Texas House Bill HB3118

Texas 2009 - 81st Regular

Caption

Relating to a study on the cost and benefits of undocumented immigrants to the state budget and economy.

Impact

If implemented, HB 3118 would require the comptroller to publish the findings of this study on an easily accessible website and distribute copies of the report to key political officials including the governor, lieutenant governor, and other relevant legislative committees. The study is expected to take into account multiple facets of state budgeting and may influence future legislation and policy decisions regarding immigration and funding allocations. By presenting a comprehensive analysis of the economic contributions and costs brought on by undocumented immigrants, the bill aims to shed light on an often contentious topic in Texas politics.

Summary

House Bill 3118 is an act that mandates a study conducted by the comptroller of public accounts regarding the economic implications of undocumented immigrants on the Texas state budget. The bill stipulates that this study should evaluate various factors including the costs and benefits associated with undocumented immigrants, specifically looking into their impacts on education, healthcare, incarceration rates, salaries, and revenue for both local and state governments. The goal of such assessment is to provide a clearer understanding of how undocumented immigrants affect the financial landscape of the state.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding HB 3118 may emerge from differing views on immigration itself. Supporters of the study may argue that evidence-based understanding fosters informed legislation that addresses public concerns about undocumented immigrants. On the other hand, critics may express concerns about resource allocation for such studies, questioning the intentions behind gathering this data in the context of current immigration debates. Additionally, the varying perceptions of undocumented immigrants' impacts on state budgets—either as economic burdens or contributors—could lead to significant political discussions during and after the study's publication.