Hawaii 2023 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SCR226 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
1-THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 226 THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023 S.D. 1 STATE OF HAWAII SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION URGING THE UNITED STATES INDO-PACIFIC COMMAND TO MORE PROACTIVELY COMBAT VIOLENCE AGAINST CIVILIAN WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN HAWAII BY MAKING A ZERO-TOLERANCE COMMITMENT, SHARING GENDER‑BASED VIOLENCE PREVALENCE DATA WITH THE STATE GOVERNMENT, AND LAUNCHING AN ANTI-COMMERCIAL SEXUAL EXPLOITATION PROGRAM ACROSS ALL HAWAII MILITARY INSTALLATIONS.
1+THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 226 THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023 STATE OF HAWAII SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION URGING THE UNITED STATES INDO-PACIFIC COMMAND TO more proactively combat VIOLENCE AGAINST CIVILIAN WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN HAWAII BY making a zero-tolerance commitment, SHARING GENDER‑BASED VIOLENCE PREVALENCE DATA WITH THE STATE GOVERNMENT, and LAUNCHING AN ANTI-COMMERCIAL SEXUAL EXPLOITATION program ACROSS ALL HAWAII MILITARY INSTALLATIONS.
22
33 THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 226
4-THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023 S.D. 1
4+THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023
55 STATE OF HAWAII
66
77 THE SENATE
88
99 S.C.R. NO.
1010
1111 226
1212
1313 THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023
1414
15-S.D. 1
15+
1616
1717 STATE OF HAWAII
1818
1919
2020
2121
2222
2323
2424
2525
2626
2727
2828
2929 SENATE CONCURRENT
3030
3131 RESOLUTION
3232
3333
3434
3535
3636
3737 URGING THE UNITED STATES INDO-PACIFIC COMMAND TO more proactively combat VIOLENCE AGAINST CIVILIAN WOMEN AND CHILDREN IN HAWAII BY making a zero-tolerance commitment, SHARING GENDER‑BASED VIOLENCE PREVALENCE DATA WITH THE STATE GOVERNMENT, and LAUNCHING AN ANTI-COMMERCIAL SEXUAL EXPLOITATION program ACROSS ALL HAWAII MILITARY INSTALLATIONS.
3838
3939
4040
4141
4242
43- WHEREAS, the negative impacts of a large military presence extend beyond carbon footprint, environmental degradation, water contamination, and housing competition to also include gender‑based violence against women and children at scale; and WHEREAS, Hawaii is the most densely militarized state in the United States; and WHEREAS, according to The New Republic, the United States military is the world's largest employer and second largest employer in Hawaii, and it is an industry with unique aggravating factors for sex trafficking; and WHEREAS, there are approximately forty thousand active duty military agents stationed in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, more than two-thirds of military personnel are male, and the majority of military service members are white; and WHEREAS, across all branches of the United States military, men are more likely than women to be officers; and WHEREAS, over eighty percent of sex traffickers, sex buyers, fatal domestic violence perpetrators, rapists, child pornography consumers, and online child sexual predators are men; and WHEREAS, the United States Department of Defense Sexual Assault Prevention and Response Office's Annual Report on Sexual Assault in the Military Fiscal Year 2021, published in 2022, concluded that there has been an overall growth in an unhealthy military environment on sexual violence and found an increase in sexual assault perpetrated by military members against civilians and military members; and WHEREAS, the sex trade is a historical creature that began with the onset of Western colonization in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, according to Holoi ā nalo Wāhine Ōiwi: Missing and Murdered Native Hawaiian Women and Girls Task Force Report (Part 1), the United States military played a direct role in creating a sex trade, including prostitution and sex trafficking as systemic occurrences in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, according to a historic placard on Hotel Street in Honolulu, "the United States military and Honolulu Police Department previously ran the brothel industry" in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, according to the Organization for Security and Co‑operation in Europe Office of the Special Representative and Coordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings, the United States military is consistently a substantial contributor to fueling sex trafficking and sexual exploitation through the practice of buying sex; and WHEREAS, according to child pornography watchdog Internet Crimes Against Children Child Online Protective Services, the United States Department of Defense's network consistently ranks in the top tier of internet service providers for trafficking child pornography and is ranked nineteenth of nearly three thousand networks surveyed in 2018; and WHEREAS, the military impact on women and children in Hawaii is an open secret that has not been directly addressed or prioritized by state government beyond the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women and Office of Hawaiian Affairs; and WHEREAS, the United States Indo-Pacific Command submits an annual report on human trafficking to the Combatting Trafficking in Persons Management Office of the United States Department of Defense, but these reports are not public or available to state government, local victim assistance service providers, Native Hawaiian organizations, or gender equality advocates; and WHEREAS, twenty-five percent of child sexual predators arrested for arranging sex with a thirteen-year old online on Oahu in 2019 and thirty percent of arrests in January 2023 through Operation Keiki Shield were active duty military; and WHEREAS, none of the thirty-two active duty military personnel arrested for soliciting sex from a twelve- to fifteen- year-old child online through Operation Keiki Shield since 2019 have been women; and WHEREAS, sex trafficking is a form of recruitment of vulnerable people into the sex trade that is a causal factor for missing and murdered Native Hawaiian women and girls; and WHEREAS, the United States Army Schofield Barracks is the only domestic military base in the United States that is conducting proactive investigations into sex trafficking, but these efforts are embryonic; and WHEREAS, seventy-three percent of child sex trafficking victims in Hawaii were sexually abused as minors; and WHEREAS, the Domestic Violence Action Center identified two hundred military batterers in fiscal year 2022 and served one hundred nine military victims of domestic violence without any compensation for these services from the United States Department of Defense; and WHEREAS, in January 2023, United States Senator Mazie Hirono convened a public roundtable to bring attention to the crisis of missing and murdered Native Hawaiian women and girls and expressed concern about the inadequate military response; and WHEREAS, Hale Kipa leadership testified at a January 2023 roundtable that United States military personnel and tourists constitute the majority of perpetrators commercially sexually exploiting at-risk youth served by the agency; and WHEREAS, the majority of sex trafficking victims in Hawaii are Native Hawaiian women and girls; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women has been leading state government efforts to expose and address the connection between the military and sex trafficking since 2018; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women, Native Hawaiian organizations, and community advocates do not have ready access to data critical to implementing sex trafficking prevention; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women can assist in developing an anti-trafficking response that is gender transformative and victim-centered; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-second Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2023, the House of Representatives concurring, that the United States Indo-Pacific Command is urged to: (1) Issue a public statement committing to zero tolerance for sex buying, sex trafficking, child sexual abuse material consumption, and child sexual exploitation by United States Indo-Pacific Command personnel; (2) Share gender-based violence prevalence data with the Missing and Murdered Native Hawaiian Women and Girls Taskforce; and (3) Implement an anti-commercial sexual exploitation program aimed at informing military personnel, including through the placement of posters and signage in visible areas, at all Hawaii military installations of the consequences for sex buying and holding sex buyers accountable; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the members of Hawaii's Congressional delegation are requested to submit an amendment to the next National Defense Authorization Act requiring the Department of Defense to submit an annual report on efforts to combat commercial sexual exploitation, including sex buying, and non-commercial sexual exploitation, including child sexual abuse, by service members to the United States House of Representatives Committee on Armed Services and United States Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Commander of the United States Indo-Pacific Command, each member of Hawaii's congressional delegation, the Chairperson of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs Board of Trustees, Executive Director of the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women, and Executive Director of Kamāwaelualani. Report Title: United States Indo-Pacific Command; Anti-commercial Sexual Exploitation Campaign
43+
44+
45+ WHEREAS, the negative impacts of a large military presence extend beyond carbon footprint, environmental degradation, water contamination, and housing competition to also include gender‑based violence against women and children at scale; and WHEREAS, Hawaii is the most densely militarized state in the United States; and WHEREAS, according to The New Republic, the United States military is the world's largest employer and second largest employer in Hawaii, and it is an industry with unique aggravating factors for sex trafficking; and WHEREAS, there are approximately 40,000 active duty military agents stationed in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, more than two-thirds of military personnel are male, and the majority of military service members are white; and WHEREAS, across all branches of the United States military, men are more likely than women to be officers; and WHEREAS, over eighty percent of sex traffickers, sex buyers, fatal domestic violence perpetrators, rapists, child pornography consumers, and online child sexual predators are men; and WHEREAS, the United States Department of Defense Sexual Assault Prevention and Response Office's Annual Report on Sexual Assault in the Military Fiscal Year 2021, published in 2022, concluded that there has been an overall growth in an unhealthy military environment on sexual violence and found an increase in sexual assault perpetrated by military members against civilians and military members; and WHEREAS, the sex trade is a historical creature that began with the onset of Western colonization in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, according to Holoi ā nalo Wāhine Ōiwi: Missing and Murdered Native Hawaiian Women and Girls Task Force Report (Part 1), the United States military played a direct role in creating a sex trade, including prostitution and sex trafficking as systemic occurrences in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, according to a historic placard on Hotel Street in Honolulu, "the United States military and Honolulu Police Department previously ran the brothel industry" in Hawaii; and WHEREAS, according to the Organization for Security and Co‑operation in Europe Office of the Special Representative and Coordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings, the United States military is consistently a substantial contributor to fueling sex trafficking and sexual exploitation through the practice of buying sex; and WHEREAS, according to child pornography watchdog Internet Crimes Against Children Child Online Protective Services, the United States Department of Defense's network consistently ranks in the top tier of internet service providers for trafficking child pornography and is ranked 19th of nearly 3,000 networks surveyed in 2018; and WHEREAS, the military impact on women and children in Hawaii is an open secret that has not been directly addressed or prioritized by state government beyond the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women and Office of Hawaiian Affairs; and WHEREAS, the United States Indo-Pacific Command submits an annual report on human trafficking to the Combatting Trafficking in Persons Management Office of the United States Department of Defense, but these reports are not public or available to state government, local victim assistance service providers, Native Hawaiian organizations, or gender equality advocates; and WHEREAS, twenty-five percent of child sexual predators arrested for arranging sex with a thirteen-year old online on Oahu in 2019 and thirty percent of arrests in January 2023 through Operation Keiki Shield were active duty military; and WHEREAS, none of the thirty-two active duty military personnel arrested for soliciting sex from a twelve-to fifteen- year-old child online through Operation Keiki Shield since 2019 have been women; and WHEREAS, sex trafficking is a form of recruitment of vulnerable people into the sex trade that is a causal factor for missing and murdered Native Hawaiian women and girls; and WHEREAS, the United States Army Schofield Barracks is the only domestic military base in the United States that is conducting proactive investigations into sex trafficking, but these efforts are embryonic; and WHEREAS, seventy-three percent of child sex trafficking victims in Hawaii were sexually abused as minors; and WHEREAS, the Domestic Violence Action Center identified 200 military batterers in fiscal year 2022 and served 109 military victims of domestic violence without any compensation for these services from the United States Department of Defense; and WHEREAS, in January 2023, United States Senator Mazie Hirono convened a public roundtable to bring attention to the crisis of missing and murdered Native Hawaiian women and girls and expressed concern about the inadequate military response; and WHEREAS, Hale Kipa leadership testified at a January 2023 roundtable that United States military personnel and tourists are the majority of perpetrators commercially sexually exploiting at-risk youth served by the agency; and WHEREAS, the majority of sex trafficking victims in Hawaii are Native Hawaiian women and girls; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women has been leading state government efforts to expose and address the connection between the military and sex trafficking since 2018; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women, Native Hawaiian organizations, and community advocates do not have ready access to data critical to implementing sex trafficking prevention; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women can assist in developing an anti-trafficking response that is gender transformative and victim-centered; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-second Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2023, the House of Representatives concurring, that the United States Indo-Pacific Command is urged to: (1) Issue a public statement committing to zero tolerance for sex buying, sex trafficking, child sexual abuse material consumption, and child sexual exploitation by United States Indo-Pacific Command personnel; (2) Share gender-based violence prevalence data with the Missing and Murdered Native Hawaiian Women and Girls Taskforce; and (3) Implement an anti-commercial sexual exploitation program aimed at informing military personnel, including through the placement of posters and signage in visible areas, at all Hawaii military installations of the consequences for sex buying and holding sex buyers accountable; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the members of Hawaii's Congressional delegation are requested to submit an amendment to the next National Defense Authorization Act requiring the Department of Defense to submit an annual report on efforts to combat commercial sexual exploitation, including sex buying, and non-commercial sexual exploitation, including child sexual abuse, by service members to the United States House of Representatives Committee on Armed Services and United States Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Commander of the United States Indo-Pacific Command, each member of Hawaii's Congressional delegation, the Chairperson of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs Board of Trustees, Executive Director of the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women, and Executive Director of Kamāwaelualani. OFFERED BY: _____________________________ Report Title: United States Indo-Pacific Command; Anti-commercial Sexual Exploitation Campaign
4446
4547 WHEREAS, the negative impacts of a large military presence extend beyond carbon footprint, environmental degradation, water contamination, and housing competition to also include gender‑based violence against women and children at scale; and
4648
4749
4850
4951 WHEREAS, Hawaii is the most densely militarized state in the United States; and
5052
5153
5254
5355 WHEREAS, according to The New Republic, the United States military is the world's largest employer and second largest employer in Hawaii, and it is an industry with unique aggravating factors for sex trafficking; and
5456
5557
5658
57- WHEREAS, there are approximately forty thousand active duty military agents stationed in Hawaii; and
59+ WHEREAS, there are approximately 40,000 active duty military agents stationed in Hawaii; and
5860
5961
6062
6163 WHEREAS, more than two-thirds of military personnel are male, and the majority of military service members are white; and
6264
6365
6466
6567 WHEREAS, across all branches of the United States military, men are more likely than women to be officers; and
6668
6769
6870
6971 WHEREAS, over eighty percent of sex traffickers, sex buyers, fatal domestic violence perpetrators, rapists, child pornography consumers, and online child sexual predators are men; and
7072
7173
7274
7375 WHEREAS, the United States Department of Defense Sexual Assault Prevention and Response Office's Annual Report on Sexual Assault in the Military Fiscal Year 2021, published in 2022, concluded that there has been an overall growth in an unhealthy military environment on sexual violence and found an increase in sexual assault perpetrated by military members against civilians and military members; and
7476
7577
7678
7779 WHEREAS, the sex trade is a historical creature that began with the onset of Western colonization in Hawaii; and
7880
7981
8082
8183 WHEREAS, according to Holoi ā nalo Wāhine Ōiwi: Missing and Murdered Native Hawaiian Women and Girls Task Force Report (Part 1), the United States military played a direct role in creating a sex trade, including prostitution and sex trafficking as systemic occurrences in Hawaii; and
8284
8385
8486
8587 WHEREAS, according to a historic placard on Hotel Street in Honolulu, "the United States military and Honolulu Police Department previously ran the brothel industry" in Hawaii; and
8688
8789
8890
8991 WHEREAS, according to the Organization for Security and Co‑operation in Europe Office of the Special Representative and Coordinator for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings, the United States military is consistently a substantial contributor to fueling sex trafficking and sexual exploitation through the practice of buying sex; and
9092
9193
9294
93- WHEREAS, according to child pornography watchdog Internet Crimes Against Children Child Online Protective Services, the United States Department of Defense's network consistently ranks in the top tier of internet service providers for trafficking child pornography and is ranked nineteenth of nearly three thousand networks surveyed in 2018; and
95+ WHEREAS, according to child pornography watchdog Internet Crimes Against Children Child Online Protective Services, the United States Department of Defense's network consistently ranks in the top tier of internet service providers for trafficking child pornography and is ranked 19th of nearly 3,000 networks surveyed in 2018; and
9496
9597
9698
9799 WHEREAS, the military impact on women and children in Hawaii is an open secret that has not been directly addressed or prioritized by state government beyond the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women and Office of Hawaiian Affairs; and
98100
99101
100102
101103 WHEREAS, the United States Indo-Pacific Command submits an annual report on human trafficking to the Combatting Trafficking in Persons Management Office of the United States Department of Defense, but these reports are not public or available to state government, local victim assistance service providers, Native Hawaiian organizations, or gender equality advocates; and
102104
103105
104106
105107 WHEREAS, twenty-five percent of child sexual predators arrested for arranging sex with a thirteen-year old online on Oahu in 2019 and thirty percent of arrests in January 2023 through Operation Keiki Shield were active duty military; and
106108
107109
108110
109111 WHEREAS, none of the thirty-two active duty military personnel arrested for soliciting sex from a twelve-to fifteen- year-old child online through Operation Keiki Shield since 2019 have been women; and
110112
111113
112114
113115 WHEREAS, sex trafficking is a form of recruitment of vulnerable people into the sex trade that is a causal factor for missing and murdered Native Hawaiian women and girls; and
114116
115117
116118
117119 WHEREAS, the United States Army Schofield Barracks is the only domestic military base in the United States that is conducting proactive investigations into sex trafficking, but these efforts are embryonic; and
118120
119121
120122
121123 WHEREAS, seventy-three percent of child sex trafficking victims in Hawaii were sexually abused as minors; and
122124
123125
124126
125- WHEREAS, the Domestic Violence Action Center identified two hundred military batterers in fiscal year 2022 and served one hundred nine military victims of domestic violence without any compensation for these services from the United States Department of Defense; and
127+ WHEREAS, the Domestic Violence Action Center identified 200 military batterers in fiscal year 2022 and served 109 military victims of domestic violence without any compensation for these services from the United States Department of Defense; and
126128
127129
128130
129131 WHEREAS, in January 2023, United States Senator Mazie Hirono convened a public roundtable to bring attention to the crisis of missing and murdered Native Hawaiian women and girls and expressed concern about the inadequate military response; and
130132
131133
132134
133- WHEREAS, Hale Kipa leadership testified at a January 2023 roundtable that United States military personnel and tourists constitute the majority of perpetrators commercially sexually exploiting at-risk youth served by the agency; and
135+ WHEREAS, Hale Kipa leadership testified at a January 2023 roundtable that United States military personnel and tourists are the majority of perpetrators commercially sexually exploiting at-risk youth served by the agency; and
134136
135137
136138
137139 WHEREAS, the majority of sex trafficking victims in Hawaii are Native Hawaiian women and girls; and
138140
139141
140142
141143 WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women has been leading state government efforts to expose and address the connection between the military and sex trafficking since 2018; and
142144
143145
144146
145147 WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women, Native Hawaiian organizations, and community advocates do not have ready access to data critical to implementing sex trafficking prevention; and
146148
147149
148150
149151 WHEREAS, the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women can assist in developing an anti-trafficking response that is gender transformative and victim-centered; now, therefore,
150152
151153
152154
153155 BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-second Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2023, the House of Representatives concurring, that the United States Indo-Pacific Command is urged to:
154156
155157
156158
157159 (1) Issue a public statement committing to zero tolerance for sex buying, sex trafficking, child sexual abuse material consumption, and child sexual exploitation by United States Indo-Pacific Command personnel;
158160
159161
160162
161163 (2) Share gender-based violence prevalence data with the Missing and Murdered Native Hawaiian Women and Girls Taskforce; and
162164
163165
164166
165167 (3) Implement an anti-commercial sexual exploitation program aimed at informing military personnel, including through the placement of posters and signage in visible areas, at all Hawaii military installations of the consequences for sex buying and holding sex buyers accountable; and
166168
167169
168170
169171 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the members of Hawaii's Congressional delegation are requested to submit an amendment to the next National Defense Authorization Act requiring the Department of Defense to submit an annual report on efforts to combat commercial sexual exploitation, including sex buying, and non-commercial sexual exploitation, including child sexual abuse, by service members to the United States House of Representatives Committee on Armed Services and United States Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs; and
170172
171173
172174
173175 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Commander of the United States Indo-Pacific Command, each member of Hawaii's Congressional delegation, the Chairperson of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs Board of Trustees, Executive Director of the Hawaii State Commission on the Status of Women, and Executive Director of Kamāwaelualani.
174176
177+
178+
179+
180+
181+
182+
183+ OFFERED BY: _____________________________
184+
185+
186+
187+OFFERED BY:
188+
189+_____________________________
190+
191+
192+
193+
194+
175195 Report Title:
176196
177197 United States Indo-Pacific Command; Anti-commercial Sexual Exploitation Campaign