Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania House Bill HB462

Introduced
3/16/23  

Caption

Providing for actions by law enforcement; and, in employees, providing for use of force recordkeeping and reporting for law enforcement agencies.

Impact

The implications of HB 462 are noteworthy as it directly affects the procedural framework under which police actions are conducted. The legislation mandates that law enforcement agencies must maintain comprehensive records of all incidents involving the use of force. This recordkeeping is intended to monitor incidences that could lead to serious injuries or fatalities, thus facilitating better oversight of police operations. By requiring annual reports on force incidents, HB 462 seeks to provide transparency and data-driven insights to regulators and the public, thereby promoting safety and responsibility in law enforcement practices.

Summary

House Bill 462 focuses on establishing stricter regulations surrounding the use of force by law enforcement agencies in Pennsylvania. It aims to amend the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes by introducing a new part dedicated to use of force, specifically prohibiting certain techniques such as chokeholds and prone restraints for extended periods. The bill outlines parameters under which law enforcement officers may operate, thus setting clearer expectations regarding acceptable practices when executing arrests. This act intends to enhance accountability within law enforcement and improve community trust.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 462 shows a range of support and opposition. Proponents, including many advocacy groups and some lawmakers, view the bill as a pivotal step towards necessary reforms in policing and a means to rebuild community trust in law enforcement. They argue that by limiting aggressive tactics and increasing transparency, the bill is aligned with contemporary standards for civil rights protections. Conversely, critics, including some law enforcement unions, have expressed concerns about the bill's potential impact on officer safety and its feasibility in real-life scenarios, arguing that certain restrictions may hinder their ability to perform their duties effectively.

Contention

One of the main points of contention lies in the balance between ensuring public safety and protecting the rights of individuals during law enforcement interactions. Detractors argue that the restrictions on the use of certain force techniques might endanger officers and hinder their defensive capabilities in volatile situations. Moreover, the requirement for extensive recordkeeping and reporting could impose a considerable administrative burden on smaller agencies and divert resources away from community policing efforts. Thus, while the legislation reflects a strong sentiment for reform, the implementation details and their repercussions present a complex landscape that continues to evoke debate among stakeholders.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA SB332

In employees, providing for use of force and deadly force policy for law enforcement agencies; and making an editorial change.

PA SB279

In employees, providing for use of force and deadly force policy for law enforcement agencies; imposing duties on the Municipal Police Officers' Education and Training Commission; and making an editorial change.

PA SB66

Providing for the adoption of a Statewide model policy related to the prevention of excessive force by law enforcement officers and school security personnel.

PA SB1212

In employees, providing for mandatory firearms training for certain law enforcement agencies.

PA SB46

Providing for adoption by the Attorney General of a Statewide model policy related to the prevention of excessive force by law enforcement officers and school security personnel.

PA HB1297

In employees, providing for ballistic armor for law enforcement officers.

PA HB1548

Providing for extent of cooperation between certain law enforcement agencies and Federal immigration authorities; prohibiting certain acts by law enforcement agencies and postsecondary institutions; and providing for policies limiting assistance with immigration enforcement.

PA SB838

Victim compensation: use of force by a law enforcement officer.

PA AB1709

Law enforcement: use of force.

PA SB299

Victim compensation: use of force by a law enforcement officer.

Similar Bills

PA HB157

In Pennsylvania PreferredĀ® Trademark, further providing for definitions, for Pennsylvania PreferredĀ® trademark, for licensee qualification, for duties and authority of department, for trademark license agreement, application and licensure process, for costs, for Pennsylvania PreferredĀ® Trademark Licensing Fund, for injunctive relief, for rules and regulations and for purpose, repealing provisions relating to definitions and further providing for qualified veterans and qualified veteran business entities.

PA SR108

Congratulating The Pennsylvania State University wrestling team on its 11th National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I Championship and Pennsylvania residents who competed and placed during the National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I Wrestling Championship.

PA HB179

Authorizing the provision or sale of Pennsylvania milk in Pennsylvania schools.

PA HB997

Authorizing the provision or sale of Pennsylvania milk in Pennsylvania schools.

PA SB297

Authorizing the provision or sale of Pennsylvania milk in Pennsylvania schools.

PA SB463

Authorizing the provision or sale of Pennsylvania milk in Pennsylvania schools.

PA HB2273

In licenses and regulations and liquor, alcohol and malt and brewed beverages, further providing for Pennsylvania Malt and Brewed Beverages Industry Promotion Board and for Pennsylvania Wine Marketing and Research Program Board; and, in distilleries, wineries, bonded warehouses, bailees for hire and transporters for hire, establishing the Pennsylvania Distilled Spirits Industry Promotion Board.

PA HB364

Providing for the Pennsylvania Amber Alert System for Abducted and Missing Persons, the Missing Endangered Person Advisory System (MEPAS) and the Green Alert System and for duties of the Pennsylvania State Police; assessing costs; providing for immunity and penalties; and making a repeal.