North Dakota 2023-2024 Regular Session

North Dakota Senate Bill SB2302

Introduced
1/16/23  
Refer
1/16/23  
Report Pass
2/7/23  
Engrossed
2/9/23  
Refer
2/17/23  
Report Pass
3/3/23  
Enrolled
3/7/23  

Caption

Prohibiting discrimination in the organ transplant process.

Impact

If enacted, SB 2302 will amend the North Dakota Century Code by introducing a new section that addresses discrimination in organ transplantation. This modification aligns with broader national movements advocating for disability rights and non-discrimination in healthcare. The bill's intention is to foster a more inclusive environment for organ recipients, thereby ensuring that the organ transplant process does not perpetuate societal biases against individuals with disabilities. Furthermore, it reflects a commitment to healthcare equity, compelling healthcare providers to evaluate patients' candidacy for transplants based solely on medical criteria rather than biases associated with disabilities.

Summary

Senate Bill 2302 seeks to prohibit discrimination against individuals based on their mental or physical disabilities throughout the organ transplant process. This bill is aimed at ensuring that all recipients are treated fairly and equitably, and it asserts that no individual should face discrimination solely based on their disability unless it is demonstrably significant to the medical considerations of organ donation. By formalizing these protections, the bill aspires to enhance awareness and compliance in the medical community regarding the rights of disabled individuals in critical healthcare scenarios.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SB 2302 appears to be overwhelmingly positive, as evidenced by the unanimous support in both the Senate and House votes—46 yeas in the Senate and 85 in the House. Advocates for the bill argue that it is a necessary step towards protecting the rights of individuals with disabilities, therefore representing a progressive move towards establishing equality in medical treatments. The discussions around the bill have centered on the significance of removing barriers to care and ensuring that all patients are afforded equal consideration regardless of their health status.

Contention

While the voting history indicates strong legislative support, potential areas of contention may arise from interpreting what constitutes 'medical significance' in relation to disabilities. Critics may worry about how healthcare providers will apply these guidelines in practice, particularly if they are perceived to conflict with existing medical standards or if discrimination persists despite the new regulations. These discussions underscore the importance of continual education and training for medical professionals to ensure compliance and understanding of the implications of SB 2302.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

ND S644

No CV19 Discrimination/Organ Transplantation

ND HB1129

Prohibit forms of discrimination in access to organ transplantation.

ND HB2659

Organ transplants; disabilities; discrimination; prohibition

ND AB955

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

ND SB933

Prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.

ND HB3032

Prohibiting discrimination based on an individual’s mental or physical disability in access to organ transplantation

ND HB2752

Prohibiting discrimination in access to organ transplants based on physical or mental disability

ND HB119

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of certain disabilities.

ND HB4076

Relating to prohibiting organ transplant recipient discrimination on the basis of vaccination status.

ND HB1450

The definition of pregnancy in our discrimination laws.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.