Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa House Bill HSB531

Introduced
1/9/24  
Introduced
1/9/24  

Caption

A bill for an act relating to confidential records including booking photographs.(See HF 2309.)

Impact

The implications of HSB531 on state law include the establishment of a clear framework for the management of booking photographs. By defining specific instances when such photographs can be released, the bill intends to balance public interest in security and transparency against individual privacy rights. This change strives to streamline processes within law enforcement and potentially enhance the efficiency of fugitive apprehensions and threat mitigations by facilitating the lawful release of photographs when deemed appropriate.

Summary

House Study Bill 531 pertains to the handling of booking photographs by law enforcement agencies. This legislative proposal aims to classify booking photographs as confidential records while also establishing specific conditions under which these photos can be released or disseminated. The bill outlines that booking photographs may be published if the individual depicted is a fugitive, if there's an imminent threat to public safety, if ordered by a judge, or if the individual has been convicted of a crime related to the arrest.

Contention

Notably, discussions surrounding HSB531 may arise concerning the balance between privacy rights and public safety. Proponents argue that the bill provides necessary tools for law enforcement to effectively address public safety issues, while critics may fear that even limited releases could compromise individual privacy or lead to unintended consequences. Therefore, establishing the boundaries for what constitutes a legitimate interest in releasing a booking photograph will likely be a point of contention during legislative debates.

Companion Bills

IA HF2309

Replaced by A bill for an act relating to confidential records including booking photographs.(Formerly HSB 531.)

Similar Bills

CA SB1407

Driver’s licenses: photographs.

CA SB238

Criminal procedure: arrests and evidence.

CA SB564

Depiction of individual using digital or electronic technology: sexually explicit material: cause of action.

GA HB10

Georgia Booking Photo Privacy Protection Act; enact

CA SB683

Privacy: use of a person’s name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness: injunctive relief.

GA HB882

Law enforcement officers and agencies; prohibit posting of booking photograph until individual is convicted

LA SB24

Removes certain limitations on the release and dissemination of mug shots. (8/1/24)

CA AB2045

Driver’s licenses: photographs.