Louisiana 2020 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SB489

Introduced
3/31/20  
Refer
5/4/20  
Report Pass
5/13/20  
Report Pass
5/13/20  
Engrossed
5/15/20  
Engrossed
5/15/20  

Caption

Provides relative to limitation of liability of governmental entities which require its employees to work during a declared state of emergency. (gov sig)

Impact

SB 489 impacts state laws by retroactively limiting the liability of governmental bodies from March 11, 2020, onwards, which aligns with the declaration of a statewide public health emergency. This retroactive application means that governmental entities, including various levels of state and local governments, have broad protection against lawsuits related to COVID-19, thereby altering the landscape of legal recourse available to affected individuals. Proponents of the bill argue that it is crucial for safeguarding public health workers and keeping essential government services functional during crises.

Summary

Senate Bill 489, introduced by Senator McMath, aims to provide a limitation of liability for governmental entities that require employees to work during declared states of emergency, specifically focusing on the COVID-19 health crisis. This legislation enacts R.S. 29:773, clarifying that such entities will not be held civilly liable for injuries or deaths resulting from COVID-19 exposure, provided they comply with relevant governmental health guidelines. Importantly, this protection is only negated in cases of gross negligence or willful misconduct, ensuring a degree of accountability.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 489 is generally supportive among lawmakers and public health advocates who view it as a necessary measure to protect government entities from excessive litigation during unprecedented times. However, some critics express concerns that the bill may undermine accountability, allowing governmental bodies to neglect safety measures due to the reduced risk of legal repercussions. This divergence in sentiment reflects a broader national dialogue on balancing public health needs with the rights of citizens to seek redress for negligence.

Contention

Noteworthy points of contention revolve around the potential implications of the bill's liability limitations. Opponents fear that by shielding government entities from liability, it may diminish the incentives for maintaining rigorous safety standards and responding adequately to health guidelines. The contested nature of these discussions suggests an ongoing tension between ensuring a responsive government during emergencies and protecting individual rights to seek justice for harm suffered during such times.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA SB445

Provides relative to limitation of civil liability for medical personnel and healthcare providers during public health emergency. (gov sig)

LA HB856

Provides relative to limitations of liability in response to the COVID-19 state of emergency

LA HB778

Provides for the limitation of liability during a declaration of a state of public health emergency

LA HB59

Provides relative to limitations of liability for public and private school districts and postsecondary institutions during a declared state of emergency or a public health emergency (Item #40)

LA SB435

Provides relative to certain immunity from civil liability during state of emergencies. (gov sig)

LA HB826

Provides relative to the limitations of liability due to the COVID-19 public health emergency

LA SB508

Limits liability for restaurants that provide food-to-go during the COVID-19 public health emergency. (gov sig)

LA HB58

Provides relative to limitations of liability due to the COVID-19 public health emergency (Item #40)

LA SB491

Limits liability of persons who provide relief or recovery equipment or services during a declared state emergency. (gov sig)

LA HB745

Provides for limited liability for medical services rendered during a state of emergency

Similar Bills

OK HB3720

Local government investments; Oklahoma Local Government Investments Act of 2024; effective date.

TX SB1048

Relating to the creation of public and private facilities and infrastructure.

CA AB839

Medi-Cal: targeted case management.

TX HB2432

Relating to the creation of public and private facilities and infrastructure.

WV SB255

Relating to state contracts with and investments in certain companies that boycott energy companies

TX HB390

Relating to the Internet broadcast or recording of certain open meetings.

TX SB341

Relating to the Internet broadcast or audio recording of certain open meetings.

TX HB327

Relating to the Internet broadcast or audio recording of certain open meetings.