Michigan House Bill HB4155

Michigan 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/2/23
• Refer: 3/2/23

Caption

Natural resources: hunting; penalties for failure to report a deer harvest or taking of deer over feeding or baiting; modify. Amends sec. 40118 of 1994 PA 451 (MCL 324.40118).

Impact

The impact of HB4155 on state laws includes a change in how certain violations related to hunting are penalized, shifting them from criminal misdemeanors to civil infractions in some cases. This adjustment is expected to streamline the enforcement process and reduce the criminal burden on individuals who may inadvertently violate reporting requirements. By focusing on civil penalties rather than more severe criminal charges, the bill seeks to promote better compliance among hunters regarding harvest reporting and bait usage.

Summary

House Bill 4155 aims to amend the Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act by modifying penalties related to the reporting of deer harvests and the use of bait for hunting. Specifically, the bill establishes that violations of reporting regulations or the use of bait between specified deer hunts will result in civil infractions. This aims to enhance compliance and enforcement of rules governing deer hunting practices in Michigan. The objective is to better manage wildlife populations while ensuring hunters adhere to necessary reporting protocols.

Contention

Discussions surrounding HB4155 point to some contention regarding the effectiveness and fairness of imposing civil penalties for what may be perceived as minor infractions. Critics argue that reducing the severity of penalties might create leniency towards habitual offenders, potentially undermining conservation efforts and responsible hunting practices. Proponents, on the other hand, advocate that this approach will lead to increased compliance among hunters who might otherwise avoid reporting due to fear of criminal charges. The balance between strict enforcement and encouraging responsible hunting practices remains a focal point of debate.