Oklahoma 2024 Regular Session

Oklahoma Senate Bill SB771 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
11
22
3+SB771 HFLR Page 1
4+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
5+2
6+3
7+4
8+5
9+6
10+7
11+8
12+9
13+10
14+11
15+12
16+13
17+14
18+15
19+16
20+17
21+18
22+19
23+20
24+21
25+22
26+23
27+24
328
4-An Act
5-ENROLLED SENATE
29+HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES - FLOOR VERSION
30+
31+STATE OF OKLAHOMA
32+
33+2nd Session of the 59th Legislature (2024)
34+
35+ENGROSSED SENATE
636 BILL NO. 771 By: Gollihare of the Senate
737
838 and
939
1040 Lawson of the House
1141
1242
1343
1444
1545 An Act relating to determination of competence;
1646 amending 22 O.S. 2021, Sections 1175.1, 1175.3,
1747 1175.4, and 1175.6b, which relate to definitions and
1848 procedures for determining competency; modifying
1949 definitions; providing for standing for Office of
2050 Public Guardian to participate in certain
2151 proceedings; requiring court to consider certain
2252 recommendations; updating statutory reference; and
2353 providing an effective date .
2454
2555
2656
2757
2858
29-SUBJECT: Determination of competence
30-
3159 BE IT ENACTED BY THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA:
32-
3360 SECTION 1. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 1175.1, is
3461 amended to read as follows:
35-
3662 Section 1175.1. As used in Sections 1175.1 through 1176 of this
3763 title:
38-
3964 1. “Competent” or “competency” means the present ability of a
4065 person arrested for or charged with a crime to understand the nature
4166 of the charges and proceedings brou ght against him or her and to
4267 effectively and rationally assist in his or her defense;
4368
69+SB771 HFLR Page 2
70+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
71+2
72+3
73+4
74+5
75+6
76+7
77+8
78+9
79+10
80+11
81+12
82+13
83+14
84+15
85+16
86+17
87+18
88+19
89+20
90+21
91+22
92+23
93+24
94+
4495 2. “Criminal proceeding” means every stage of a criminal
4596 prosecution after arrest and before judgment, including, but not
46-
47-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 2
4897 limited to, interrogation, lineup, preliminary hearing, motion
4998 dockets, discovery, pretrial hearings and trial;
50-
5199 3. “Dangerous” means a person who is a person requiring
52100 treatment as defined in Section 1 -103 of Title 43A of the Oklahoma
53101 Statutes;
54-
55102 4. “Incompetent” or “incompetency” means the present in ability
56103 of a person arrested for or charged with a crime to understand the
57104 nature of the charges and pro ceedings brought against him or her and
58105 to effectively and rationally assist in his or her defense;
59-
60106 3. “Dangerous” means a person who is a person requi ring
61107 treatment as defined in Section 1 -103 of Title 43A of the Oklahoma
62108 Statutes;
63-
64109 4. “Criminal proceeding” means every stage of a criminal
65110 prosecution after arrest and before judgment, including, but not
66111 limited to, interrogation, lineup, preliminary hear ing, motion
67112 dockets, discovery, pretrial hearings and trial;
68-
69113 5. “Public guardian” means the Office of P ublic Guardian as
70114 established under the Oklahoma Public Guardianship Act in Section 6 -
71115 101 et seq. of Title 30 of the Oklahoma Statutes;
116+6. “Qualified forensic examiner” means any:
117+a. psychiatrist with forensic training and experience,
118+b. psychologist with forensic training and experience, or
72119
73-6. “Qualified forensic examiner ” means any:
74-
75-a. psychiatrist with forens ic training and experience,
76-
77-b. psychologist with forensic training and experience, or
120+SB771 HFLR Page 3
121+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
122+2
123+3
124+4
125+5
126+6
127+7
128+8
129+9
130+10
131+11
132+12
133+13
134+14
135+15
136+16
137+17
138+18
139+19
140+20
141+21
142+22
143+23
144+24
78145
79146 c. a licensed mental health professional whose forensic
80147 training and experience enable him or her to form
81148 expert opinions regarding mental illness, competency
82149 and dangerousness and who has been approved to render
83150 such opinions by the court; provided, however, a
84151 licensed mental health professional shall not be
85152 qualified to issue expert opinions as to competency or
86153 dangerousness in cases in which a person is alleged to
87154 be incompetent due to intellectual disability; and
88-
89-
90-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 3
91155 6. 7. “Reasonable period of time ” means a period not to exceed
92156 the lesser of:
93-
94157 a. the maximum sentence specified for the most serious
95158 offense with which t he defendant is charged, or
96-
97159 b. a maximum period of two (2) years ; and
98-
99160 7. “Public guardian” means the Office of Public Guardian as
100161 established under the Oklahoma Public Guardianship Act in Section 6 -
101162 101 et seq. of Title 30 of the Oklahoma Statutes .
102-
103163 SECTION 2. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 1175.3, is
104164 amended to read as follows:
105-
106165 Section 1175.3. A. Upon filing of an application for
107166 determination of competency, the court shall set a hearing date,
108167 which shall be as soon as practica ble, but at least one (1) day
109168 after service of notice as provided by Section 1175.2 of this title.
169+
170+SB771 HFLR Page 4
171+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
172+2
173+3
174+4
175+5
176+6
177+7
178+8
179+9
180+10
181+11
182+12
183+13
184+14
185+15
186+16
187+17
188+18
189+19
190+20
191+21
192+22
193+23
194+24
110195
111196 B. The court shall hold a hearing on the date provided. At the
112197 hearing, the court shall examine the application for determination
113198 of competency to determin e if it alleges facts sufficient to raise a
114199 doubt as to the competency of the person. Any additional evi dence
115200 tending to create a doubt as to the competency of the person may be
116201 presented at this hearing.
117-
118202 C. If the court finds there is no doubt as to the competency of
119203 the person, it shall order the criminal proceedings to resume.
120-
121204 D. 1. a. If the court finds there is a doubt as to the
122205 competency of the person, it shall order the person to
123206 be examined by the Department of Mental Health and
124207 Substance Abuse Services or by a qualified forensic
125208 examiner designated by the Department to perform
126209 competency examinatio ns.
127-
128210 b. In addition, the Developmental Disabilities Services
129211 Division and the Office of Public Guardian of the
130212 Department of Human Services shall receiv e written
131213 notice from the district attorney who filed the
132214 criminal petition, and be authorized by order of the
133-
134-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 4
135215 court to have a psychologist or other appropriate
136216 clinician participate with professionals assigned by
137217 any other public or private agency in any competency
138218 evaluation wherein where developmental or intellectual
139219 disability may be involved. The psycho logist or
220+
221+SB771 HFLR Page 5
222+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
223+2
224+3
225+4
226+5
227+6
228+7
229+8
230+9
231+10
232+11
233+12
234+13
235+14
236+15
237+16
238+17
239+18
240+19
241+20
242+21
243+22
244+23
245+24
246+
140247 clinician employed, by contract or otherwise, by the
141248 Department of Human Services may issue a separate
142249 opinion and recommendation to the cour t. In such
143250 cases where intellectual disability may be involved,
144251 the Office of Public Guardian shall hav e standing to
145252 participate in any stage of the proceedings as deemed
146253 necessary by the Office.
147-
148254 2. The person shall be examined by a qualified forensic
149255 examiner on an outpatient basis prior to referral for any necessary
150256 inpatient evaluation, as ordered by the court. The outpatient
151257 examination may be conducted in the community, the jail or detention
152258 facility where the person is held.
153-
154259 3. If the court determ ines that the person whose competency is
155260 in question may be dangerous as defined in Section 1175.1 of th is
156261 title, it shall order the person retained in a secure facility until
157262 the completion of the competency hearing provided in Section 1175.4
158263 of this title. If the court determines the person may be dangerous
159264 as defined in Section 1175.1 of this title becaus e the individual is
160265 a person requiring treatment as defined in Section 1 -103 of Title
161266 43A of the Oklahoma Statutes, it may commit the person to the
162267 custody of the Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse
163268 Services or any other state agency or privat e facility for the
164269 examination required by this subsection. The person shall be
165270 required to undergo examination for a period of time sufficient for
271+
272+SB771 HFLR Page 6
273+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
274+2
275+3
276+4
277+5
278+6
279+7
280+8
281+9
282+10
283+11
284+12
285+13
286+14
287+15
288+16
289+17
290+18
291+19
292+20
293+21
294+22
295+23
296+24
297+
166298 the qualified forensic examiner(s) examiner or examiners to reach a
167299 conclusion as to competency, and the cou rt shall impose a reasonable
168300 time limitation for such period of examination.
169-
170301 E. The qualified forensic examiner(s) examiner or examiners
171302 shall receive instructions that they shall examine the patient to
172303 determine:
173-
174304 1. If the person is able to appreciate the nature of the
175305 charges made against such person;
176-
177-
178-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 5
179306 2. If the person is able to consult with the lawyer and
180307 rationally assist in the preparation of the defense of such person;
181-
182308 3. If the person is unable to appreciate the nature of the
183309 charges or to consul t and rationally assist in the preparation of
184310 the defense, whether the person can attain competency within a
185311 reasonable period of time as defined in Se ction 1175.1 of this title
186312 if provided with a course of treatment, therapy or training;
187-
188313 4. If the person is a person requiring treatment as defined by
189314 Section 1-103 of Title 43A of the Oklahoma Statutes;
190-
191315 5. If the person is incompetent because the person is
192316 intellectually disabled as defined in Section 1408 of Title 10 of
193317 the Oklahoma Statutes;
194-
195318 6. If the answers to questions requirements of paragraphs 4 and
196319 5 of this subsection are no not established, why the reasoning for
197320 which the defendant is otherwise incompetent; and
198321
322+SB771 HFLR Page 7
323+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
324+2
325+3
326+4
327+5
328+6
329+7
330+8
331+9
332+10
333+11
334+12
335+13
336+14
337+15
338+16
339+17
340+18
341+19
342+20
343+21
344+22
345+23
346+24
347+
199348 7. If the person were released, whether such person would
200349 presently be dangerous as defined in Section 1175.1 of this title.
201-
202350 F. Upon completion of the competency evaluation, the Department
203351 of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services or qualified forensic
204352 examiner designated by the Department to perform competency
205353 examinations shall noti fy the court of its findings. If the person
206354 is in the custody of the Department of Mental Health and Substance
207355 Abuse Services, the person shall be ret urned to the court in the
208356 customary manner within five (5) business days. If the person is
209357 not returned within that time, the county in which the proceedings
210358 are to be held shall pay the costs of maintaining the person at the
211359 institution or facility for t he period of time the person remains at
212360 the institution or facility in excess of the five -day period.
213-
214361 SECTION 3. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 1175.4, is
215362 amended to read as follows:
216-
217363 Section 1175.4. A. A hearing to determine t he competency of
218364 the person whose competency is in question shall be held within
219365 thirty (30) days after the qualified forensic examiner(s) examiner
220366 or examiners have made the determination required in Section 1175.3
221-
222-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 6
223367 of this title. In such cases where inte llectual disability may be
224368 involved, the Office of Public Guardian shall have standing to
225369 participate in any stage of the proceedings as deemed necessary by
226370 the Office.
371+
372+SB771 HFLR Page 8
373+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
374+2
375+3
376+4
377+5
378+6
379+7
380+8
381+9
382+10
383+11
384+12
385+13
386+14
387+15
388+16
389+17
390+18
391+19
392+20
393+21
394+22
395+23
396+24
227397
228398 B. The court, at the hearing, shall determine by a
229399 preponderance of the evidence if th e person is incompetent. Such
230400 determination shall include consideration of all reports prepared by
231401 the qualified forensic examiner(s) examiner or examiners ; provided,
232402 however, in any case where intellectual disability may be involved,
233403 the recommendations of examiners set forth in subparagraph b of
234404 paragraph 1 of subsection D of Section 1175.3 of this title shall be
235405 considered by the court . The person shall be presumed to be
236406 competent for the purposes of the allocation of the burden of proof
237407 and burden of going forward with the evidence. If the court deems
238408 it necessary, or if the person alleged to be a pers on requiring
239409 treatment, or any relative, friend, or any person with whom he may
240410 reside, or at whose house the person may be, shall so demand, the
241411 court shall schedule the hearing on the application as a jury trial
242412 to be held within seventy -two (72) hours of the request, excluding
243413 weekends and legal holidays, or within as much additional time as is
244414 requested by the attorney of the person whose competency i s in
245415 question, upon good cause shown. The jury shall be composed of six
246416 (6) persons having the qualific ations required of jurors in courts
247417 of record, summoned to determine the questions of the person ’s
248418 competency and need for treatment. Whenever a jury i s required, the
249419 court shall proceed to the selection of such jury in the manner as
250420 provided by law and su ch jury shall determine the questions of the
251421 competency and need for treatment of the person whose competency is
422+
423+SB771 HFLR Page 9
424+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
425+2
426+3
427+4
428+5
429+6
430+7
431+8
432+9
433+10
434+11
435+12
436+13
437+14
438+15
439+16
440+17
441+18
442+19
443+20
444+21
445+22
446+23
447+24
448+
252449 in question. The jurors shall receive fees for attendance and
253450 mileage as are allowed by law.
254-
255451 C. The person whose competency is in question s hall have the
256452 right to be present at the hearing on the petition unless it is made
257453 to appear to the court that the presence of the person makes it
258454 impossible to conduct the hearing in a reasonable manner. The court
259455 may not decide in advance of the hearing, solely on the basis of the
260456 certificate of the examining doctor or doctors, that the person
261457 whose competency is in question should not be allowed to ap pear. It
262458 shall be made to appear to the court based on clear and convincing
263459 evidence that alternatives to exclusion were attempted before the
264-
265-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 7
266460 court renders the person ’s removal for that purpose or the person ’s
267461 appearance at such hearing improper and unsaf e.
268-
269462 D. All witnesses shall be subject to cross -examination in the
270463 same manner as is provided by law. If so stipulated by counsel for
271464 a person whose competency is in question, the district attorney and
272465 the court, testimony may be given by telephone or othe r electronic
273466 transmitting device approved by the court. No statement, admission
274467 or confession made by t he person whose competency is in question
275468 obtained during the examination for competency may be used for any
276469 purpose except for proceedings under this act Section 1175.1 et seq.
277470 of this title. No such statement, admission or confession may be
278471 used against such person in any criminal action whether pending at
472+
473+SB771 HFLR Page 10
474+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
475+2
476+3
477+4
478+5
479+6
480+7
481+8
482+9
483+10
484+11
485+12
486+13
487+14
488+15
489+16
490+17
491+18
492+19
493+20
494+21
495+22
496+23
497+24
498+
279499 the time the hearing is held or filed against such person at any
280500 later time, directly, indirectly or in any manner or form.
281-
282501 E. If the question of competency is submitted to a jury, the
283502 court shall instruct the jury as to the law regarding competency,
284503 and the findings they are to make. If the trial of the question is
285504 to the court, the court shall mak e the required findings.
286-
287505 SECTION 4. AMENDATORY 22 O.S. 2021, Section 1175.6b, i s
288506 amended to read as follows:
289-
290507 Section 1175.6b. A. If the person is found to be incompetent
291508 primarily because the person is intellectually disabled as defined
292509 in Section 1408 of Title 10 of the Oklahoma Statutes , and is also
293510 found by the court to be dang erous as defined by Section 1175.1 of
294511 this title, the court shall suspend the criminal proceedings , and
295512 shall place the person into the custody of the O ffice of Public
296513 Guardian. The Office of Public Guardian shall act with all powers
297514 set forth in the Oklah oma Public Guardianship Act, and:
298-
299515 1. The Office of Public Guardian shall place any person placed
300516 in its custody under this title in a facility or resi dential
301517 setting, private or public, willing to accept the individual and
302518 that has a level of supervision and security that is appropriate to
303519 the needs of the person;
304-
305520 2. Such placements shall be within the sole discretion of the
306521 Office of Public Guardian;
307522
523+SB771 HFLR Page 11
524+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
525+2
526+3
527+4
528+5
529+6
530+7
531+8
532+9
533+10
534+11
535+12
536+13
537+14
538+15
539+16
540+17
541+18
542+19
543+20
544+21
545+22
546+23
547+24
308548
309-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 8
310549 3. All such placements made by the Office of Public Guardian
311550 shall be made within six (6) months of the date of the order
312551 awarding custody to the Office of Public Guardian;
313-
314552 4. The Office of Public Guardian shall report to the court at
315553 least every six (6) months as to the status of the person including,
316554 but not limited to, the type of placement, services pr ovided, level
317555 of supervision, the medical and psychological health of the person,
318556 whether the person would be dangerous if conditionally released into
319557 a nonsecure environment, the assistance and services that would be
320558 required for such conditional release a nd whether the person has
321559 achieved competency;
322-
323560 5. If the person is determined by the Office of Public Guardian
324561 to have regained competency or that con ditional release to a private
325562 guardian or other caretaker is appropriate, a hearing shall be
326563 scheduled within twenty (20) days. If found competent by the court
327564 or a jury after such rehearing, criminal proceedings shall be
328565 resumed. If the court finds cond itional release to be appropriate,
329566 the court shall make an appropriate order for conditional release;
330567 and
331-
332568 6. The provisions of subsections C, H and I of Section 6 -101 of
333569 Title 30 of the Oklahoma Statutes shall not apply to custody orders
334570 arising under this title.
335-
336571 B. If the person is found to be incompetent for reasons other
337572 than the person is a person requ iring treatment as defined by
573+
574+SB771 HFLR Page 12
575+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
576+2
577+3
578+4
579+5
580+6
581+7
582+8
583+9
584+10
585+11
586+12
587+13
588+14
589+15
590+16
591+17
592+18
593+19
594+20
595+21
596+22
597+23
598+24
599+
338600 Section 1-103 of Title 43A of the Oklahoma Statutes and is found to
339601 be not dangerous as defined by Section 1175.1 of this title, the
340602 court shall suspend the criminal proceedings and either refer the
341603 person to the Department of Human Services for consideration of
342604 voluntary assistance or conditionally release the person as set
343605 forth in this section.
344-
345606 1. For any person recommend ed for conditional release, a
346607 written plan for services shall be prepared by the Department of
347608 Human Services and filed with the court. In its order of
348609 conditional release, the court shall specify the conditions of
349610 release and shall direct the appropriate agencies or persons to
350611 submit annual reports regarding the person ’s compliance with the
351612 conditions of release and progress:
352-
353-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 9
354-
355613 a. to be eligible for conditional release, the person
356614 shall agree, in writing, that during the period the
357615 person is granted conditi onal release and is subject
358616 to the provisions thereof, there shall be free
359617 transmission of all pertinent information, including
360618 clinical information regarding the person, among the
361619 person’s treatment providers, the appropriate district
362620 attorneys, law enfor cement and court personnel. To
363621 effect this agreement, the person shall execute any
364622 releases required by law to allow for the
365623 dissemination of this information,
366624
625+SB771 HFLR Page 13
626+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
627+2
628+3
629+4
630+5
631+6
632+7
633+8
634+9
635+10
636+11
637+12
638+13
639+14
640+15
641+16
642+17
643+18
644+19
645+20
646+21
647+22
648+23
649+24
650+
367651 b. the court’s order placing the person on conditional
368652 release shall include notice that the pe rson’s
369653 conditional release may be revoked upon good cause,
370-
371654 c. the district attorney, as well as any agen cy or
372655 individual involved in providing services with regard
373656 to the person’s conditional release, may prepare and
374657 file an affidavit under oath if the dis trict attorney,
375658 agency, or individual believes that the person has
376659 failed to comply with the conditions o f release. The
377660 court shall then conduct a hearing to determine if the
378661 person has violated the conditions of release. Notice
379662 of the hearing shall be i ssued, at least twenty -four
380663 (24) hours before the hearing, to the Department of
381664 Human Services, the pers on, trial counsel for the
382665 person, and the client advocate general of the
383666 Department of Human Services. After reviewing the
384667 evidence concerning any alle ged violation of the
385668 conditions of the release, the person ’s progress,
386669 treatment alternatives, and the ne ed for public
387670 safety, the court may order no change to the
388671 conditions for the person ’s release or modify the
389672 conditions of release, and
390673
674+SB771 HFLR Page 14
675+BOLD FACE denotes Committee Amendments. 1
676+2
677+3
678+4
679+5
680+6
681+7
682+8
683+9
684+10
685+11
686+12
687+13
688+14
689+15
690+16
691+17
692+18
693+19
694+20
695+21
696+22
697+23
698+24
699+
391700 d. the person placed on conditional release shall remain
392701 in a conditional release status until the reviewing
393702 court issues a full release from all conditions.
394-
395-
396-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 10
397703 2. If the person is determined by the Department of Human
398704 Services to have regained competency, a hearing shall be scheduled
399705 within twenty (20) days:
400-
401706 a. if found competent by the court or a jury after such
402707 rehearing, criminal proceedings shall be resumed,
403-
404708 b. if the person is found to continue to be incompetent,
405709 the person shall be returned to either conditional
406710 release or referred to the Department of Human
407711 Services for consideration of voluntary assistance.
408-
409712 C. The Office of Public Guardian shall have standing to
410713 participate in any proceeding held pursuant to this section as
411714 deemed necessary by the Office.
412-
413715 SECTION 5. This act shall become effective November 1, 2024.
414716
415-
416-ENR. S. B. NO. 771 Page 11
417-Passed the Senate the 5th day of March, 2024.
418-
419-
420-
421- Presiding Officer of the Senate
422-
423-
424-Passed the House of Representatives the 16th day of April, 2024.
425-
426-
427-
428- Presiding Officer of the House
429- of Representatives
430-
431-OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
432-Received by the Office of the Governor this _______ _____________
433-day of _________________ __, 20_______, at _______ o'clock _______ M.
434-By: _________________________________
435-Approved by the Governor of the State of Oklahom a this _________
436-day of _________________ __, 20_______, at _______ o'clock _______ M.
437-
438- _________________________________
439- Governor of the State of Oklahoma
440-
441-
442-OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY OF STATE
443-Received by the Office of the Secretary of State this _______ ___
444-day of _________________ _, 20 _______, at _______ o'clock _______ M.
445-By: _________________________________
717+COMMITTEE REPORT BY: COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY - CIVIL, dated
718+04/04/2024 - DO PASS.