Oklahoma 2024 Regular Session

Oklahoma Senate Bill SB325 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
11
22
3+ENGR. H. A. to ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 1 1
4+2
5+3
6+4
7+5
8+6
9+7
10+8
11+9
12+10
13+11
14+12
15+13
16+14
17+15
18+16
19+17
20+18
21+19
22+20
23+21
24+22
25+23
26+24
327
4-An Act
5-ENROLLED SENATE
6-BILL NO. 325 By: Daniels of the Senate
28+ENGROSSED HOUSE AMENDME NT
29+ TO
30+ENGROSSED SENATE BILL NO . 325 By: Daniels of the Senate
731
832 and
933
10- Duel, Deck, Lepak, and Lowe
11-(Jason) of the House
12-
34+ Duel of the House
1335
1436
1537
1638
1739
1840 An Act relating to criminal prosecutions; amending 22
1941 O.S. 2021, Sections 812.1 and 812.2, which relate to
2042 the right to speedy trial; m odifying time limits for
2143 conducting certain criminal proceedings; updating
44+statutory references; limiting number of continuances
45+on certain grounds; adding permissible grounds for
46+delay of certain proceedings; increasing frequency of
47+certain required revie w; updating statutory language;
48+and providing an effective date .
49+
50+
51+
52+
53+
54+
55+
56+
57+
58+AUTHOR: Add the following House Coauthor s: Deck and Lepak
59+
60+AMENDMENT NO. 1. Strike the title, enacting clause, and entire bill
61+and insert:
62+
63+
64+
65+
66+"An Act relating to criminal prosecutions; amending
67+22 O.S. 2021, Sections 812.1 and 812.2, which relate
68+to the right to speedy trial; modifying time limits
69+for conducting certain criminal procee dings; updating
2270 statutory references; providing time limitation for
2371 setting trial date; adding and modifying permissible
2472 grounds for the delay of certain proceedings;
2573 decreasing time limitation for settin g certain cases
74+
75+ENGR. H. A. to ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 2 1
76+2
77+3
78+4
79+5
80+6
81+7
82+8
83+9
84+10
85+11
86+12
87+13
88+14
89+15
90+16
91+17
92+18
93+19
94+20
95+21
96+22
97+23
98+24
99+
26100 for review; updating statutory langu age; and
27101 providing an effective date .
28102
29103
30104
31105
32-
33-SUBJECT: Criminal prosecutions
34-
35106 BE IT ENACTED BY THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA:
36-
37107 SECTION 1. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 812.1, is
38108 amended to read as follows:
39-
40-Section 812.1. A. If any person charged with a crime and held
109+Section 812.1 A. If any person charged with a crim e and held
41110 in jail solely by reason thereof is not brought to trial within one
42111 (1) year after arrest nine (9) months after the initial appearance
43112 by the person on the charge, the court shall set the case for
44113 immediate review as provided in Section 2 812.2 of this act title,
45114 to determine if the r ight of the accused to a speedy trial , as
46-
47-ENR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 2
48115 provided in this section and in Section 812.2 of this t itle, is
49116 being protected.
50-
51117 B. If any person charged with a fe lony crime who is held to
52118 answer on an appearance bond is not brought to trial within eighteen
53119 (18) months after arrest the initial appearance, the court shall set
54120 the case for immediate review as provided in Section 2 812.2 of this
55121 act, title to determine if the right of the accused to a speedy
56122 trial is being protected.
57-
58123 C. In the event a mistrial is declared or a conviction is
59124 reversed on appeal, the time l imitations provided for in this
60125 section shall commence to run from the date the mistrial is declared
61126 or the date of the mandate of the Court of Criminal Appea ls.
62127
128+ENGR. H. A. to ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 3 1
129+2
130+3
131+4
132+5
133+6
134+7
135+8
136+9
137+10
138+11
139+12
140+13
141+14
142+15
143+16
144+17
145+18
146+19
147+20
148+21
149+22
150+23
151+24
152+
63153 SECTION 2. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 81 2.2, is
64154 amended to read as follows:
65-
66-Section 812.2. A. Whenever the court find s that a case should
155+Section 812.2 A. Whenever the court finds that a case should
67156 be reviewed to determin e if the right of an accused to a speedy
68157 trial is being protected, the court shall:
69-
70158 1. Issue notice to the District Attorney district attorney, the
71159 accused, and the attorney for the accused that the case will be
72160 reviewed by the court at a date and time wh ich is not less than ten
73161 (10) days nor more than twenty (2 0) days from the date of the
74162 notice. Each party shall have the opportunity to present evidence
75163 or legal authority in support of its position; and
76-
77164 2. Take evidence from both parties regarding the
78165 appropriateness of the cause for the delay. At the hearing , the
79166 court shall consider whether the delay has occurred for any of the
80167 following reasons:
81-
82168 a. the extent to which the delay is the result of the
83169 application of the accused or an attorney on behalf of
84170 the accused,
85-
86171 b. the extent to which the delay is the result of the
87172 fault of the accused or the attorney for the accused,
88-
89173 c. the accused is incompetent to stand trial,
90-
91-ENR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 3
92-
93174 d. a proceeding to determine the competency of the accused
94175 to stand trial is pending and a determination cannot be
95176 completed within the time lim itations fixed for trial,
177+
178+ENGR. H. A. to ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 4 1
179+2
180+3
181+4
182+5
183+6
184+7
185+8
186+9
187+10
188+11
189+12
190+13
191+14
192+15
193+16
194+17
195+18
196+19
197+20
198+21
199+22
200+23
201+24
96202
97203 e. there is material evidence or a material witness which
98204 is unavailable and that reasonable efforts have been
99205 made to procure such evidence or witness, and there are
100206 reasonable grounds to believe t hat such evidence or
101207 witness can be obtained and trial commenced within a
102208 reasonable time,
103-
104209 f. the accused is charged as a codefend ant or
105210 coconspirator and the court has determined that the
106211 codefendants or coconspirators must be tried before
107212 separate juries taken from separate jury panels ,
108-
109213 g. the court has other cases pending for trial that are
110214 for persons incarcerated prior to the ca se in question,
111215 and the court does not have sufficient time to commence
112216 the trial of the case within the time limitation fixed
113217 for trial; provided, the case shall be commenced as
114218 soon as practicable,
115-
116219 h. the court, state, accused, or th e attorney for the
117220 accused is incapable of proceeding to trial due to
118221 illness or other exigent reason and it is unr easonable
119222 to reassign the case, and
120-
121223 i. no court reporter is avai lable for the trial of the
122224 case; provided, if the delay is pursuant to this
123225 subparagraph, a court reporter shall be assigned within
124226 sixty (60) days of the hear ing, and
227+
228+ENGR. H. A. to ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 5 1
229+2
230+3
231+4
232+5
233+6
234+7
235+8
236+9
237+10
238+11
239+12
240+13
241+14
242+15
243+16
244+17
245+18
246+19
247+20
248+21
249+22
250+23
251+24
125252
126253 j. due to other reasonable grounds the court does not have
127254 sufficient time to commence the trial of the case
128255 within the time limit fixed for trial ; provided, the
129256 court shall commence the trial case as soon thereafter
130257 as practicable.
131-
132258 B. If, after After hearing all the evidence and the legal
133259 arguments properly submitted, if the court finds by a preponderance
134-
135-ENR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 4
136260 of the evidence that the state is not proc eeding with due diligence,
137261 that none of the exceptions set out in paragraph 2 of subsection A
138262 of this section just ify additional delay and the right of t he
139263 accused to a speedy trial as provided in this section and Section
140264 812.1 of this title has been violated, the court shall dismiss the
141265 case.
142-
143266 C. If a preliminary hearing has been held, the case may be
144267 refiled, unless the applicable statute of limitations has expired,
145268 upon a showing of newly discover ed evidence which could not have
146269 been discovered prior to trial, unless the applicable statute of
147270 limitations has expired.
148-
149271 D. If a preliminary hearing has not been held, t he case may be
150272 refiled, upon good cause shown, unless any applicable statute of
151273 limitations has expired.
152-
153274 E. If, after After hearing all the evidence and the legal
154275 arguments properly submitted, if the court finds that the right of
155276 the accused to a speedy t rial has not been violated, the court s hall
277+
278+ENGR. H. A. to ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 6 1
279+2
280+3
281+4
282+5
283+6
284+7
285+8
286+9
287+10
288+11
289+12
290+13
291+14
292+15
293+16
294+17
295+18
296+19
297+20
298+21
299+22
300+23
301+24
302+
156303 set the case for review in four (4) within three (3) months. If the
157304 case is still pending after t he four-month three-month period, the
158305 court shall conduct another review. The four-month review of
159306 pending cases shall be a continuing responsibility of the court
160307 until final disposition of the cas e.
161-
162-SECTION 3. This act shall become effective November 1, 2024.
308+SECTION 3. This act shall become effective November 1, 20 24."
309+Passed the House of Representatives the 24th day of April, 2024.
163310
164311
165-ENR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 5
166-Passed the Senate the 21st day of May, 2024.
312+
313+
314+
315+Presiding Officer of the House of
316+ Representatives
317+
318+
319+Passed the Senate the ____ day of _______ ___, 2024.
320+
321+
167322
168323
169324
170325 Presiding Officer of the Senate
171326
172327
173-Passed the House of Representatives the 24th day of April, 2024.
328+ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 1 1
329+2
330+3
331+4
332+5
333+6
334+7
335+8
336+9
337+10
338+11
339+12
340+13
341+14
342+15
343+16
344+17
345+18
346+19
347+20
348+21
349+22
350+23
351+24
352+
353+ENGROSSED SENATE
354+BILL NO. 325 By: Daniels of the Senate
355+
356+ and
357+
358+ Duel of the House
359+
360+
361+
362+
363+An Act relating to criminal prosecutions; amending 22
364+O.S. 2021, Sections 812.1 and 812.2, which relate to
365+the right to speedy trial; modifying time limits for
366+conducting certain criminal proceedings; updating
367+statutory references; limiting number of continuances
368+on certain grounds; adding permissible grounds for
369+delay of certain proceedings; increasing frequency of
370+certain required review; updating statutory language;
371+and providing an effective date .
372+
373+
374+
375+
376+
377+BE IT ENACTED BY THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA:
378+SECTION 4. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 812.1, is
379+amended to read as follows:
380+Section 812.1. A. If any person charged with a crime a nd held
381+in jail solely by reason thereof is not brought to trial within one
382+(1) year after arrest nine (9) months after the person ’s initial
383+appearance on the charge , the court shall set the case for immediate
384+review as provided in Section 2 812.2 of this act title, to
385+determine if the right of the accused to a speedy trial is being
386+protected.
387+B. If any person charged with a felony crime who is held to
388+answer on an appearance bond is not brought to trial within eighteen
389+
390+ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 2 1
391+2
392+3
393+4
394+5
395+6
396+7
397+8
398+9
399+10
400+11
401+12
402+13
403+14
404+15
405+16
406+17
407+18
408+19
409+20
410+21
411+22
412+23
413+24
414+
415+(18) months after arrest initial appearance, the court shall set the
416+case for immediate revi ew as provided in Section 2 812.2 of this
417+act, title to determine if the right of the accused to a speedy
418+trial is being protected.
419+C. In the event a mistrial is declared or a conviction is
420+reversed on appeal, the time limitations provided for in this
421+section shall commence to run from the date the mistrial is declared
422+or the date of the mandate of the Court of Criminal Appeals.
423+SECTION 5. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 812 .2, is
424+amended to read as follows:
425+Section 812.2. A. W henever the court finds that a case should
426+be reviewed to determine if the right of an accused to a speedy
427+trial is being protected, the court shall:
428+1. Issue notice to the District Attorney district attorney, the
429+accused, and the attorney for the accused that the case will be
430+reviewed by the court at a date and time which is not less than ten
431+(10) days nor more than twenty (20) days from the date of the
432+notice. Each party shall have the opportunity to present evidence
433+or legal authority in support of its position; and
434+2. Take evidence from both parties regarding the
435+appropriateness of the cause for the delay. At the hearing, the
436+court shall consider whether the delay has occurred for any of the
437+following reasons:
438+
439+ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 3 1
440+2
441+3
442+4
443+5
444+6
445+7
446+8
447+9
448+10
449+11
450+12
451+13
452+14
453+15
454+16
455+17
456+18
457+19
458+20
459+21
460+22
461+23
462+24
463+
464+a. the delay is the result of due to the application of
465+the accused or an attorney on behalf of the accused,
466+b. the delay is the result of due to the fault of the
467+accused or the attorney for the accused,
468+c. the accused is incompetent to sta nd trial,
469+d. a proceeding to determine the competency of the accused
470+to stand trial is pending and a determination cannot be
471+completed within the time limitations fixed for trial,
472+e. there is material evidence or a material witness which
473+is unavailable and that reasonable efforts have be en
474+made to procure such evidence or witness, and there are
475+reasonable grounds to believe that such evidence or
476+witness can be obtained and trial commenced within a
477+reasonable time,
478+f. the accused is charged as a codefendant or
479+coconspirator and the court has determined that the
480+codefendants or coconspirators must be tried before
481+separate juries taken from separate jury panels,
482+g. the court has other cases pending for trial that are
483+for persons incarcerated prior to the case i n question,
484+and the court does n ot have sufficient time to commence
485+the trial of the case within the time limitation fixed
486+for trial; provided, no more than three continuances of
487+
488+ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 4 1
489+2
490+3
491+4
492+5
493+6
494+7
495+8
496+9
497+10
498+11
499+12
500+13
501+14
502+15
503+16
504+17
505+18
506+19
507+20
508+21
509+22
510+23
511+24
512+
513+not more than thirty (30) days may be ordered pursuant
514+to this subparagraph ,
515+h. the court, state, accused, or the attorney for the
516+accused is incapable of proceeding to trial due to
517+illness or other reason and it is unreasonable to
518+reassign the case, and
519+i. no court reporter is available for the trial of the
520+case; provided, if the delay is pursuant to this
521+subparagraph, a court reporter shall be assigned for
522+trial within sixty (60) days of the hearing,
523+j. a continuance is granted to allow the prosecution
524+additional time to prepare in a felony case if the
525+court enters specific findin gs that additional time is
526+justified due to exceptional circumstances, and
527+k. due to other reasonable grounds the court does not have
528+sufficient time to commence the trial of the case
529+within the time limit fixed for trial ; provided, no
530+more than one continuance of not more than thirty (3 0)
531+days may be ordered p ursuant to this subparagraph .
532+B. If, after After hearing all the evidence and the legal
533+arguments properly submitted, if the court finds by a preponderance
534+of the evidence that the state is not proce eding with due diligence,
535+that none of the exceptions se t out in paragraph 2 of subsection A
536+of this section justify additional delay and the right of the
537+
538+ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 5 1
539+2
540+3
541+4
542+5
543+6
544+7
545+8
546+9
547+10
548+11
549+12
550+13
551+14
552+15
553+16
554+17
555+18
556+19
557+20
558+21
559+22
560+23
561+24
562+
563+accused to a speedy trial as provided in this section and Section
564+812.1 of this title has been violated, the court shall dismiss the
565+case.
566+C. If a preliminary hearing has been held, the case may be
567+refiled, unless the applicable statute of limitations has expired,
568+upon a showing of newly discovered evidence which could not have
569+been discovered prior to t rial, unless the applicable statute of
570+limitations has expired.
571+D. If a preliminary hearing has not been held, the case may be
572+refiled, upon good cause shown , unless any applicable statute of
573+limitations has expired.
574+E. If, after After hearing all the evidence and the legal
575+arguments properly submitted, if the court finds that the right of
576+the accused to a speedy trial has not been violated, the court shall
577+set the case for review in four (4) within three (3) months. If the
578+case is still pending after th e four-month three-month period, the
579+court shall conduct another review within thirty (30) days . The
580+four-month review of pending cases every thirty (30) days shall be a
581+continuing responsibility of the court until final disposition of
582+the case.
583+SECTION 6. This act shall become effective Novem ber 1, 2024.
584+
585+ENGR. S. B. NO. 325 Page 6 1
586+2
587+3
588+4
589+5
590+6
591+7
592+8
593+9
594+10
595+11
596+12
597+13
598+14
599+15
600+16
601+17
602+18
603+19
604+20
605+21
606+22
607+23
608+24
609+
610+Passed the Senate the 4th day of March, 2024.
611+
612+
613+
614+ Presiding Officer of the Senate
615+
616+
617+Passed the House of Representatives the ____ day of __________,
618+2024.
174619
175620
176621
177622 Presiding Officer of the Ho use
178623 of Representatives
179624
180-OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
181-Received by the Office of the Governor this _______ _____________
182-day of ___________________, 20_______, at _______ o'clock _______ M.
183-By: _________________________________
184-Approved by the Governor of the State of Oklahoma this _______ __
185-day of _________________ __, 20_______, at _______ o'clock _______ M.
186625
187- ______________________________ ___
188- Governor of the State of Oklahoma
189-
190-
191-OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE
192-Received by the Office of the Secretary of State this _______ ___
193-day of _________________ _, 20 _______, at _______ o'clock _______ M.
194-By: _________________________________