34 | | - | and |
---|
35 | | - | |
---|
36 | | - | Howard of the Senate |
---|
37 | | - | |
---|
38 | | - | |
---|
39 | | - | |
---|
40 | | - | An Act relating to criminal procedure; specifying |
---|
41 | | - | requirements for issuing criminal subpoenas; |
---|
42 | | - | requiring witnesses to attend trials or hearings upon |
---|
43 | | - | service of *** period for submitting written |
---|
44 | | - | objections; providing procedures for serving written |
---|
45 | | - | objections; allowing *** provision; providing for |
---|
46 | | - | codification; and providing an effective date . |
---|
47 | | - | |
---|
48 | | - | |
---|
49 | | - | |
---|
50 | | - | AMENDMENT NO. 1. Page 5, line 14, strike after the word “to” and |
---|
51 | | - | before the letter “C.”, the words “appear before”, |
---|
52 | | - | and insert the words “ (appear before) or (produce |
---|
53 | | - | for inspection to)” |
---|
54 | | - | |
---|
55 | | - | AMENDMENT NO. 2. Page 7, line 1, insert after the word “ deposition” |
---|
56 | | - | and before the first c omma “,”, the words |
---|
57 | | - | “pursuant to Section 761 et seq. of this title ” |
---|
58 | | - | |
---|
59 | | - | |
---|
60 | | - | ENGR. S. A. TO ENGR. H. B. NO. 3777 Page 2 1 |
---|
61 | | - | 2 |
---|
62 | | - | 3 |
---|
63 | | - | 4 |
---|
64 | | - | 5 |
---|
65 | | - | 6 |
---|
66 | | - | 7 |
---|
67 | | - | 8 |
---|
68 | | - | 9 |
---|
69 | | - | 10 |
---|
70 | | - | 11 |
---|
71 | | - | 12 |
---|
72 | | - | 13 |
---|
73 | | - | 14 |
---|
74 | | - | 15 |
---|
75 | | - | 16 |
---|
76 | | - | 17 |
---|
77 | | - | 18 |
---|
78 | | - | 19 |
---|
79 | | - | 20 |
---|
80 | | - | 21 |
---|
81 | | - | 22 |
---|
82 | | - | 23 |
---|
83 | | - | 24 |
---|
84 | | - | |
---|
85 | | - | Passed the Senate the 22nd day of April, 2024. |
---|
86 | | - | |
---|
87 | | - | |
---|
88 | | - | |
---|
89 | | - | Presiding Officer of the Senate |
---|
90 | | - | |
---|
91 | | - | |
---|
92 | | - | Passed the House of Representatives the ____ day of __________, |
---|
93 | | - | 2024. |
---|
94 | | - | |
---|
95 | | - | |
---|
96 | | - | |
---|
97 | | - | Presiding Officer of the H ouse |
---|
98 | | - | of Representatives |
---|
99 | | - | |
---|
100 | | - | ENGR. H. B. NO. 3777 Page 1 1 |
---|
101 | | - | 2 |
---|
102 | | - | 3 |
---|
103 | | - | 4 |
---|
104 | | - | 5 |
---|
105 | | - | 6 |
---|
106 | | - | 7 |
---|
107 | | - | 8 |
---|
108 | | - | 9 |
---|
109 | | - | 10 |
---|
110 | | - | 11 |
---|
111 | | - | 12 |
---|
112 | | - | 13 |
---|
113 | | - | 14 |
---|
114 | | - | 15 |
---|
115 | | - | 16 |
---|
116 | | - | 17 |
---|
117 | | - | 18 |
---|
118 | | - | 19 |
---|
119 | | - | 20 |
---|
120 | | - | 21 |
---|
121 | | - | 22 |
---|
122 | | - | 23 |
---|
123 | | - | 24 |
---|
124 | 32 | | |
---|
125 | 33 | | ENGROSSED HOUSE |
---|
126 | 34 | | BILL NO. 3777 By: Duel, Davis, and Lowe |
---|
127 | 35 | | (Jason) of the House |
---|
128 | 36 | | |
---|
129 | 37 | | and |
---|
130 | 38 | | |
---|
131 | 39 | | Howard of the Senate |
---|
132 | 40 | | |
---|
133 | 41 | | |
---|
134 | 42 | | |
---|
135 | 43 | | |
---|
136 | 44 | | |
---|
137 | 45 | | An Act relating to criminal procedure; specifying |
---|
138 | 46 | | requirements for issuing criminal subpoenas; |
---|
139 | 47 | | requiring witnesses to attend trials or hearings upon |
---|
140 | 48 | | service of subpoenas; allowing court clerks and |
---|
141 | 49 | | attorneys to issue subpoenas; directing issuers of |
---|
142 | 50 | | subpoenas to avoid imposing undue burden or expense |
---|
143 | 51 | | on persons subject to subpoenas; requiring courts to |
---|
144 | 52 | | enforce said duty; providing for sanctions; allowing |
---|
145 | 53 | | courts to quash or modify subpoenas under certain |
---|
146 | 54 | | circumstances; declaring subpoenas separate and |
---|
147 | 55 | | distinct from certain rights or obligations; amending |
---|
148 | 56 | | 22 O.S. 2021, Section s 708, 710, 712, 715 and 716, |
---|
149 | 57 | | which relate to the service and issuance of |
---|
150 | 58 | | subpoenas; updating statutory reference s and form |
---|
151 | 59 | | requirements; providing guidelines and requirements |
---|
152 | 60 | | for issuing subpoenas requesting the production of |
---|
153 | 61 | | documents or inspecti on of premises; allowing for the |
---|
154 | 62 | | nonappearance of persons unless commanded to appear; |
---|
155 | 63 | | authorizing service of written objection s to |
---|
156 | 64 | | subpoenas; establishing time period for submitting |
---|
157 | 65 | | written objections; providing procedures for serving |
---|
158 | 66 | | written objections; allowing parties to move for |
---|
159 | 67 | | orders to compel production; providing requirements |
---|
160 | 68 | | for producing documents; providing guidelines for |
---|
161 | 69 | | claims of privilege or protection of trial |
---|
162 | 70 | | preparation materials; clarifying processes for |
---|
163 | 71 | | serving subpoenas in person and by mail; modifying |
---|
164 | 72 | | exemption to subpoena requirem ent for court clerks; |
---|
165 | 73 | | clarifying criminal contempt penalty provision; |
---|
166 | 74 | | providing for codification; and providing an |
---|
167 | 75 | | effective date. |
---|
168 | 76 | | |
---|
198 | 107 | | BE IT ENACTED BY THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA: |
---|
199 | 108 | | SECTION 1. NEW LAW A new section of law to be codified |
---|
200 | 109 | | in the Oklahoma Statutes as Section 707.1 of Title 22, unless there |
---|
201 | 110 | | is created a duplication in numbering, reads as follows: |
---|
202 | 111 | | A. A subpoena issued on behalf of or by a defendant to a law |
---|
203 | 112 | | enforcement agency may command the production of the foll owing law |
---|
204 | 113 | | enforcement records: |
---|
205 | 114 | | 1. Body camera videos; |
---|
206 | 115 | | 2. Vehicle mounted camera videos; |
---|
207 | 116 | | 3. Traffic camera videos; and |
---|
208 | 117 | | 4. Law enforcement incident reports. |
---|
209 | 118 | | B. A law enforcement agency may charge a record copying fee of |
---|
210 | 119 | | not more than One Dollar ($1. 00) per page and a video copying fee of |
---|
211 | 120 | | not more than Fifty Dollars ($50.00) per video when complying with |
---|
212 | 121 | | the requests of the subpoena. |
---|
213 | 122 | | SECTION 2. NEW LAW A new section of law to be codified |
---|
214 | 123 | | in the Oklahoma Statutes as Section 707.2 of Title 22, unless there |
---|
215 | 124 | | is created a duplication in numbering, reads as follows: |
---|
216 | 125 | | A. Every subpoena issued on behalf of or by a defendant shall |
---|
217 | 126 | | state the name of the court from which it is issued and the title of |
---|
218 | 127 | | the action. |
---|
247 | 157 | | C. The court clerk shall issue a subpoena, or a subpoena for |
---|
248 | 158 | | the production of documentary evidence, signed and sealed but |
---|
249 | 159 | | otherwise in blank, to a party requesti ng it, who shall complete the |
---|
250 | 160 | | subpoena before service. As an officer of the court, an attorney |
---|
251 | 161 | | authorized to practice law in this state may also issue and sign a |
---|
252 | 162 | | subpoena on behalf of a court in this state. |
---|
253 | 163 | | SECTION 3. NEW LAW A new section of law to be codified |
---|
254 | 164 | | in the Oklahoma Statutes as Section 707. 3 of Title 22, unless there |
---|
255 | 165 | | is created a duplication in numbering, reads as follows: |
---|
256 | 166 | | A party or an attorney responsible for the issuance and service |
---|
257 | 167 | | of a subpoena shall take reasonable steps to avoid imposing undue |
---|
258 | 168 | | burden or expense on a person subject to that subpoena. The court |
---|
259 | 169 | | on behalf of which the subpoena w as issued shall enforce this duty |
---|
260 | 170 | | and impose upon the party or attorney, or both, in breach of this |
---|
261 | 171 | | duty an appropriate sancti on, which may include, but is not limited |
---|
262 | 172 | | to, lost earnings and a reasonable attorney fee. |
---|
263 | 173 | | SECTION 4. NEW LAW A new section of law to be codified |
---|
264 | 174 | | in the Oklahoma Statutes as Section 707. 4 of Title 22, unless there |
---|
265 | 175 | | is created a duplication in numbering, reads as follows: |
---|
266 | 176 | | A. On timely motion, the court by which a subpoena was issued |
---|
267 | 177 | | shall quash or modify the su bpoena if it: |
---|
268 | 178 | | 1. Fails to allow reasonable time for compliance; |
---|
297 | 208 | | 3. Requires disclosure of privileged or other protected matter |
---|
298 | 209 | | and no exception or waiver applies ; |
---|
299 | 210 | | 4. Subjects a person to undue burden ; or |
---|
300 | 211 | | 5. Requires production of books, papers, d ocuments, or tangible |
---|
301 | 212 | | things that fall outside the scope of discovery permitted by Section |
---|
302 | 213 | | 3226 of Title 12 of the Oklahoma Statut es. |
---|
303 | 214 | | B. If a subpoena: |
---|
304 | 215 | | 1. Requires disclosure of a trade secret or other confidential |
---|
305 | 216 | | research, development, or commercial in formation; or |
---|
306 | 217 | | 2. Requires disclosure of the opinion of an unretained expert |
---|
307 | 218 | | or information not describing specific events or occurrences in |
---|
308 | 219 | | dispute and resulting from the study by the expert made not at the |
---|
309 | 220 | | request of any party, the court may, to protect a person subject to |
---|
310 | 221 | | or affected by the subpoena, quash or modify the subpoena. However, |
---|
311 | 222 | | if the party in whose behalf the subpoena is issued shows a |
---|
312 | 223 | | substantial need for the testimony or material that cannot be |
---|
313 | 224 | | otherwise met without undue hardship and assu res that the person to |
---|
314 | 225 | | whom the subpoena is addressed will be reasonably compensated, the |
---|
315 | 226 | | court may order appearance or production only upon specified |
---|
316 | 227 | | conditions. |
---|
346 | 258 | | Subpoenas issued in accordance with the provisions of Sections |
---|
347 | 259 | | 707.1 through 707.3, 708, 710 and 712 of Title 22 of the Oklahoma |
---|
348 | 260 | | Statutes shall be considered separate and distinct from any right or |
---|
349 | 261 | | obligation provided for in Section 2002 of Title 22 of the Oklahoma |
---|
350 | 262 | | Statutes. |
---|
351 | 263 | | SECTION 6. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 708, is |
---|
352 | 264 | | amended to read as follows: |
---|
353 | 265 | | Section 708. A subpoena, authorized by the last four sections |
---|
354 | 266 | | provisions of Sections 704, 705, 706, 707 , and 707.1 of this title, |
---|
355 | 267 | | must be substantially in the following form: |
---|
356 | 268 | | IN THE NAME OF THE STATE OF |
---|
357 | 269 | | OKLAHOMA. |
---|
358 | 270 | | To ......... , |
---|
359 | 271 | | Greeting: You are commanded to appear before C. D., a justice |
---|
360 | 272 | | of the peace of ........ at ....... (or the grand jury of the county |
---|
361 | 273 | | County of ......... or the district court of ......... county |
---|
362 | 274 | | County, or other location as the case may be specified), on the |
---|
363 | 275 | | ........ (stating day and hour), and remain in attendance on and |
---|
364 | 276 | | call of said ........ from day to day and term to term until |
---|
365 | 277 | | lawfully discharged, as a witness in a criminal action prosecuted by |
---|
396 | 309 | | Section 710. A. If the books, papers or documents be required, |
---|
397 | 310 | | a direction to the following effect must be continued in the |
---|
398 | 311 | | subpoena: |
---|
399 | 312 | | And you are required also to bring with you th e following: |
---|
400 | 313 | | (Describe intelligently the books, papers or documents required). |
---|
401 | 314 | | B. A copy of any subpoena that commands production of documents |
---|
402 | 315 | | and things or inspection of premises before trial shall be served on |
---|
403 | 316 | | each party in the manner prescribed by subs ection B of Section 2005 |
---|
404 | 317 | | of Title 12 of the Oklahoma Statutes. If the subpoena commands |
---|
405 | 318 | | production of documents and things or inspection of premises from a |
---|
406 | 319 | | nonparty before trial but does not require attendance of a witness, |
---|
407 | 320 | | the subpoena shall specify a da te and location for the production or |
---|
408 | 321 | | inspection that is at least seven (7) days after the date that the |
---|
409 | 322 | | subpoena and copies of th e subpoena are served on the witness and |
---|
410 | 323 | | all parties, and the subpoena shall include the following language: |
---|
411 | 324 | | "In order to allow objections to the production of documents and |
---|
412 | 325 | | things to be filed, you should not produce them until the date |
---|
413 | 326 | | specified in this subpoena, and if an objection is filed, until the |
---|
414 | 327 | | court rules on the objection. " |
---|
445 | 359 | | inspection unless commanded to appear fo r deposition, hearing , or |
---|
446 | 360 | | trial. |
---|
447 | 361 | | D. Subject to subsection F of this section, a person commanded |
---|
448 | 362 | | to produce and permit inspection, copying, testing or sampling , or |
---|
449 | 363 | | any party may, within fourteen (14) days after service of the |
---|
450 | 364 | | subpoena or before the time sp ecified for compliance if such time is |
---|
451 | 365 | | less than fourteen (14) days after service, serve written objection |
---|
452 | 366 | | to inspection, copying, testing, or sampling of any or all of the |
---|
453 | 367 | | designated materials or of the premises, or to producing |
---|
454 | 368 | | electronically stored info rmation in the form or forms requested. |
---|
455 | 369 | | An objection that all or a portion of the requested material will or |
---|
456 | 370 | | should be withheld on a claim that it is privileged or subject to |
---|
457 | 371 | | protection as trial preparation materials shall be made within this |
---|
458 | 372 | | time period and in accordance with subsection s E and F of this |
---|
459 | 373 | | section. If the objection is made by the witness, the witness shall |
---|
460 | 374 | | serve the objection on all parties; if objection is made by a party, |
---|
461 | 375 | | the party shall serve the objection on the witness and all other |
---|
462 | 376 | | parties. If objection is made, the party serving the subpoena shall |
---|
463 | 377 | | not be entitled to inspect, copy, test , or sample the materials or |
---|
464 | 378 | | inspect the premises except pursuant to an order of the court by |
---|
495 | 410 | | solely for a failure to timely object under this section. If |
---|
496 | 411 | | objection has been made, the party serving the subpoena may, upon |
---|
497 | 412 | | notice to the person commanded to produce, move at any time for an |
---|
498 | 413 | | order to compel the production. Such an order to compel production |
---|
499 | 414 | | shall protect any person who is not a part y or an officer of a party |
---|
500 | 415 | | from significant expense resulting from the inspection and copying |
---|
501 | 416 | | commanded. |
---|
502 | 417 | | E. 1. A person respondi ng to a subpoena to produce documents |
---|
503 | 418 | | shall produce them as they are kept in the usual course of business |
---|
504 | 419 | | or shall organize an d label them to correspond with the categories |
---|
505 | 420 | | in the demand. |
---|
506 | 421 | | 2. If a subpoena does not specify the form or forms for |
---|
507 | 422 | | producing electronically stored information, a person responding to |
---|
508 | 423 | | a subpoena shall produce the information in a form or forms in which |
---|
509 | 424 | | the person ordinarily maintains it or in a form or forms that are |
---|
510 | 425 | | reasonably usable. |
---|
511 | 426 | | 3. A person responding to a subpoena is not required to produce |
---|
512 | 427 | | the same electronically stored information in more than one form. |
---|
513 | 428 | | 4. A person responding to a subpoena is not required to provide |
---|
514 | 429 | | discovery of electronically stored information from sources that the |
---|
545 | 461 | | of subsection B of Section 3226 of Title 12 of the Oklahoma |
---|
546 | 462 | | Statutes. The court may specify conditions for the discovery. |
---|
547 | 463 | | F. 1. When information subject to a subpoena is withheld on a |
---|
548 | 464 | | claim that it is privileged or subject to protection as trial |
---|
549 | 465 | | preparation materials, the claim shall be made expressly and shall |
---|
550 | 466 | | be supported by a description of the nature of the documents, |
---|
551 | 467 | | communications, or things not produced that is sufficient to enable |
---|
552 | 468 | | the demanding party to contest the claim. |
---|
553 | 469 | | 2. If information is produced in response to a subpoena th at is |
---|
554 | 470 | | subject to a claim or privilege or of protection as trial |
---|
555 | 471 | | preparation material, the person making the claim may notify a ny |
---|
556 | 472 | | party that received the information of the claim and the basis for |
---|
557 | 473 | | such claim. After being notified, a party shall promptly return, |
---|
558 | 474 | | sequester, or destroy the specified information and any copies the |
---|
559 | 475 | | party has and may not use or disclose the information until the |
---|
560 | 476 | | claim is resolved. A receiving party may promptly present the |
---|
561 | 477 | | information to the court under seal for a determination of the |
---|
562 | 478 | | claim. If the receiving party disclosed the information before |
---|
563 | 479 | | being notified, such party shall take reasonable steps to retrieve |
---|
564 | 480 | | the information. The person who produced the information shall |
---|
594 | 511 | | protection as trial preparation material or whether such privilege |
---|
595 | 512 | | or protection has been waived. |
---|
596 | 513 | | SECTION 8. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 712, is |
---|
597 | 514 | | amended to read as follows: |
---|
598 | 515 | | Section 712. A. Service of subpoenas for witnesses in criminal |
---|
599 | 516 | | actions in the district courts of this state a subpoena upon a |
---|
600 | 517 | | person named therein shall be made in the same manner as in civil |
---|
601 | 518 | | actions pursuant to Section 2004.1 of Title 12 of the Oklahoma |
---|
602 | 519 | | Statutes by delivering or mailing a copy thereo f to such person and, |
---|
603 | 520 | | if the attendance of the person is demanded, by tendering to that |
---|
604 | 521 | | person the fees for one (1) day of attenda nce and the mileage |
---|
605 | 522 | | allowed by law. Service of a subpoena may be accomplished by any |
---|
606 | 523 | | person who is eighteen (18) years of age or older. |
---|
607 | 524 | | B. Service of a subpoena by mail may be accomplished by mailing |
---|
608 | 525 | | a copy thereof by certified mail with return receipt requested and |
---|
609 | 526 | | delivery restricted to the person named in the subpoena. The person |
---|
610 | 527 | | serving the subpoena shall make proof of ser vice thereof to the |
---|
611 | 528 | | court promptly, and in any event, before the witness is required to |
---|
612 | 529 | | testify at the hearing or trial. If service is made by a person |
---|
613 | 530 | | other than a peace officer, such person shall make affidavit |
---|
614 | 531 | | thereof. If service is by mail, the perso n serving the subpoena |
---|
644 | 562 | | validity of the service, but servic e of a subpoena by mail shall not |
---|
645 | 563 | | be effective if the mailing was not accepted by the person named in |
---|
646 | 564 | | the subpoena. The cost costs of service of subpoenas shall be borne |
---|
647 | 565 | | by the parties unless otherwise ordered by the court allowed whether |
---|
648 | 566 | | service is made by a peace officer or any other person . |
---|
649 | 567 | | SECTION 9. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 715, is |
---|
650 | 568 | | amended to read as follows: |
---|
651 | 569 | | Section 715. A. No person is obliged to attend as a witness |
---|
652 | 570 | | before a court or magistrate outside the county where the witness |
---|
653 | 571 | | resides or is served with a subpoena, unless the judge of the court |
---|
654 | 572 | | in which the offense is triable, upon an aff idavit of the district |
---|
655 | 573 | | attorney, or of the defendant or the defendant 's counsel, stating |
---|
656 | 574 | | that he or she believes that the evid ence and attendance of the |
---|
657 | 575 | | witness is material and necessary, shall endorse on the subpoena an |
---|
658 | 576 | | order for the attendance of the witness. |
---|
659 | 577 | | B. The court clerks of this state shall not be subject to |
---|
660 | 578 | | subpoena in matters relating to court records unless the court makes |
---|
661 | 579 | | a specific finding that the appearance and testimony of the court |
---|
662 | 580 | | clerk are both material and necessary because of a writt en objection |
---|
663 | 581 | | to the introduction of certified documents court records made by the |
---|
664 | 582 | | defendant or other party prior to trial. |
---|
693 | 612 | | Section 716. Disobedience or failure by any person without |
---|
694 | 613 | | adequate excuse to obey a subpoena served upon himself or herself , |
---|
695 | 614 | | or a refusal to be sworn o r to testify, may be punished by the court |
---|
696 | 615 | | or magistrate, as for deemed a criminal contempt, in the manner |
---|
697 | 616 | | provided in civil proce dure of the court from which the subpoena was |
---|
698 | 617 | | issued. |
---|
699 | 618 | | SECTION 11. This act shall become effective November 1, 2024. |
---|