Louisiana 2014 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SB1

Introduced
3/10/14  
Introduced
3/10/14  
Refer
3/10/14  
Refer
3/10/14  
Report Pass
4/30/14  
Report Pass
4/30/14  
Engrossed
5/6/14  
Engrossed
5/6/14  
Refer
5/7/14  

Caption

Enacts the "Legislative Scholarship Fairness Act" (gov sig)

Impact

The enactment of this bill will modify existing state laws governing the Tulane Legislative Scholarship Program. Notably, it aims to ensure that scholarships are awarded based on merit and need rather than connections, as the nomination process is designed to be more transparent. The legislation will require that information about the scholarship, including recipients and nominations, is published on state and university websites. This change is intended to enhance public awareness and provide fair access to potential candidates in Louisiana.

Summary

Senate Bill No. 1, known as the Legislative Scholarship Fairness Act, aims to amend the Tulane Legislative Scholarship Program to improve transparency and fairness in the nomination process for scholarships. Under this bill, each state legislator retains the right to nominate one Louisiana resident for a full undergraduate tuition scholarship at Tulane University, provided the student meets the university's admission requirements. The bill also specifies conditions under which nominations can be made and restricts legislators from nominating individuals who are family members or other elected officials, thereby attempting to eliminate any potential conflicts of interest.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around SB1 has been cautiously positive among proponents who view it as a necessary reform that emphasizes fairness and accountability in the scholarship nomination process. However, some concerns have been raised regarding the potential impacts on community representation, especially if local students do not get adequate support in the nomination process. The sentiment reflects a balance between wanting to foster transparency while ensuring that local students still have access to these opportunities.

Contention

Despite the overall support, there are notable points of contention surrounding this legislative change. Critics worry that the new rules may limit the ability of legislators to effectively help deserving students from their districts, potentially leading to inequities in scholarship allocations. Additionally, some fear that imposing strict eligibility criteria may unintentionally exclude students who could benefit from these opportunities. The debate encapsulates a classic tension in policy-making between ensuring fairness and maintaining local representation.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA SB183

Provides relative to the Tulane legislative scholarships.

LA SB420

Eliminates the Tulane legislative scholarships. (See Act)

LA HB299

Relative to legislative scholarships, requires certain information on application forms, provides for certain forms and material to be public record, and provides for the custodian of such records

LA SB145

Provides relative to Tulane Legislative Scholarships. (8/1/17) (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

LA HB307

Concerning Tulane University scholarships for students nominated by legislators, provides relative to requirements, procedures, limitations, and publication of information

LA HB991

Provides relative to Tulane University scholarships granted to students pursuant to nominations by state legislators (OR SEE FISC NOTE GF RV)

LA SB31

Enacts the Board Scholarship Reporting Act relative to scholarships awarded by members of public postsecondary education management boards.

LA HB107

Prohibits legislators from accepting campaign contributions from persons they nominate for Tulane scholarships or members of their families

LA SB36

Provides relative to qualifications for Taylor Opportunity Program for Students scholarships. (gov sig) (Item #43)

LA SB460

Requires schools receiving certain state scholarship funds to maintain funds in a separate account or use certain accounting procedures established for the legislative auditor. (8/1/14)

Similar Bills

LA SB183

Provides relative to the Tulane legislative scholarships.

LA SB182

Provides relative to school choice. (gov sig) (OR INCREASE GF EX See Note)

LA SB655

Authorizes public or private entities to make certain donations to various educational institutions for recipients of TOPS Awards or GO Grants. (7/1/14) (EN DECREASE GF EX See Note)

LA HB307

Concerning Tulane University scholarships for students nominated by legislators, provides relative to requirements, procedures, limitations, and publication of information

LA SB20

Provides relative to hospital service districts and scholarships for certain healthcare professionals. (gov sig) (EN SEE FISC NOTE LF EX See Note)

LA SR107

Expresses the establishment of the Rose Landry Long Louisiana Senate Scholarship.

LA HB969

Authorizes a rebate for taxpayers who donate to certain school tuition organizations

LA SB697

Authorizes a rebate for taxpayers who donate to certain school tuition organizations. (8/1/12) (OR SEE FISC NOTE GF EX See Note)