Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SB2

Introduced
1/18/23  

Caption

Proposing An Amendment To The Hawaii Constitution To Require The Election Of Members Of The Board Of Education.

Impact

Should this amendment be enacted, it would fundamentally change the structure of the Board of Education by transitioning it from an appointed to an elected board. This is expected to enhance democratic governance within the education system, allowing for greater input from the electorate regarding educational policies and initiatives. It also opens the possibility for increased accountability for board members, as they would be directly answerable to voters. The transition from an appointed to an elected board is designed to align educational governance with broader democratic practices in the state.

Summary

SB2 proposes an amendment to the Hawaii Constitution to require that the members of the Board of Education be elected by the qualified voters of the state rather than appointed by the governor. This change aims to increase public participation and accountability in the governance of education in Hawaii. The bill delineates two at-large school board districts, one representing Oahu and other islands, and the other representing the islands of Hawaii, Maui, Lanai, Molokai, Kahoolawe, Kauai, and Niihau. Additionally, the amendment makes provisions for having at least one member residing in each departmental school district within these at-large districts.

Contention

One notable point of contention surrounding SB2 may stem from concerns over the effectiveness and clarity of elected boards versus appointed boards. Advocates for the elected board highlight the need for accountability and responsiveness to community needs, while opponents may argue that appointing members allows for more qualified and specialized individuals to oversee education policy. There may also be discussion about the potential impact on the quality of educational governance, particularly concerning the expertise and commitment of elected versus appointed members.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

HI SB2

Proposing An Amendment To The Hawaii Constitution To Require The Election Of Members Of The Board Of Education.

HI HB630

Proposing Amendments To The Constitution Of The State Of Hawaii Relating To Public Education.

HI SB32

Proposing An Amendment To The Hawaii State Constitution To Require The Reapportionment Commission To Establish A Reapportionment Plan To Draw District Lines For The Members Of The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs Board Of Trustees.

HI HB1714

Proposing Amendments To Article X, Section 2 And Article Xviii, Section 12, Of The Constitution Of The State Of Hawaii To Establish Local Elected School Boards.

HI SB927

Proposing Amendments To Article Iv, Sections 4 And 6, Of The Hawaii State Constitution Regarding Reapportionment.

HI HB1168

Proposing Amendments To Article Iv, Sections 4 And 6, Of The Hawaii State Constitution Regarding Reapportionment.

HI HB1119

Proposing Amendments To The Constitution Of The State Of Hawaii Relating To Elected County School Boards.

HI SB52

Relating To The Election Of Members To The Board Of Trustees Of The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.

HI HB66

Relating To The Election Of Members To The Board Of Trustees Of The Office Of Hawaiian Affairs.

HI HB1399

Proposing Amendments To The Hawaii Constitution Relating To The Attorney General.

Similar Bills

NJ SCR26

Proposes constitutional amendment to require that legislative districts be established in manner that promotes competition between political parties.

NJ SCR37

Proposes constitutional amendment to require that legislative districts be established in manner that promotes competition between political parties.

CA SB743

Education finance: Education Equalization Act: Equalization Reserve Account.

NH SB253

Apportioning state senate districts.

NH SB240

Apportioning state senate districts.

CA SB154

Education finance: Proposition 98: suspension.

CA AB1253

Education finance: school bonds: citizens’ oversight committees.

CA AB154

Education finance: Proposition 98: suspension.