Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

Pennsylvania Senate Bill SB152

Introduced
1/19/23  
Refer
1/19/23  
Refer
6/5/23  
Report Pass
6/5/23  
Engrossed
6/6/23  
Refer
6/7/23  
Refer
10/30/23  
Report Pass
10/31/23  
Enrolled
11/1/23  
Chaptered
11/6/23  

Caption

Repealing the act of September 1, 1965 (P.L.420, No.215), known as The Frozen Dessert Law.

Impact

The repeal of the Frozen Dessert Law is expected to have considerable implications for the dairy industry within Pennsylvania. Proponents of the bill argue that removing these regulations can stimulate growth and innovation among local manufacturers, by reducing bureaucracy and enabling easier market entry. However, the possible consequence of deregulation may lead to health and safety concerns, as the uniform standards that previously safeguarded consumers against substandard products would be dismantled.

Summary

Senate Bill 152 proposes the repeal of the Frozen Dessert Law enacted on September 1, 1965. This legislation was originally intended to protect public health concerning the manufacture, sale, and distribution of frozen desserts, ensuring that products were hygienic and free from adulteration. The bill aims to eliminate the existing regulatory framework surrounding frozen desserts in Pennsylvania, which includes various stipulations concerning health standards, licensing requirements for manufacturers, and penalties for non-compliance. By repealing these regulations, the bill signals a shift in how frozen desserts may be marketed and produced in the state.

Sentiment

Discussions surrounding SB152 reveal a polarized sentiment toward its passage. Supporters of the repeal advocate for greater freedom in business operations, suggesting that the old law imposes unnecessary restrictions that could deter entrepreneurship. Conversely, critics express apprehension about the potential for increased risks to consumer health and confusion in the marketplace, fearing that without a governing law, the quality and safety of frozen dessert products could decline.

Contention

Central to the debate about SB152 is the balance between regulation and free enterprise. Advocates caution against potential negative health outcomes from unregulated products, while opponents cite the need for streamlined operations and fewer governmental obstacles. This contention highlights a broader conversation regarding the role of government in regulating industries that directly affect public health and consumer rights.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

PA HB953

Repealing the act of September 1, 1965 (P.L.420, No.215), known as The Frozen Dessert Law.

PA HB1086

LIQUOR-FROZEN DESSERTS

PA SB2085

LIQUOR-FROZEN DESSERTS

PA SB3570

LIQUOR-FROZEN DESSERTS

PA S348

"Packaged Ice Plant Operator and Packaged Ice Dealer Licensing Act."

PA S3404

Provides for licensure of packaged ice plant operators and packaged ice dealers.

PA A4988

Provides for licensure of packaged ice plant operators and packaged ice dealers.

PA H1279

Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services

PA HB1005

Repealing the act of July 13, 1953 (P.L.377, No.85), known as the Use and Storage Tax Act.

PA HB74

Repealing the act of July 13, 1953 (P.L.377, No.85), known as the Use and Storage Tax Act.

Similar Bills

CA SB1232

Solid waste: products: labeling: biodegradability.

CA AB954

Food labeling: quality and safety dates.

PA HB953

Repealing the act of September 1, 1965 (P.L.420, No.215), known as The Frozen Dessert Law.

VA HB837

Food and drink law; permitting requirements.

CA AB1201

Solid waste: products: labeling: compostability and biodegradability.

CA AB937

Plastic products: commercial agricultural mulch film: labeling: soil biodegradable.

MI SB0302

Trade: business regulation; agricultural equipment repair act; create. Creates new act.

CA AB2287

Solid waste.