New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Senate Bill S1352

Introduced
1/9/24  

Caption

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

Impact

The proposed changes are expected to impact how schools can gather information on student health behaviors. By requiring prior written permission, advocates of the bill argue that it enhances parental involvement in critical conversations around health and safety issues. This amendment might lead to a reduction in the number of students voluntarily participating in such surveys, potentially limiting the data available for public health initiatives and programs aimed at improving student welfare. However, the bill proponents believe that the benefits of obtaining explicit parental consent outweigh the drawbacks.

Summary

Senate Bill S1352 proposes a significant amendment to the existing student health survey regulations by mandating that school districts obtain written permission from a parent or legal guardian before administering certain health assessments to students. This legislation aims to empower parents and guardians by ensuring they have control over their children's participation in surveys that explore sensitive topics such as substance use, sexual behavior, and violence-related behaviors. Previously, notification was deemed sufficient for the administration of these surveys, but this bill seeks to sharpen the requirement to a more explicit consent model.

Contention

The bill's reception is likely varied among different stakeholders. Supporters, including certain legislators, assert that enhancing parental rights will safeguard students' privacy and ensure families are informed about potentially sensitive health-related topics. Conversely, critics may argue that stricter consent requirements could hinder schools' ability to collect important data that could benefit public health initiatives. This could lead to a mismatch between the data collected and the actual needs of the student population, making it challenging for policymakers to develop effective health strategies.

Companion Bills

NJ A1281

Same As Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ S2280

Carry Over Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A3920

Carry Over Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

Previously Filed As

NJ S2280

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A3920

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A1281

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ HB1998

Schools; requiring parent permission to administer certain curriculum and surveys to students; effective date; emergency.

NJ S1717

Allows parent or guardian to exclude student from administration of State assessment.

NJ HB1680

Students with disabilities; require school district to provide written notification to parents regarding any modification or access to benefits.

NJ HB1812

Schools; requiring parents to give permission for students to participate in sex education; repealer; effective date; emergency.

NJ SB413

Schools; creating the Oklahoma Sexual Education Reform and Parental Rights Protection Act; requiring written consent for a student to participate in certain instruction. Effective date. Emergency.

NJ HB1812

Schools; requiring parents to give permission for students to participate in sex education; repealer; effective date; emergency.

NJ SB1981

Schools; creating the Oklahoma Sexual Education Reform and Parental Rights Protection Act; requiring written consent for a student to participate in certain instruction. Effective date. Emergency.

Similar Bills

NJ S2280

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A1281

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A3920

Requires school districts to receive written permission from parent or legal guardian before administering certain student health surveys.

NJ A2580

"Children Innocence Protection Act."

NJ A4042

"Children Innocence Protection Act."

CA AB281

Comprehensive sexual health education and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) prevention education: outside consultants.

CA AB1120

Pupil health: mental health screenings.

SC H3478

Mental Health in Schools Act