Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii House Bill HR74

Introduced
3/9/23  
Refer
3/15/23  
Report Pass
3/30/23  

Caption

Requesting The Formation Of A Working Group To Create A Plan Regarding The Return Of Cultural Artifacts.

Impact

If enacted, HR74 would facilitate discussions and actions surrounding the repatriation of cultural artifacts. The proposed working group would be co-chaired by representatives from the Office of Hawaiian Affairs and the State Historic Preservation Division, engaging museum representatives and cultural experts in the planning process. This collaborative approach is anticipated to foster an environment that values both the retrieval of Hawaii's cultural artifacts and the respectful return of artifacts belonging to other cultures.

Summary

House Resolution 74 (HR74) seeks to establish a Cultural Artifact Return Working Group to form a comprehensive plan aimed at the return of cultural artifacts to Hawaii. The resolution recognizes the importance of cultural artifacts to the history of the Hawaiian people, highlighting that many such items have been removed from the state, and equally, that artifacts within Hawaii may belong to other cultures. The initiative aims to address these concerns while promoting respect and understanding among diverse cultures.

Sentiment

The general sentiment towards HR74 appears supportive, particularly among those who emphasize the importance of cultural identity and heritage preservation. Advocates for the bill argue that it honors the historical significance of cultural artifacts and the necessity of restoring them to their rightful places. However, discussions may arise over the logistics of implementation and the need for careful negotiation when dealing with artifacts that involve multiple stakeholders from different cultural backgrounds.

Contention

Notably, while HR74 promotes a collaborative effort to return cultural artifacts, it also raises potential points of contention regarding ownership debates and the complexities of cross-border cultural relations. The resolution’s success will depend on forming a balanced group that can navigate potential tensions between different cultural claims and foster a broader dialogue about the recognition and respect of cultural heritage.

Companion Bills

HI HCR73

Same As Requesting The Formation Of A Working Group To Create A Plan Regarding The Return Of Cultural Artifacts.

Similar Bills

CA AB1815

Cultural heritage destruction: California universities and museums.

TX SB1516

Relating to the collection of artifacts from public waterways.

TX SB1829

Relating to the collection of artifacts from public waterways.

CA AB1137

Cultural heritage destruction: California universities and museums.

HI HCR73

Requesting The Formation Of A Working Group To Create A Plan Regarding The Return Of Cultural Artifacts.

HI HB738

Relating To Historic Preservation.

HI SB1263

Relating To Historic Preservation.

CA AB1544

Cultural heritage: protection of items and places of cultural and historical interest.