New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A3920

Introduced
5/9/22  

Caption

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

Impact

The key impact of A3920 on state law is its shift towards enhancing parental authority over their children's participation in health-related surveys. This change aims to promote privacy and guarding against the unsolicited collection of sensitive health information from minors. By requiring affirmative consent, the bill aligns school protocol with growing trends toward parental control and data protection in educational settings, reflecting broader societal concerns about privacy and data security in regards to children.

Summary

Assembly Bill A3920 introduces amendments to current regulations governing student health surveys in New Jersey. This bill mandates that school districts must obtain written permission from a parent or legal guardian before administering any anonymous and voluntary health surveys that collect sensitive information regarding students. Previously, schools could conduct such surveys simply by providing prior written notification, which the new bill seeks to tighten by ensuring explicit consent is received from parents or guardians.

Conclusion

If passed, this bill will amend previous laws concerning the administration of health surveys, making it more challenging for schools to gather data that could inform health initiatives. Therefore, while intended to protect students' privacy, the legislation may also complicate efforts to combat issues such as substance abuse, sexual health, and nutrition among youths. Stakeholder viewpoints on this change will play a crucial role in how the implementation and consequences of this bill are perceived moving forward.

Contention

The main contention around A3920 likely arises from debates regarding parental rights versus institutional authority. Supporters of the bill argue that it empowers parents and fosters greater involvement in their children's education and health decisions. Conversely, some critics may view this as an obstacle to acquiring vital data necessary for public health initiatives and may express concerns that such requirements could hinder schools from effectively assessing student health and wellbeing, potentially impacting related services.

Companion Bills

NJ S2280

Same As Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

Previously Filed As

NJ S2280

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ S1352

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A1281

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ HB1998

Schools; requiring parent permission to administer certain curriculum and surveys to students; effective date; emergency.

NJ S1717

Allows parent or guardian to exclude student from administration of State assessment.

NJ HB1680

Students with disabilities; require school district to provide written notification to parents regarding any modification or access to benefits.

NJ SB413

Schools; creating the Oklahoma Sexual Education Reform and Parental Rights Protection Act; requiring written consent for a student to participate in certain instruction. Effective date. Emergency.

NJ HB1812

Schools; requiring parents to give permission for students to participate in sex education; repealer; effective date; emergency.

NJ HB1812

Schools; requiring parents to give permission for students to participate in sex education; repealer; effective date; emergency.

NJ SB1981

Schools; creating the Oklahoma Sexual Education Reform and Parental Rights Protection Act; requiring written consent for a student to participate in certain instruction. Effective date. Emergency.

Similar Bills

NJ S2280

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ S1352

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A1281

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A4042

"Children Innocence Protection Act."

NJ A2580

"Children Innocence Protection Act."

CA AB281

Comprehensive sexual health education and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) prevention education: outside consultants.

CA AB1120

Pupil health: mental health screenings.

SC H3478

Mental Health in Schools Act