Texas Senate Bill SB1169

Texas 2023 - 88th Regular

• Filed: 2/23/23

Caption

Relating to the carrying or possession of a handgun by certain retired judges and justices.

Impact

The enactment of SB1169 would modify existing firearms laws by creating a clearer framework that allows retired judges and justices to carry handguns without the legal restrictions applied to regular citizens. This change signifies a recognition of the unique status of these individuals, who may need to protect themselves from potential threats due to their former roles in the judiciary. The bill is expected to have implications on how local law enforcement and other agencies manage firearms regulations among retired judicial officers, potentially prompting discussions around the need for additional training or safety measures.

Summary

Senate Bill 1169, introduced by Senator Birdwell, addresses the regulations surrounding the carrying or possession of handguns by certain retired judges and justices in Texas. The bill amends Section 46.15(a) of the Penal Code to specify that retired judicial officers who are licensed to carry a handgun are exempt from certain prohibitions on carrying firearms. This legislation is specifically aimed at enhancing the rights of retired judges and justices, allowing them to carry firearms more freely under the law, which has historically been a matter of contention in the realm of public safety and law enforcement.

Sentiment

The overall sentiment surrounding SB1169 appears to be mixed. Supporters, including various law enforcement groups and legal advocates, argue that the bill is a necessary step in acknowledging the service of retired judges and justices and equipping them with the means to protect themselves. However, critics express concerns about the potential risks of increasing the number of firearms in public spaces and worry about the implications for public safety. The measure has touched on deep-seated beliefs about gun rights and the balance between self-defense and community protection.

Contention

Key points of contention related to SB1169 include the broader debate over gun control and the rights of individuals to carry firearms. Advocates claim that allowing retired judges and justices to carry handguns is justified given their previous roles and potential vulnerabilities. Conversely, opponents caution that such legislation could set a precedent for other specialized groups to seek similar exemptions, leading to a potential increase in gun proliferation in public spaces. This highlights the ongoing tension between individual rights and collective safety in the legislative context.

Texas Constitutional Statutes Affected

Penal Code

• Chapter 46. Weapons
  • Section: 15

Government Code

• Chapter 411. Department Of Public Safety Of The State Of Texas
  • Section: 201

• Chapter 76. Community Supervision And Corrections Departments
  • Section: New Section
  • Section: 0051

Code Of Criminal Procedure

• Chapter 2. General Duties Of Officers
  • Section: 122

Occupations Code

• Chapter 1701. Law Enforcement Officers
  • Section: 357