqualified from being298
333315 appointed or elected to the office of district attorney of any judicial circuit or to the office299
334316 of solicitor-general of any county of this state for a period of ten years from the date of300
335317 such removal or involuntary retirement."301
336318 SECTION 3.302
337319 Said chapter is further amended by revising paragraph (1) of subsection (b) of Code Section303
338320 15-18-66, relating to duties and authority regarding solicitors-general, as follows:304
339321 "(1) To review every individual case for which probable cause for prosecution exists, and305
340322 make a prosecutorial decision available under the law based on the facts and306
341323 circumstances of each individual case under oath of duty as provided in Code Section307
342324 15-18-2, and, if necessary, investigate all criminal cases which may be prosecuted in state308
343-court;"309 23 SB 92/AP
344-S. B. 92
325+court;"309 LC 47 2519S
345326 - 13 -
346-SECTION 4.
347-310
327+SECTION 4.310
348328 Chapter 4 of Title 21 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated, relating to recall of public311
349329 officers, is amended by revising paragraph (7) of Code Section 21-4-3, relating to definitions,312
350330 as follows:313
351331 "(7) 'Grounds for recall' means:314
352332 (A) That the official has, while holding public office, conducted himself or herself in315
353333 a manner which relates to and adversely affects the administration of his or her office316
354334 and adversely affects the rights and interests of the public; and317
355335 (B) That the official:318
356336 (i) Has committed an act or acts of malfeasance while in office;319
357337 (ii) Has violated his or her oath of office;320
358338 (iii) Has committed an act of misconduct in office;321
359339 (iv) Is guilty of a failure to perform duties prescribed by law; or322
360340 (v) Has willfully misused, converted, or misappropriated, without authority, public323
361341 property or public funds entrusted to or associated with the elective office to which324
362342 the official has been elected or appointed.325
363343 Discretionary performance of a lawful act or a prescribed duty shall not constitute a326
364-ground for recall of an elected public official; provided, however, that a judicial circuit
365-327
344+ground for recall of an elected public official; provided, however, that a judicial circuit327
366345 district attorney's failure to perform the duties provided for in Code Section 15-18-6 or328
367346 a state court solicitor-general's failure to perform the duties provided for in Code Section329
368347 15-18-66 shall constitute grounds for a recall of such elected official."330
369348 SECTION 5.331
370349 This Act shall become effective upon its approval by the Governor or upon its becoming law332
371-without such approval.333 23 SB 92/AP
372-S. B. 92
350+without such approval.333 LC 47 2519S
373351 - 14 -
374-SECTION 6.
375-334
352+SECTION 6.334
376353 All laws and parts of laws in conflict with this Act are repealed.335