Iowa House Bill HSB99

Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/26/23
• Refer: 1/26/23

Caption

A bill for an act relating to homeowner's and renter's insurance policies and certain dog breeds, and including effective date and applicability provisions.

Impact

If enacted, HSB99 will impact the conduct of insurance companies in Iowa, mandating that they cannot discriminate against dog owners based on breed alone. Insurers may not exclude or limit coverage based on a policyholder's dog breed unless the breed is classified as dangerous or high risk per city ordinances. This change seeks to enhance protections for pet owners, promoting a more inclusive approach to insurance policies while ensuring that coverage decisions are made based on actual risks rather than breed stereotypes.

Summary

House Study Bill 99, also known as the Dog Breed Insurance Underwriting Protection Act, addresses issues regarding homeowners and renters insurance policies as they pertain to specific dog breeds classified as dangerous or high risk. The bill prohibits insurers from refusing to issue or renew policies, increasing premiums, or canceling policies solely based on a policyholder's custody of a dog of a particular breed. This legislation aims to protect dog owners from discrimination in insurance practices, creating more equitable treatment for individuals who own dogs identified by certain breeds.

Contention

There may be notable points of contention surrounding HSB99, particularly regarding the definitions of 'dangerous' or 'high risk' breeds, which could lead to disputes over subjective interpretations. Insurers and consumer advocates may debate the balance between ensuring fair treatment for dog owners and managing liability concerns associated with certain breeds. Some stakeholders might argue that the bill restricts insurers' ability to operate based on their risk assessments, potentially leading to higher overall costs for all policyholders.