Montana 2023 Regular Session

Montana Senate Bill SB544

Introduced
3/24/23  
Refer
3/27/23  
Engrossed
4/4/23  
Refer
4/5/23  
Enrolled
4/24/23  

Caption

Revise internet laws related to material harmful to minors

Impact

The implementation of SB544 is poised to significantly alter existing state laws surrounding internet usage and the responsibilities of content distributors. By enforcing age verification measures, the bill seeks to limit minors' exposure to potentially detrimental online materials while simultaneously placing the burden of compliance on commercial entities. This move is likely to prompt discussions about the effectiveness and privacy implications of age verification methods, affecting how businesses operate within the state's digital economy. Moreover, the establishment of liability for retaining minors' identifying information introduces a new layer of accountability in the digital sphere.

Summary

Senate Bill 544 aims to address the issue of material harmful to minors accessible via the internet by imposing strict regulations on commercial entities. The bill mandates that these entities must implement reasonable age verification procedures before allowing minors access to such material. A failure to comply can result in them being held liable for damages incurred by minors who access harmful content, thereby providing a civil remedy for affected individuals. This legislation reflects a growing concern about the impact of online material on the younger population as well as the necessity for more robust protections in a digital landscape saturated with virtually unrestricted access to information.

Sentiment

Discussions surrounding SB544 reveal a polarized sentiment among legislators and stakeholders. Supporters champion the bill as a necessary step to safeguard children against the dangers of unregulated online content, emphasizing the potential long-term benefits of protecting youth from exposure to harmful materials. However, critics voice concerns about the feasibility of enforcing such age verification methods and the implications for individual privacy rights. Additionally, there are fears that the liability imposed on businesses could inadvertently stifle innovation and limit access to information for users.

Contention

Key points of contention include the appropriate balance between protecting minors and preserving internet freedoms. Critics argue that such regulations could lead to overreach, potentially infringing on the rights of internet users and content providers. They also raise practical concerns about how age verification systems can be effectively implemented without compromising user privacy. Furthermore, there is apprehension regarding the liability provisions, as businesses may struggle to navigate an environment of heightened legal exposure, which could disproportionately impact smaller entities in the industry.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

MT HB3339

Protection of minors from harmful material on internet

MT HB4423

Protection of minors from harmful material on internet

MT SB1298

Internet; material harmful to minors.

MT SB1125

Internet; material harmful to minors

MT H0931

Online Access to Materials Harmful to Minors

MT HB3570

Relating to restricting access to sexual material harmful to minors on an Internet website.

MT HB3585

Relating to restricting access to sexual material harmful to minors on an Internet website.

MT SB2164

Relating to restricting access to sexual material harmful to minors on an Internet website.

MT SB2021

Relating to requirements for certain Internet websites containing sexual material harmful to minors; providing a civil penalty.

MT HB1091

Minors; hold entities that publish harmful material on the internet civilly liable if age vertification is not performed.

Similar Bills

CA SB822

Communications: broadband Internet access service.

HI SB1036

Relating To Consumer Protection.

NJ S113

Establishes "New Jersey Net Neutrality Act."

NJ S1993

Establishes "New Jersey Net Neutrality Act."

CA AB2095

Publication: newspapers of general circulation.

CA AB940

Quantum Innovation Zones.

CA AB63

State government.

CA SB1179

Affordable Internet and Net Equality Act of 2024.